Section IX: Yajnavalkya and Vidagdha Sakalya
Brihadaranyaka Upanishad, Chapter III, Section IX (Śākalya Brāhmaṇa)
This section records the dramatic debate between Sage Yājñavalkya and Vidagdha, the son of Śakala (Śākalya), in the assembly of King Janaka.
The preceding sections established Brahman as the innermost ruler (Antaryāmin) pervading all elements. Here, Śākalya questions Yājñavalkya regarding the exact number and identity of the gods. Yājñavalkya progressively reduces the gods from 3,306 down to 33, 6, 3, 2, 1½, and finally to One—the cosmic vital principle (Prāṇa / Hiraṇyagarbha), which is Brahman.
When Śākalya persists in challenging Yājñavalkya on the eight forms of the Puruṣa and the directions, Yājñavalkya turns the tables and demands knowledge of the supreme transcendent Puruṣa known only through the Upaniṣads (Aupaniṣada Puruṣa, described via Neti Neti). Unable to answer, Śākalya suffers the curse of losing his head. Yājñavalkya then addresses the silent assembly with the profound parable of Man and the Tree, culminating in the declaration: Vijñānam Ānandaṃ Brahma (“Brahman is Knowledge and Bliss Absolute”).
Summary Tables of the Gods
1. The Contraction and Expansion of the Gods (Verses 3.9.1–3.9.9)
| Number of Gods | Identity / Classification | Philosophical & Cosmological Basis |
|---|---|---|
| 3,306 (303 + 3,003) | The Viśvadevas indicated in the Nivid hymn | Diverse cosmic manifestations (mahimānaḥ) of the thirty-three gods. |
| 33 | 8 Vasus + 11 Rudras + 12 Ādityas + Indra + Prajāpati | The primary cosmic and physiological governing principles of Vedic cosmology. |
| 6 | Fire (Agni), Earth (Pṛthivī), Air (Vāyu), Sky (Antarikṣa), Sun (Āditya), Heaven (Dyauḥ) | The basic cosmic spheres containing all the thirty-three gods (excluding moon and stars). |
| 3 | The Three Worlds (Triloka): • Earth + Fire • Sky + Air • Heaven + Sun | All the gods are comprised within the terrestrial, atmospheric, and celestial planes. |
| 2 | Matter (Anna / Food) and Vital Force (Prāṇa) | The fundamental duality of sustenance and life energy animating all existence. |
| 1½ (Adhyardha) | The Air that blows (Vāyu) | Though one, all beings grow and attain surpassing glory (adhyārdhnot) in its presence. |
| 1 | The Cosmic Vital Force (Prāṇa / Hiraṇyagarbha) | The ultimate source and unity of all divine forces; Brahman called Tyat (“That”). |
2. The Thirty-Three Gods (Trayastriṃśad Devāḥ) (Verses 3.9.2–3.9.6)
| Group | Count | Members / Constituents | Etymology & Reason for Name |
|---|---|---|---|
| Vasus (वसवः) | 8 | Fire (Agni), Earth (Pṛthivī), Air (Vāyu), Sky (Antarikṣa), Sun (Āditya), Heaven (Dyauḥ), Moon (Candramas), Stars (Nakṣatrāṇi) | From root vas (“to dwell/support”). All this phenomenal world is placed (hitam) in them, and they help every being to live. |
| Rudras (रुद्राः) | 11 | The 10 physiological organs (5 sensory + 5 motor) in the human body, with the Mind (Manas / Ātman) as the eleventh | From root rud (“to weep”). When they depart from this mortal body at death, they cause surviving relatives to weep (rodayanti). |
| Ādityas (आदित्याः) | 12 | The twelve months of the solar year | From root ā-dā (“to take away”). As they rotate, they take away the life-span of mortals and the fruits of work. |
| Indra (इन्द्रः) | 1 | The Cloud (Stanayitnu), representing Thunder / Vigour / Strength (Aśani) | Cosmic power and strength that subdues and rules all forces. |
| Prajāpati (प्रजापतिः) | 1 | The Sacrifice (Yajña), represented by the Animals (Paśavaḥ) | The cosmic order of creation and offering; sacrifice has no independent form except through its means (animals/offerings). |
3. The Eight Forms of the Puruṣa (Aṣṭau Puruṣāḥ) (Verses 3.9.10–3.9.17)
| # | Abode (Āyatana) | Instrument of Vision (Loka) | Light (Manojyotiḥ) | Special Manifestation (Puruṣa) | Presiding Deity / Cause (Devatā) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 (3.9.10) | Earth (Pṛthivī) | Fire (Agni) | Mind (Manas) | The Person in the physical body (Śārīra Puruṣa) | Nectar / Chyle (Amṛta — essence of food producing blood) |
| 2 (3.9.11) | Desire / Lust (Kāma) | Heart / Intellect (Hṛdaya) | Mind (Manas) | The Person identified with desire (Kāmamaya Puruṣa) | Women (Striyaḥ — the object/inflamer of desire) |
| 3 (3.9.12) | Colours / Forms (Rūpāṇi) | Eye (Cakṣus) | Mind (Manas) | The Person in the Sun (Āditye Puruṣa) | Truth / The Eye (Satyam) |
| 4 (3.9.13) | Ether / Space (Ākāśa) | Ear (Śrotra) | Mind (Manas) | The Person of the ear/hearing (Śrautra Puruṣa) | The Quarters / Directions (Diśaḥ) |
| 5 (3.9.14) | Darkness (Tamas) | Heart / Intellect (Hṛdaya) | Mind (Manas) | The Person of shadow / ignorance (Chāyāmaya Puruṣa) | Death (Mṛtyu) |
