These are my notes from Akilesh Ayyar’s book, How to Find What Isn’t Lost

Three Steps to Enlightenment

Actually all three of the steps are inseparable:

The Three Steps:

  1. Knowledge
  2. Quieting the mind
  3. Pursuit of the Self

Their Interactions:

  • Knowledge ↔ Quieting the mind: Knowledge quiets the mind, and a quiet mind absorbs knowledge better.
  • Knowledge ↔ Pursuit of the Self: Knowledge is required for the pursuit of the Self, but that pursuit also increases one’s knowledge.
  • Quieting the mind ↔ Pursuit of the Self: A quiet mind helps in the pursuit of the Self, and that pursuit quiets the mind.

Handling Negative Emotions and Desires

Don’t suppress or ignore intense desires and negative emotions. Listen to them, as they carry two key messages:

  1. Unmet Needs: Honest indicators of what we are lacking or ignoring.
  2. Inner Beauty: A unique perspective that should be channeled and fulfilled through artistic expression—a fundamental need on the spiritual path.

Analogies for the Relationship Between Self and Mind

To understand the relationship between the true Self (the witnessing awareness) and the mind (the experienced reality), several modern and classic analogies can be helpful:

  • Life as a Dream: Just as the dreamer creates and experiences an entire world that vanishes upon waking, the mind projects reality within the infinite space of the Self.
  • Life as The Matrix: The mind is a simulated reality we mistakenly believe is absolute truth, while the Self is what exists outside the illusion.
  • Life as The Truman Show: We are deeply immersed in an orchestrated drama, mistaking the set (the mind) for the real world (the Self) until we begin to notice the edges of the illusion.
  • Life as a Novel: The Self is the author/reader, while the mind is the unfolding plot and characters; the author observes the drama without being harmed by it.
  • Life as a Movie: The Self is the screen on which the movie (the mind’s projections) is playing. The screen allows the movie to happen but remains untainted by the fire or water shown in the film.
  • Life as Theater: The Self is the audience or the stage itself, silently observing the actors (thoughts and experiences) performing their roles.
  • Life as a Video Game: The Self is the player holding the controller, while the mind is the avatar inside the game world. The player experiences the avatar’s journey without actually being the avatar.

Experience as Art

The cosmic mind acts as an artist, continuously assembling raw sensory data into seamless, entirely unique moments of experience. This creative process is not governed by conventional human notions of “good” or “bad”—just as a screenwriter can write tragedy for a good character without it being “evil.” Instead, the cosmic intelligence is guided by the value of beauty, stringing together these unique moments to form a coherent, individual perspective that transcends our everyday judgments of good and evil.

Metaphorization and Decoding Desire

The cosmic intelligence structures our experiences to define “what it is like” to be us. Since we can only describe “what it is like” by comparing it to other things, this expression inherently relies on metaphor. Metaphorization is the artistic process of attempting to express these experiences as closely as possible. By examining and conveying our experiences in this way, we decode the specific messages the cosmic intelligence has designed for us to appreciate. Most importantly, this process of metaphorization is how we learn what we truly desire.

The NEEM Method

A recommended framework for this process of metaphorization is NEEM:

  1. Notice your Experience
  2. Express it in Metaphor

1. Notice your Experience

Pause and observe what you are currently undergoing across different dimensions:

  • Feelings and thoughts
  • Sensory inputs (seeing, hearing, touching, smelling, tasting)
  • Memories, expectations, and imagination

2. Express it in Metaphor

Choose something interesting from that experience and convey “what it feels like” by comparing it to something else:

  • Be Specific & Original: Avoid clichés. If anger feels like a landscape, what does it look like? If pain feels like a hammer, what kind of hammer?
  • Use Any Medium: You can use words, music, painting, or any art form. You don’t have to be “good” at art, as no one else needs to see it.
  • Capture the Essence: Don’t try to record every detail like a camera. Focus on capturing the overall impression, sense, and feel.
  • Start Simple if Needed: You can start with basic descriptors (“I am irritated” or “it is round”) and gradually build towards richer metaphors.
  • Flexible Scope: You can focus on an experience spanning a single minute or an entire lifetime.
  • The Ultimate Goal: Convey the feeling so vividly that an audience would feel exactly what you feel.

Meaning and Messages

Questioning the “meaning of life” or specific struggles often stems from a deep desire for self-expression. By metaphorizing your doubts, fears, and desires, you satisfy this thirst and quiet the mind’s restless search, allowing you to effectively pursue the Self.

Additionally, the cosmic intelligence (the Self) uses experiences to send you messages. Turning an experience into art decodes its message and can instantly cure pain or fixations. If pain persists (like in severe trauma), it holds a complex message requiring multiple expressive attempts to fully comprehend your past and find relief.