| 6 (3.9.15) | Reflecting Colours (Rūpāṇi) | Eye (Cakṣus) | Mind (Manas) | The Person in the mirror (Ādarśe Puruṣa) | Vital Force / Breath (Asu / Prāṇa) |
| 7 (3.9.16) | Water (Āpaḥ) | Heart / Intellect (Hṛdaya) | Mind (Manas) | The Person in water (Apsu Puruṣa) | Varuṇa (Rain / source of water) |
| 8 (3.9.17) | Seed (Retas) | Heart / Intellect (Hṛdaya) | Mind (Manas) | The Person identified with the son (Putramaya Puruṣa) | Prajāpati (The Father / progenitor) |
4. The Five Directions and their Foundations in the Heart (Verses 3.9.20–3.9.24)
| Direction (Diś) | Presiding Deity (Devatā) | Primary Support | Secondary Support | Tertiary Support | Ultimate Ground |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| East (Prācī) | Sun (Āditya) | Eye (Cakṣus) | Colours / Forms (Rūpāṇi) | — | Heart / Mind (Hṛdaya) |
| South (Dakṣiṇā) | Yama (God of Justice) | Sacrifice (Yajña) | Remuneration (Dakṣiṇā) | Faith (Śraddhā) | Heart / Mind (Hṛdaya) |
| West (Pratīcī) | Varuṇa (God of Waters) | Water (Āpaḥ) | Seed (Retas) | — | Heart / Mind (Hṛdaya) |
| North (Udīcī) | Soma (Moon & Divine Plant) | Initiation (Dīkṣā) | Truth (Satya) | — | Heart / Mind (Hṛdaya) |
| Zenith / Fixed (Dhruvā) | Fire (Agni) | Speech (Vāc) | — | — | Heart / Mind (Hṛdaya) |
5. Parable of Man and the Tree (Verse 3.9.28)
| Part of Tree (Vanaspati) | Corresponding Part of Man (Puruṣa) | Spiritual Significance |
|---|---|---|
| Leaves (Parṇāni) | Hair (Lomāni) | The outer foliage/covering. |
| Outer Bark (Utpāṭikā bahiḥ) | Skin (Tvac) | The external boundary. |
| Sap (Rasa) | Blood (Rudhira) | The life-fluid flowing when injured. |
| Inner Bark (Śakarāṇi) | Flesh (Māṃsa) | The substantial layer beneath the outer covering. |
| Innermost Fiber (Kināṭa / Snāva) | Sinews (Snāyu) | The tough, stabilizing binding tissue. |
| Wood (Dāru) | Bones (Asthi) | The inner skeletal framework. |
| Pith (Majjā) | Marrow (Majjā) | The innermost core substance. |
| Root of Renascence | Brahman (Vijñānam Ānandaṃ Brahma) | When a felled tree resprouts from its root or seed, what root causes a mortal to be reborn after death? The eternal root is Knowledge, Bliss, Brahman. |
Verses, Transliterations, Translations, and Commentary
Part I: The Number and Nature of the Gods (Verses 3.9.1–3.9.9)
Verse 3.9.1: The Progressive Reduction of the Gods
Sanskrit Verse
अथ हैनं विदग्धः शाकल्यः पप्रच्छ, कति देवा याज्ञवल्क्येति; स हैतयैव निविदा प्रतिपेदे, यावन्तो वैश्वदेवस्य निविद्युच्यन्ते—त्रयश्च त्री च शता, त्रयश्च त्री च सहस्रेति; ओमिति होवाच, कत्येव देवा याज्ञवल्क्येति; त्रयस्त्रिंशदिति; ओमिति होवाच; कत्येव देवा याज्ञवल्क्येति; षडित्य्; ओमिति होवाच, कत्येव देवा याज्ञवल्क्येति; त्रय इति; ओमिति होवाच, कत्येव देवा याज्ञवल्क्येति; द्वाविति; ओमिति होवाच, कत्येव देवा याज्ञवल्क्येति; अध्यर्ध इति; ओमिति होवाच, कत्येव देवा याज्ञवल्क्येति; एक इति; ओमिति होवाच, कतमे ते त्रयश्च त्री च शता, त्रयश्च त्री च सहस्रेति ॥ १ ॥
Transliteration
atha hainaṃ vidagdhaḥ śākalyaḥ papraccha, kati devā yājñavalkyeti; sa haitayaiva nividā pratipede, yāvanto vaiśvadevasya nividyucyante—trayaśca trī ca śatā, trayaśca trī ca sahasreti; omiti hovāca, katyeva devā yājñavalkyeti; trayastriṃśaditi; omiti hovāca; katyeva devā yājñavalkyeti; ṣaḍity; omiti hovāca, katyeva devā yājñavalkyeti; traya iti; omiti hovāca, katyeva devā yājñavalkyeti; dvāviti; omiti hovāca, katyeva devā yājñavalkyeti; adhyardha iti; omiti hovāca, katyeva devā yājñavalkyeti; eka iti; omiti hovāca, katame te trayaśca trī ca śatā, trayaśca trī ca sahasreti || 1 ||
Translation
Then Vidagdha, the son of Śakala, asked him: “How many gods are there, Yājñavalkya?” Yājñavalkya decided it through this (group of Mantras known as) Nivid (saying): “As many as are indicated in the Nivid of the Viśvadevas—three hundred and three, and three thousand and three.”
“Very well,” said Śākalya, “how many gods are there, Yājñavalkya?"
"Thirty-three."
"Very well,” said the other, “how many gods are there, Yājñavalkya?"
"Six."
"Very well,” said Śākalya, “how many gods are there, Yājñavalkya?"
"Three."
"Very well,” said the other, “how many gods are there, Yājñavalkya?"
"Two."
"Very well,” said Śākalya, “how many gods are there, Yājñavalkya?"
"One and a half."
"Very well,” said the other, “how many gods are there, Yājñavalkya?"
"One.”“Very well,” said Śākalya, “which are those three hundred and three and three thousand and three?”
Commentary Summary:
A Nivid is an ancient liturgical formula or inserted hymn listing divine invocations in Vedic rituals. Yājñavalkya begins from the grandest liturgical count (3,306), and upon repeated questioning, steadily contracts the pantheon into smaller categories until reaching the single non-dual ground.
Verse 3.9.2: The Thirty-Three Gods
Sanskrit Verse
स होवाच, महिमान एवैषामेते, त्रयस्त्रिंशत्त्वेव देवा इति; कतमे ते त्रयस्त्रिंशदिति; अष्टौ वसवः, एकादश रुद्राः, द्वादशादित्याः, ते एकत्रिंशत्, इन्द्रश्चैव प्रजापतिश्च त्रयस्त्रिंशाविति ॥ २ ॥
Transliteration
sa hovāca, mahimāna evaiṣāmete, trayastriṃśattveva devā iti; katame te trayastriṃśaditi; aṣṭau vasavaḥ, ekādaśa rudrāḥ, dvādaśādityāḥ, te ekatriṃśat, indraścaiva prajāpatiśca trayastriṃśāviti || 2 ||
Translation
Yājñavalkya said: “These are but the manifestations (mahimānaḥ) of them, but there are only thirty-three gods."
"Which are those thirty-three?"
"The eight Vasus, the eleven Rudras, and the twelve Ādityas—these are thirty-one, and Indra and Prajāpati make up the thirty-three.”
Verse 3.9.3: The Eight Vasus
Sanskrit Verse
कतमे वसव इति; अग्निश्च पृथिवी च वायुश्चान्तरिक्शं चादित्यश्च द्यौश्च चन्द्रमाश्च नक्शत्राणि चैते वसवः; एतेषु हीदं वसु सर्वं हितमिति तस्माद्वसव इति ॥ ३ ॥
Transliteration
katame vasava iti; agniśca pṛthivī ca vāyuścāntarikśaṃ cādityaśca dyauśca candramāśca nakśatrāṇi caite vasavaḥ; eteṣu hīdaṃ vasu sarvaṃ hitamiti tasmādvasava iti || 3 ||
Translation
“Which are the Vasus?"
"Fire, the earth, the air, the sky, the sun, heaven, the moon, and the stars—these are the Vasus, for in these all this is placed; therefore they are called Vasus.”
Commentary Summary:
Transforming themselves into the bodies and organs of all beings, as well as into their dwelling-places, these cosmic entities provide the physical support for existence and enable all beings to live (vasanti / vāsayanti).
Verse 3.9.4: The Eleven Rudras
Sanskrit Verse
कतमे रुद्रा इति; दशेमे पुरुषे प्राणा आत्मैकादशः; ते यदास्माच्छरीरान्मर्त्यादुत्क्रामन्त्यथ रोदयन्ति; तद्यद्रोदयन्ति तस्माद्रुद्रा इति ॥ ४ ॥
Transliteration
katame rudrā iti; daśeme puruṣe prāṇā ātmaikādaśaḥ; te yadāsmāccharīrānmartyādutkrāmantyatha rodayanti; tadyadrodayanti tasmādrudrā iti || 4 ||
Translation
“Which are the Rudras?"
"The ten organs in the human body, with the mind (ātman) as the eleventh. When they depart from this mortal body, they make (one’s relatives) weep. Because they then make them weep, therefore they are called Rudras.”
Commentary Summary:
The ten organs comprise the five sensory organs (jñānendriyas) and five motor organs (karmendriyas), with the eleventh being the inner organ/mind (manas). When life ends and these faculties withdraw, the grief of departure causes weeping (rud).
Verse 3.9.5: The Twelve Ādityas
Sanskrit Verse
कतम आदित्या इति । द्वादश वै मासाः संवत्सरस्य, एत आदित्याः, एते हीदं सर्वमाददाना यन्ति; ते यदिदं सर्वमाददाना यन्ति तस्मादादित्या इति ॥ ५ ॥
Transliteration
katama ādityā iti | dvādaśa vai māsāḥ saṃvatsarasya, eta ādityāḥ, ete hīdaṃ sarvamādadānā yanti; te yadidaṃ sarvamādadānā yanti tasmādādityā iti || 5 ||
Translation
“Which are the Ādityas?"
"The twelve months of a year; these are the Ādityas, for they go taking all this with them. Because they go taking all this with them, therefore they are called Ādityas.”
Commentary Summary:
The passing months inexorably carry away (ā-dā) human longevity and the fruits of actions as time marches forward.
Verse 3.9.6: Indra and Prajāpati
Sanskrit Verse
कतम इन्द्रः, कतमः प्रजापतिरिति; स्तनयित्नुरेवेन्द्रः, यज्ञः प्रजापतिरिति; कतमः स्तनयित्नुरिति; अशनिरिति; कतमो यज्ञ इति; पशव इति ॥ ६ ॥
Transliteration
katama indraḥ, katamaḥ prajāpatiriti; stanayitnurevendraḥ, yajñaḥ prajāpatiriti; katamaḥ stanayitnuriti; aśaniriti; katamo yajña iti; paśava iti || 6 ||
Translation
“Which is Indra, and which is Prajāpati?"
"The cloud is Indra, and the sacrifice is Prajāpati."
"Which is the cloud?"
"Thunder (strength/vigour)."
"Which is the sacrifice?"
"Animals.”
Verse 3.9.7: The Six Gods
Sanskrit Verse
कतमे षडित्य्; अग्निश्च पृथिवी च वायुश्चान्तरिक्शं चादित्यश्च द्यौश्चैते षड्, एते हीदं सर्वं षडिति ॥ ७ ॥
Transliteration
katame ṣaḍity; agniśca pṛthivī ca vāyuścāntarikśaṃ cādityaśca dyauścaite ṣaḍ, ete hīdaṃ sarvaṃ ṣaḍiti || 7 ||
Translation
“Which are the six (gods)?"
"Fire, the earth, the air, the sky, the sun, and heaven—these are the six. Because all those (gods) are comprised in these six.”
Verse 3.9.8: The Three, Two, and One-and-a-Half Gods
Sanskrit Verse
कतमे ते त्रयो देवा इति; इम एव त्रयो लोकाः, एषु हीमे सर्वे देवा इति; कतमौ तौ द्वौ देवाविति; अन्नं चैव प्राणश्चेति; कतमो’ध्यर्ध इति; यो’यं पवत इति ॥ ८ ॥
Transliteration
katame te trayo devā iti; ima eva trayo lokāḥ, eṣu hīme sarve devā iti; katamau tau dvau devāviti; annaṃ caiva prāṇaśceti; katamo’dhyardha iti; yo’yaṃ pavata iti || 8 ||
Translation
“Which are the three gods?"
"These three worlds, because in these all those gods are comprised."
"Which are the two gods?"