The Science of Desire

The “science of desire” is an iterative process of hypothesis and testing to uncover what you truly want. It combines two approaches with metaphorization (NEEM):

  1. Envisioning Scenarios: Imagine a potential choice (like a new job) in detail. Use NEEM to process your feelings about it. If it feels right, pursue it. If you feel conflicted, use the insights from NEEM to envision a new, better-suited scenario.
  2. Real-World Testing: Try things out in reality (e.g., visit the city where the job is). Monitor and metaphorize your feelings during the experience.

As you get clearer on your desires and pursue them, your mind naturally quiets. If you ever feel resistance toward a desire you’ve identified, that resistance is simply another desire asking for a voice. Metaphorize the resistance to understand it, and then envision new scenarios that accommodate all your values. You cannot—and should not—fight your true desires. Aligning with them quiets the mind and paves the way to enlightenment.

Decoding Negative Emotions

Negative emotions are often encoded with judgments and indicate complex, hidden desires. Always treat these emotions as messages. By using metaphorization to unpack them, they often naturally transform just by being expressed, though sometimes real-world action is also required. Zooming out to touch the Self provides a spiritual perspective that complements this decoding.

Willpower and Conflicting Desires

“Willpower” is simply the natural stamina that arises when what you think you want aligns with what you actually want. If you dig deep enough, your ultimate desire is always for the eternal Self.

Conflicting desires only seem to conflict; each holds a piece of a greater message. By metaphorizing both sides, you uncover underlying needs and discover a higher, third possibility. All inner conflicts can be resolved, and the pursuit of the Self acts as a backstop providing final peace.

Your Personal Oracle

Together, metaphorization and the science of desire act as a personal oracle. When facing a decision, ask yourself a question, observe the arising emotions, and metaphorize them.

This cycle—metaphorize, test actions, and metaphorize again—clarifies your desires and next steps. Even uncertainty is a message to be decoded. By continually asking questions and expressing feelings, you commune with a higher power, quietly preparing your mind to recognize the Self.

Other Key Methods

While metaphorization and the science of desire are powerful, two other methods are highly recommended for resolving desires and quieting the mind:

  1. Psychoanalytic Therapy: Developed by Freud and his successors, this specific kind of therapy helps uncover unconscious childhood conflicts so they no longer mechanically control you. Metaphorization is powerful, but you cannot always see your own blind spots. A supportive, nonjudgmental therapist can help these conflicts manifest and be resolved. (Note: Finding the right therapist can take a few tries; trust your sense of rapport).
  2. Silence: A traditional spiritual technique where you simply sit with a conflict or confusing emotion. By watching it in silence—without getting drawn in or judging it—clarity will often arise spontaneously. While very useful, it shouldn’t be your only tool.

Ultimately, these techniques are all compatible. Psychoanalytic therapy, silence, metaphorization, and the science of desire reinforce each other, growing in power when used together to help you clarify what you want and find peace.

Self-Inquiry and Surrender

The pursuit of the Self is inherently paradoxical: you cannot truly “pursue” what you already are. As a seeker, you must undertake the search only to eventually discover that you never needed to search at all.

This pursuit boils down to two intertwined methods: self-inquiry and surrender. Both are specialized forms of meditation.

To understand them, look at the two broad categories of traditional meditation:

  1. Concentration Meditation: Focusing the mind on a single point (like a mantra or image) to soothe and clear it.
  2. Mindfulness Meditation: Observing the mind without judgment and maintaining your status as the “watcher,” which helps you detach by showing you that you are not your thoughts.

While normal meditation practices quiet the mind temporarily, they do not permanently remove mental pain. Mental suffering is rooted in the fundamental ignorance of our real identity—the false belief that we are merely a person. Self-inquiry and surrender are advanced, specialized versions of meditation designed specifically to cut this ignorance at its root.

Self-Inquiry

The premise of self-inquiry is that the sense of “I am” is essentially a hallucination or trick of the mind; question it correctly, and it disappears.

The goal is to take the unmistakable, ever-present feeling of “I” (the “I” that is reading these words, sitting, or thinking) and trace it to its source, just as you would trace a sound to your ears or a pinprick to your skin.

To do this, apply one fundamental rule: You cannot be what you notice.

  • If you feel the “I” is a sensation located in your head, you are noticing that sensation. Therefore, you are the watcher, not the sensation.
  • If you think the “I” is a specific image or thought, you are aware of that image. Therefore, you cannot be the image.

Hold tightly to the clear sensation of “I am,” and try to locate where it comes from. Every time you think you’ve found it, test it by asking: “Am I noticing this?” If the answer is yes, keep searching patiently.

Crucially, this is not an intellectual exercise—reading texts can build faith, but self-inquiry is purely experiential. You must simply hold and focus on the feeling of the “I”. If your mind goes peacefully blank, do not just rest in the stillness. Ask yourself: “To whom does this stillness occur?” The answer is “I am experiencing it,” so hold onto that “I.” Start with 10 minutes a day, but aim to eventually do it constantly during all waking activities.