"Matter (anna / food) and the vital force (prāṇa)."
"Which is the one and a half?"
"This (air) that blows.”
Verse 3.9.9: The One God: Prāṇa and Brahman
Sanskrit Verse
तदाहुः, यदयमेक इवैव पवते, अथ कथमध्यर्ध इति; यदस्मिन्निदं सर्वमध्यार्ध्नोत्, तेनाध्यर्ध इति; कतम एको देव इति; प्राण इति स ब्रह्म त्यदित्याचक्शते ॥ ९ ॥
Transliteration
tadāhuḥ, yadayameka ivaiva pavate, atha kathamadhyardha iti; yadasminnidaṃ sarvamadhyārdhnot, tenādhyardha iti; katama eko deva iti; prāṇa iti sa brahma tyadityācakśate || 9 ||
Translation
“Regarding this some say: ‘Since the air blows as one substance, how can it be one and a half?’ It is one and a half because through its presence all this attains surpassing glory (adhyārdhnot)."
"Which is the one god?"
"The vital force (Prāṇa / Hiraṇyagarbha); it is Brahman, which is called Tyat (‘That’).”
Commentary Summary:
Thus, all diverse and intermediate counts of deities resolve into the single vital force (Prāṇa), which expands into the infinite varieties of names, forms, and cosmic activities.
Part II: The Eight Forms of the Person (Aṣṭau Puruṣāḥ) (Verses 3.9.10–3.9.17)
Śākalya now challenges Yājñavalkya to identify the eight specific manifestations of the Puruṣa, their abodes, lights, instruments of vision, and deities.
Verse 3.9.10: The Person Identified with the Body
Sanskrit Verse
पृथिव्येव यस्यायतनम्, अग्निर्लोकः, मनोज्योतिः, यो वै तं पुरुषं विद्यात्सर्वस्यात्मनः परायणम्, स वै वेदिता स्याद्याज्ञवल्क्य । वेद वा अहं तं पुरुषं सर्वस्यात्मनः परायणं यमात्थ; य एवायं शारीरः पुरुषः स एष, वदैव शाकल्य; तस्य का देवतेति; अमृतमिति होवाच ॥ १० ॥
Transliteration
pṛthivyeva yasyāyatanam, agnirlokaḥ, manojyotiḥ, yo vai taṃ puruṣaṃ vidyātsarvasyātmanaḥ parāyaṇam, sa vai veditā syādyājñavalkya | veda vā ahaṃ taṃ puruṣaṃ sarvasyātmanaḥ parāyaṇaṃ yamāttha; ya evāyaṃ śārīraḥ puruṣaḥ sa eṣa, vadaiva śākalya; tasya kā devateti; amṛtamiti hovāca || 10 ||
Translation
“He who knows that being whose abode is the earth, whose instrument of vision is fire, whose light is the Manas, and who is the ultimate resort of the entire body and organs, knows truly, O Yājñavalkya."
"I know that being of whom you speak—who is the ultimate resort of the entire body and organs. It is the being who is identified with the body (Śārīra Puruṣa). Go on, Śākalya."
"Who is his deity (cause)?"
"Nectar (Amṛta / chyle),” said he.
Verse 3.9.11: The Person Identified with Lust
Sanskrit Verse
काम एव यस्यायतनम्, हृदयं लोकः, मनोज्योतिः, यो वै तं पुरुषं विद्यात्सर्वस्यात्मनः परायणम्, स वै वेदिता स्याद्याज्ञवल्क्य । वेद वा अहं तं पुरुषं सर्वस्यात्मनः परायणं यमात्थ; य एवायं काममयः पुरुषः स एषः, वदैव शाकल्य; तस्य का देवतेति; स्त्रिय इति होवाच ॥ ११ ॥
Transliteration
kāma eva yasyāyatanam, hṛdayaṃ lokaḥ, manojyotiḥ, yo vai taṃ puruṣaṃ vidyātsarvasyātmanaḥ parāyaṇam, sa vai veditā syādyājñavalkya | veda vā ahaṃ taṃ puruṣaṃ sarvasyātmanaḥ parāyaṇaṃ yamāttha; ya evāyaṃ kāmamayaḥ puruṣaḥ sa eṣaḥ, vadaiva śākalya; tasya kā devateti; striya iti hovāca || 11 ||
Translation
“He who knows that being whose abode is lust, whose instrument of vision is the intellect, whose light is the Manas, and who is the ultimate resort of the entire body and organs, knows truly, O Yājñavalkya."
"I know that being of whom you speak—who is the ultimate resort of the entire body and organs. It is the being who is identified with lust (Kāmamaya Puruṣa). Go on, Śākalya."
"Who is his deity?"
"Women,” said he.
Verse 3.9.12: The Person in the Sun
Sanskrit Verse
रूपाण्येव यस्यायतनम्, चक्शुर्लोकः, मनोज्योतिः, यो वै तं पुरुषं विद्यात्सर्वस्यात्मनः परायणम्, स वै वेदिता स्याद्याज्ञवल्क्य । वेद वा अहं तं पुरुषं सर्वस्यात्मनः परायणं यमात्थ; य एवासावादित्ये पुरुषः स एषः, वदैव शाकल्य; तस्य का देवतेति; सत्यमिति होवाच ॥ १२ ॥
Transliteration
rūpāṇyeva yasyāyatanam, cakśurlokaḥ, manojyotiḥ, yo vai taṃ puruṣaṃ vidyātsarvasyātmanaḥ parāyaṇam, sa vai veditā syādyājñavalkya | veda vā ahaṃ taṃ puruṣaṃ sarvasyātmanaḥ parāyaṇaṃ yamāttha; ya evāsāvāditye puruṣaḥ sa eṣaḥ, vadaiva śākalya; tasya kā devateti; satyamiti hovāca || 12 ||
Translation
“He who knows that being whose abode is colours, whose instrument of vision is the eye, whose light is the Manas, and who is the ultimate resort of the entire body and organs, knows truly, O Yājñavalkya."
"I know that being of whom you speak—who is the ultimate resort of the entire body and organs. It is the being who is in the sun. Go on, Śākalya."
"Who is his deity?"
"Truth (the eye),” said he.
Verse 3.9.13: The Person of Hearing
Sanskrit Verse
आकाश एव यस्यायतनम्, श्रोत्रं लोकः, मनोज्योतिः, यो वै तं पुरुषं विद्यात्सर्वस्यात्मनः परायणम्, स वै वेदिता स्याद्याज्ञवल्क्य । वेद वा अहं तं पुरुषं सर्वस्यात्मनः परायणं यमात्थ; य एवायं श्रौत्रः प्रातिश्रुत्कः पुरुषः स एष, वदैव शाकल्य; तस्य का देवतेति; दिश इति होवाच ॥ १३ ॥
Transliteration
ākāśa eva yasyāyatanam, śrotraṃ lokaḥ, manojyotiḥ, yo vai taṃ puruṣaṃ vidyātsarvasyātmanaḥ parāyaṇam, sa vai veditā syādyājñavalkya | veda vā ahaṃ taṃ puruṣaṃ sarvasyātmanaḥ parāyaṇaṃ yamāttha; ya evāyaṃ śrautraḥ prātiśrutkaḥ puruṣaḥ sa eṣa, vadaiva śākalya; tasya kā devateti; diśa iti hovāca || 13 ||
Translation
“He who knows that being whose abode is the ether, whose instrument of vision is the ear, whose light is the Manas, and who is the ultimate resort of the entire body and organs, knows truly, O Yājñavalkya."
"I know that being of whom you speak—who is the ultimate resort of the entire body and organs. It is the being who is identified with the ear and with the time of hearing. Go on, Śākalya."
"Who is his deity?"
"The quarters (diśaḥ),” said he.
Verse 3.9.14: The Person Identified with Shadow
Sanskrit Verse
तम एव यस्यायतनम्, हृदयं लोकः, मनोज्योतिः, यो वै तं पुरुषं विद्यात्सर्वस्यात्मनः परायणम्, स वै वेदिता स्याद्याज्ञवल्क्य । वेद वा अहं तं पुरुषं सर्वस्यात्मनः परायणं यमात्थ; य एवायं छायामयः पुरुषः स एषः, वदैव शाकल्य; तस्य का देवतेति; मृत्युरिति होवाच ॥ १४ ॥
Transliteration
tama eva yasyāyatanam, hṛdayaṃ lokaḥ, manojyotiḥ, yo vai taṃ puruṣaṃ vidyātsarvasyātmanaḥ parāyaṇam, sa vai veditā syādyājñavalkya | veda vā ahaṃ taṃ puruṣaṃ sarvasyātmanaḥ parāyaṇaṃ yamāttha; ya evāyaṃ chāyāmayaḥ puruṣaḥ sa eṣaḥ, vadaiva śākalya; tasya kā devateti; mṛtyuriti hovāca || 14 ||
Translation
“He who knows that being whose abode is darkness, whose instrument of vision is the intellect, whose light is the Manas, and who is the ultimate resort of the entire body and organs, knows truly, O Yājñavalkya."
"I know that being of whom you speak—who is the ultimate resort of the entire body and organs. It is the being who is identified with shadow (ignorance). Go on, Śākalya."
"Who is his deity?"
"Death,” said he.
Verse 3.9.15: The Person in the Looking-Glass
Sanskrit Verse
रूपाण्येव यस्यायतनम्, अक्शुर्लोकः, मनोज्योतिः, यो वै तं पुरुषं विद्यात्सर्वस्यात्मनः परायणम्, स वै वेदिता स्याद्याज्ञवल्क्य । वेद वा अहं तं पुरुषं सर्वस्यात्मनः परायणं यमात्थ; य एवायमादर्शे पुरुषः, स एषः, वदैव शाकल्य; तस्य का देवतेति; असुरिति होवाच ॥ १५ ॥
Transliteration
rūpāṇyeva yasyāyatanam, akśurlokaḥ, manojyotiḥ, yo vai taṃ puruṣaṃ vidyātsarvasyātmanaḥ parāyaṇam, sa vai veditā syādyājñavalkya | veda vā ahaṃ taṃ puruṣaṃ sarvasyātmanaḥ parāyaṇaṃ yamāttha; ya evāyamādarśe puruṣaḥ, sa eṣaḥ, vadaiva śākalya; tasya kā devateti; asuriti hovāca || 15 ||
Translation
“He who knows that being whose abode is (particular reflecting) colours, whose instrument of vision is the eye, whose light is the Manas, and who is the ultimate resort of the entire body and organs, knows truly, O Yājñavalkya."
"I know that being of whom you speak—who is the ultimate resort of the entire body and organs. It is the being who is in a looking-glass. Go on, Śākalya."
"Who is his deity?"
"The vital force (asu / prāṇa),” said he.
Verse 3.9.16: The Person in Water
Sanskrit Verse
आप एव यस्यायतनम्, हृदयं लोकः, मनोज्योतिः, यो वै तं पुरुषं विद्यात्सर्वस्यात्मनः परायणम्, स वै वेदिता स्याद्याज्ञवल्क्य । वेद वा अहं तं पुरुषं सर्वस्यात्मनः परायणं यमात्थ; य एवायमप्सु पुरुषः स एषः, वदैव शाकल्य; तस्य का देवतेति; वरुण इति होवाच ॥ १६ ॥
Transliteration
āpa eva yasyāyatanam, hṛdayaṃ lokaḥ, manojyotiḥ, yo vai taṃ puruṣaṃ vidyātsarvasyātmanaḥ parāyaṇam, sa vai veditā syādyājñavalkya | veda vā ahaṃ taṃ puruṣaṃ sarvasyātmanaḥ parāyaṇaṃ yamāttha; ya evāyamapsu puruṣaḥ sa eṣaḥ, vadaiva śākalya; tasya kā devateti; varuṇa iti hovāca || 16 ||
Translation
“He who knows that being whose abode is water, whose instrument of vision is the intellect, whose light is the Manas, and who is the ultimate resort of the entire body and organs, knows truly, O Yājñavalkya."
"I know that being of whom you speak—who is the ultimate resort of the entire body and organs. It is the being who is in water. Go on, Śākalya."
"Who is his deity?"