If you practice this in earnest, your concentration will naturally still your mind. But if you stubbornly hold onto the “I” experiencing that stillness and continue trying to localize it, the “I am” feeling will suddenly and unmistakably vanish.

The Spacious Mind

When the “I am” feeling vanishes, it is replaced by what Ayyar calls the spacious mind—a profound sense of vastness and peace.

  • You still have awareness, but without the usual “I am” identification.
  • You may feel that your individual self is actually the entire world, or you might observe your old self as if it were a third person.
  • It is identical to a state of flow (effortless, optimal performance) where you no longer feel like the “doer” of your actions. The burden of doing is entirely lifted.

Because of habitual thought patterns, you will inevitably fall out of the spacious mind almost as soon as you enter it. When you do, immediately begin self-inquiry again. Over time, it will take less and less effort to return to this state, until you can reach it almost instantly.

With practice, you can and should maintain this inquiry constantly, even while working or walking. The fear that it will interfere with your daily tasks is just a misconception of the small, doing-self.

Surrender

Eventually, the constant effort required for self-inquiry may become frustrating and tedious. This is where surrender becomes incredibly valuable.

The sense of “I am” and the sense of being the “doer” are the exact same false sensation. You are not actually a person who chooses to act or not act; you are simply the quiet space in which all these occurrences happen. While you cannot force yourself to feel this truth, you can align with it by surrendering.

When you feel the desire to stop self-inquiry, simply let go. Allow everything to happen exactly as it does.

  • Drop the habit of worrying about the past or future.
  • If thoughts occur, let them pass without engaging them.
  • Allow positive and negative emotions to arise without commenting on them.
  • Give up all aims. Allow action and inaction to happen spontaneously (this doesn’t mean deliberately lying in bed doing nothing, it means acting without a sense of personal aim).

This is still a practice—the “seeker’s surrender”—and it requires the effort of not grasping at anything. You are putting effort into relaxing and remaining uninvolved in your thoughts.

If you slip up by worrying, exerting effort, or deliberately thinking, do not compound the error by scolding yourself. Just let it go. By pretending you are already “at home” and mimicking the ultimate state of affairs, surrender will eventually lead you straight into the spacious mind, just as self-inquiry does.

The Realization

As you practice self-inquiry and surrender, your mind will grow quieter, and you will spend increasing amounts of time in the spacious mind. You will experience many temporary glimpses of the Truth—seeing clearly that what you thought was “yourself” is merely an image.

Eventually, this realization will strike with the permanent force of total clarity. You will unmistakably recognize the Self: the unthinkable, unsayable “dial tone” running beneath and through everything.

  • You will realize it is beyond opposites: you are the Self, but you also are not it (because there is no “you”).
  • You will understand that you cannot see it directly because you are it—it is that which knows itself by itself.
  • You will grasp the ultimate paradox: there is no one left to say “I am” or “I realize.” There was never a seeker, no quest, and no enlightenment.

Importantly, this realization does not require fireworks, ecstasy, or out-of-body experiences. Those are just experiences that come and go. The Self is precisely that which never comes and goes; it is eternal and unbroken.

The Self is the ultimate knower. It knows the entire world, it knows the mind, and it even knows the mind’s ignorance. When the mind finally realizes its own shallowness, that ignorance vanishes. The false identification with the “I” becomes just another passing thought, and the belief that the mind is real disappears.

Realization is simply the realization that the seeker never existed.

Conclusion

The Spiritual Game

Ultimately, the cosmic mind is playing a game with us, with the spiritual quest being the most important game of all. Like any game, progress relies on understanding the other player’s moves. Metaphorization is our way of communicating back. Through methods like NEEM, we decode these moves, discover what we truly desire, and learn to appreciate the hidden beauty in our unique way of seeing the world.

After Realization

You might assume the journey ends once the Self is recognized, but it does not. However, you will immediately understand why the Self is called the source of absolute peace and joy. From here, two great tasks remain:

  1. Penetrating the Mental System: The illusion of the mind persists even after it is no longer taken to be real (just as you know the Earth revolves around the Sun, yet you still see the Sun “rise”). Old mental habits will still run around, but they are now “defanged.” Over the rest of your life, this knowledge will deeply permeate your system, allowing your personality to bloom into a state of permanent stillness.
  2. Exploring the Mysteries of Life: The discovery of the Self does not void the mysteries of philosophy, art, literature, or science. Duality and non-duality co-exist, just as a movie and the screen it plays on co-exist. The mind continues to explore these mysteries—only now, you no longer identify with it.

The ego functions only in a formal, “burnt” way. You will continue to experience life in all its vibrant complexity, but no matter what happens—even amid seeming anger, pain, or misfortune—you will always be at home in the Self.