"Varuṇa (rain),” said he.
Verse 3.9.17: The Person Identified with the Son
Sanskrit Verse
रेत एव यस्यायतनम्, हृदयं लोकः, मनोज्योतिः, यो वै तं पुरुषं विद्यात्सर्वस्यात्मनः परायणम्, स वै वेदिता स्याद्याज्ञवल्क्य । वेद वा अहं तं पुरुषं सर्वस्यात्मनः परायणं यमात्थ; य एवायं पुत्रमयः पुरुषः स एषः, वदैव शाकल्य; तस्य का देवतेति; प्रजापतिरिति होवाच ॥ १७ ॥
Transliteration
reta eva yasyāyatanam, hṛdayaṃ lokaḥ, manojyotiḥ, yo vai taṃ puruṣaṃ vidyātsarvasyātmanaḥ parāyaṇam, sa vai veditā syādyājñavalkya | veda vā ahaṃ taṃ puruṣaṃ sarvasyātmanaḥ parāyaṇaṃ yamāttha; ya evāyaṃ putramayaḥ puruṣaḥ sa eṣaḥ, vadaiva śākalya; tasya kā devateti; prajāpatiriti hovāca || 17 ||
Translation
“He who knows that being whose abode is the seed, whose instrument of vision is the intellect, whose light is the Manas, and who is the ultimate resort of the entire body and organs, knows truly, O Yājñavalkya."
"I know that being of whom you speak—who is the ultimate resort of the entire body and organs. It is the being who is identified with the son. Go on, Śākalya."
"Who is his deity?"
"Prajāpati (the father),” said he.
Part III: The Five Directions and the Centrality of the Heart (Verses 3.9.18–3.9.25)
Verse 3.9.18: Yajnavalkya Rebukes Sakalya
Sanskrit Verse
शाकल्येति होवाच याज्ञवल्क्यः, त्वां स्विदिमे ब्राह्मणा अङ्गारावक्शयणमक्रता3 इति ॥ १८ ॥
Transliteration
śākalyeti hovāca yājñavalkyaḥ, tvāṃ svidime brāhmaṇā aṅgārāvakśayaṇamakratā3 iti || 18 ||
Translation
“Śākalya,” said Yājñavalkya, “have these Vedic scholars made you their instrument for burning charcoals (fire-tongs)?”
Commentary Summary:
Yājñavalkya warns Śākalya that the other Brāhmaṇas, afraid to face him directly, are using Śākalya as tongs to handle live coals, unaware that he is about to be consumed.
Verse 3.9.19: The Claim to Knowledge of the Quarters
Sanskrit Verse
याज्ञवल्क्येति होवाच शाकल्यः, यदिदं कुरुपञ्चालानां ब्राह्मणानत्यवादीः, किं ब्रह्म विद्वानिति; दिशो वेद सदेवाः सप्रतिष्ठा इति; यद्दिशो वेत्थ सदेवाः सप्रतिष्ठाः ॥ १९ ॥
Transliteration
yājñavalkyeti hovāca śākalyaḥ, yadidaṃ kurupañcālānāṃ brāhmaṇānatyavādīḥ, kiṃ brahma vidvāniti; diśo veda sadevāḥ sapratiṣṭhā iti; yaddiśo vettha sadevāḥ sapratiṣṭhāḥ || 19 ||
Translation
“Yājñavalkya,” said Śākalya, “is it because you know Brahman that you have thus flouted these Vedic scholars of Kuru and Pañcāla?"
"I know the quarters with their deities and supports."
"If you know the quarters with their deities and supports—“
Verse 3.9.20: The East
Sanskrit Verse
किंदेवतोऽस्यां प्राच्यां दिश्यसीति; आदित्यदेवत इति; स आदित्यः कस्मिन् प्रतिष्ठित इति; चक्शुषीति; कस्मिन्नु चक्शुः प्रतिष्ठितमिति; रूपेष्विति, चक्शुषा हि रूपाणि पश्यति; कस्मिन्नु रूपाणि प्रतिष्ठितानीति; हृदय इति होवाच, हृदयेन हि रूपाणि जानाति, हृदये ह्येव रूपाणि प्रतिष्ठितानि भवन्तीति; एवमेवैतद्याज्ञवल्क्य ॥ २० ॥
Transliteration
kiṃdevato’syāṃ prācyāṃ diśyasīti; ādityadevata iti; sa ādityaḥ kasmin pratiṣṭhita iti; cakśuṣīti; kasminnu cakśuḥ pratiṣṭhitamiti; rūpeṣviti, cakśuṣā hi rūpāṇi paśyati; kasminnu rūpāṇi pratiṣṭhitānīti; hṛdaya iti hovāca, hṛdayena hi rūpāṇi jānāti, hṛdaye hyeva rūpāṇi pratiṣṭhitāni bhavantīti; evamevaitadyājñavalkya || 20 ||
Translation
“What deity are you identified with in the east?"
"With the deity, sun."
"On what does the sun rest?"
"On the eye."
"On what does the eye rest?"
"On colours, for one sees colours with the eye."
"On what do colours rest?"
"On the heart (mind),” said Yājñavalkya, “for one knows colours through the heart; it is on the heart that colours rest."
"It is just so, Yājñavalkya.”
Verse 3.9.21: The South
Sanskrit Verse
किंदेवतोऽस्यां दक्शिणायां दिश्यसीति; यमदेवत इति; स यमः कस्मिन्प्रतिष्ठित इति; यज्ञ इति; कस्मिन्नु यज्ञः प्रतिष्ठित इति; दक्शिणायामिति; कस्मिन्नु दक्शिणा प्रतिष्ठितेति; श्रद्धायामिति, यदा ह्येव श्रद्धत्तेऽथ दक्शिणां ददाति, श्रद्धायां ह्येव दक्शिणा प्रतिष्ठितेति; कस्मिन्नु श्रद्धा प्रतिष्ठितेति; हृदय इति होवाच, हृदयेन हि श्रद्धां जानाति हृदये ह्येव श्रद्धा प्रतिष्ठिता भवतीति; एवमेवैतद्याज्ञवल्क्य ॥ २१ ॥
Transliteration
kiṃdevato’syāṃ dakśiṇāyāṃ diśyasīti; yamadevata iti; sa yamaḥ kasminpratiṣṭhita iti; yajña iti; kasminnu yajñaḥ pratiṣṭhita iti; dakśiṇāyāmiti; kasminnu dakśiṇā pratiṣṭhiteti; śraddhāyāmiti, yadā hyeva śraddhatte’tha dakśiṇāṃ dadāti, śraddhāyāṃ hyeva dakśiṇā pratiṣṭhiteti; kasminnu śraddhā pratiṣṭhiteti; hṛdaya iti hovāca, hṛdayena hi śraddhāṃ jānāti hṛdaye hyeva śraddhā pratiṣṭhitā bhavatīti; evamevaitadyājñavalkya || 21 ||
Translation
“What deity are you identified with in the south?"
"With the deity, Yama (the god of justice)."
"On what does Yama rest?"
"On the sacrifice."
"On what does the sacrifice rest?"
"On the remuneration (dakṣiṇā of the priests)."
"On what does the remuneration rest?"
"On faith (śraddhā), because whenever a man has faith, he gives remuneration to the priests; therefore it is on faith that remuneration rests."
"On what does faith rest?"
"On the heart,” said Yājñavalkya, “for one knows faith through the heart; therefore it is on the heart that faith rests."
"It is just so, Yājñavalkya.”
Verse 3.9.22: The West
Sanskrit Verse
किंदेवतोऽस्यां प्रतीच्यां दिश्यसीति; वरुणदेवत इति; स वरुणः कस्मिन् प्रतिष्ठित इति; अप्स्विति; कस्मिन्न्वापः प्रतिष्ठितेति; रेतसीति; कस्मिन्नु रेतः प्रतिष्ठितेति; हृदय इति, तस्मादपि प्रतिरूपं जातमाहुः, हृदयादिव सृप्तः, हृदयादिव निर्मित इति, हृदये ह्येव रेतः प्रतिष्ठितं भवतीति; एवमेवैतद्याज्ञवल्क्य ॥ २२ ॥
Transliteration
kiṃdevato’syāṃ pratīcyāṃ diśyasīti; varuṇadevata iti; sa varuṇaḥ kasmin pratiṣṭhita iti; apsviti; kasminnvāpaḥ pratiṣṭhiteti; retasīti; kasminnu retaḥ pratiṣṭhiteti; hṛdaya iti, tasmādapi pratirūpaṃ jātamāhuḥ, hṛdayādiva sṛptaḥ, hṛdayādiva nirmita iti, hṛdaye hyeva retaḥ pratiṣṭhitaṃ bhavatīti; evamevaitadyājñavalkya || 22 ||
Translation
“What deity are you identified with in the west?"
"With the deity, Varuṇa (the god of rain/waters)."
"On what does Varuṇa rest?"
"On water."
"On what does water rest?"
"On the seed."
"On what does the seed rest?"
"On the heart. Therefore do they say of a new-born child who closely resembles (his father), that he has sprung from (his father’s) heart, as it were—that he has been made out of (his father’s) heart, as it were. Therefore it is on the heart that the seed rests."
"It is just so, Yājñavalkya.”
Verse 3.9.23: The North
Sanskrit Verse
किंदेवतोऽस्यामुदीच्यां दिश्यसीति; सोमदेवत इति; स सोमः कस्मिन्प्रतिष्ठित इति; दीक्शायामिति; कस्मिन्नु दीक्शा प्रतिष्ठितेति; सत्य इति, तस्मादपि दीक्शितमाहुः सत्यं वदेति, सत्ये ह्येव दीक्शा प्रतिष्ठितेति; कस्मिन्नु सत्यं प्रतिष्ठितमिति; हृदय इति होवाच, हृदयेन हि सत्यं जानाति, हृदये ह्येव सत्यं प्रतिष्ठितं भवतीति; एवमेवैतद्याज्ञवल्क्य ॥ २३ ॥
Transliteration
kiṃdevato’syāmudīcyāṃ diśyasīti; somadevata iti; sa somaḥ kasminpratiṣṭhita iti; dīkśāyāmiti; kasminnu dīkśā pratiṣṭhiteti; satya iti, tasmādapi dīkśitamāhuḥ satyaṃ vadeti, satye hyeva dīkśā pratiṣṭhiteti; kasminnu satyaṃ pratiṣṭhitamiti; hṛdaya iti hovāca, hṛdayena hi satyaṃ jānāti, hṛdaye hyeva satyaṃ pratiṣṭhitaṃ bhavatīti; evamevaitadyājñavalkya || 23 ||
Translation
“What deity are you identified with in the north?"
"With the deity, Soma (the moon and the creeper)."
"On what does Soma rest?"
"On initiation (dīkṣā)."
"On what does initiation rest?"
"On truth. Therefore do they say to one initiated, ‘Speak the truth’; for it is on truth that initiation rests."
"On what does truth rest?"
"On the heart,” said Yājñavalkya, “for one knows truth through the heart; therefore it is on the heart that truth rests."
"It is just so, Yājñavalkya.”
Verse 3.9.24: The Zenith / Fixed Direction
Sanskrit Verse
किंदेवतो’स्यां ध्रुवायां दिश्यसीति; अग्निदेवत इति; सोऽग्निः कस्मिन्प्रतिष्ठित इति; वाचीति; कस्मिन्नु वाक् प्रतिष्ठितेति; हृदय इति; कस्मिन्नु हृदयं प्रतिष्ठितमिति ॥ २४ ॥
Transliteration
kiṃdevato’syāṃ dhruvāyāṃ diśyasīti; agnidevata iti; so’gniḥ kasminpratiṣṭhita iti; vācīti; kasminnu vāk pratiṣṭhiteti; hṛdaya iti; kasminnu hṛdayaṃ pratiṣṭhitamiti || 24 ||
Translation
“What deity are you identified with in the fixed direction (overhead)?"
"With the deity, fire."
"On what does fire rest?"
"On speech."
"On what does speech rest?"
"On the heart."
"On what does the heart rest?”
Verse 3.9.25: The Heart as the Center
Sanskrit Verse
अहल्लिकेति होवाच याज्ञवल्क्यः, यत्रैतदन्यत्रास्मन्मन्यासै, यद्ध्येतदन्यत्रास्मत्स्यात्, श्वानो वैनदद्युः, वयांसि वैनद्विमथ्नीरन्निति ॥ २५ ॥
Transliteration
ahalliketi hovāca yājñavalkyaḥ, yatraitadanyatrāsmanmanyāsai, yaddhyetadanyatrāsmatsyāt, śvāno vainadadyuḥ, vayāṃsi vainadvimathnīranniti || 25 ||
Translation
“You ghost (ahallikā),” said Yājñavalkya, “when you think the heart is elsewhere than in us! Should it be elsewhere than in us, dogs would eat this body, or birds tear it to pieces.”
Part IV: The Fivefold Prāṇa, Neti Neti, and the Fall of Śākalya (Verse 3.9.26)
Verse 3.9.26: The Upaniṣadic Puruṣa and Śākalya’s Fate
Sanskrit Verse
कस्मिन्नु त्वं चात्मा च प्रतिष्ठितौ स्थ इति; प्राण इति; कस्मिन्नु प्राणः प्रतिष्ठित इति; अपान इति; कस्मिन्न्वपानः प्रतिष्ठित इति; व्यान इति; कस्मिन्नु व्यानः प्रतिष्ठित इति; उदान इति; कस्मिन्नूदानः प्रतिष्ठित इति; समान इति; स एष नेति नेत्यात्मा, अगृह्यो नहि गृह्यते, अशीर्यो न हि शीर्यते, असङ्गो नहि सज्यते, असितो न व्यथते, न रिष्यति । एतान्यष्टावायतनानि, अष्टौ लोकाः, अष्टौ देवाः, अष्टौ पुरुषाः; स यस्तान्पुरुषान्निरुह्य प्रत्युह्यात्यक्रामत्, तं त्वौपनिषदं पुरुषं पृच्छामि; तं चेन्मे न विवक्श्यसि, मूर्धा ते विपतिष्यतीति । तं ह न मेने शाकल्यः; तस्य ह मूर्धा विपपात, अपि हास्य परिमोषिणोऽस्थीन्यपजह्रुरन्यन्मन्यमानाः ॥ २६ ॥
Transliteration
kasminnu tvaṃ cātmā ca pratiṣṭhitau stha iti; prāṇa iti; kasminnu prāṇaḥ pratiṣṭhita iti; apāna iti; kasminnvapānaḥ pratiṣṭhita iti; vyāna iti; kasminnu vyānaḥ pratiṣṭhita iti; udāna iti; kasminnūdānaḥ pratiṣṭhita iti; samāna iti; sa eṣa neti netyātmā, agṛhyo nahi gṛhyate, aśīryo na hi śīryate, asaṅgo nahi sajyate, asito na vyathate, na riṣyati | etānyaṣṭāvāyatanāni, aṣṭau lokāḥ, aṣṭau devāḥ, aṣṭau puruṣāḥ; sa yastānpuruṣānniruhya pratyuhyātyakrāmat, taṃ tvaupaniṣadaṃ puruṣaṃ pṛcchāmi; taṃ cenme na vivakśyasi, mūrdhā te vipatiṣyatīti | taṃ ha na mene śākalyaḥ; tasya ha mūrdhā vipapāta, api hāsya parimoṣiṇo’sthīnyapajahruranyanmanyamānāḥ || 26 ||
Translation
“On what do the body and the heart rest?"
"On the Prāṇa."
"On what does the Prāṇa rest?"
"On the Apāna."
"On what does the Apāna rest?"
"On the Vyāna."
"On what does the Vyāna rest?"
"On the Udāna."
"On what does the Udāna rest?"
"On the Samāna.”This Self is That which has been described as ‘Not this, not this’ (Neti, Neti). It is imperceptible, for It is never perceived; undecaying, for It never decays; unattached, for It is never attached; unfettered—It never feels pain, and never suffers injury.
“These are the eight abodes, the eight instruments of vision, the eight deities, and the eight beings. I ask you of that Being who is to be known only from the Upaniṣads (Aupaniṣada Puruṣa), who definitely projects those beings and (again) withdraws them into Himself, and who is at the same time transcendent. If you cannot clearly tell me of Him, your head shall fall off.”
Śākalya did not know Him; his head fell off; and robbers snatched away his bones, mistaking them for something else.
Commentary Summary:
The physiological breathing functions form an interlocking, interdependent whole:
- Prāṇa (forward/outward breath) is restrained from flying out by Apāna (downward breath).
- Both are balanced and held together by Vyāna (pervasive breath).
- All three are stabilized by Udāna (ascending breath).
- All rest upon Samāna (equalizing breath).
Beyond all physiological aggregates lies the Aupaniṣada Puruṣa—the non-dual Self knowable solely through the Upaniṣads, defined by radical apophatic negation (Neti Neti). Śākalya’s intellectual arrogance without genuine realization leads to his dramatic downfall.
Part V: Yajñavalkya’s Open Challenge and the Tree Analogy (Verses 3.9.27–3.9.28)
Verse 3.9.27: Yajnavalkya Challenges the Assembly
Sanskrit Verse
अथ होवाच, ब्राह्मणा भगवन्तो यो वः कामयते स मा पृच्छतु, सर्वे वा मा पृच्छत, यो वः कामयते तं वः पृच्छामि, सर्वान्वा वः पृच्छामीति; ते ह ब्राह्मणा न दधृषुः ॥ २७ ॥
Transliteration
atha hovāca, brāhmaṇā bhagavanto yo vaḥ kāmayate sa mā pṛcchatu, sarve vā mā pṛcchata, yo vaḥ kāmayate taṃ vaḥ pṛcchāmi, sarvānvā vaḥ pṛcchāmīti; te ha brāhmaṇā na dadhṛṣuḥ || 27 ||
Translation
Then he said: “Revered Brāhmaṇas, whichsoever amongst you wishes may ask me questions, or all of you may. Or I shall ask questions of whichsoever amongst you wishes, or ask all of you.” The Brāhmaṇas did not dare.
Verse 3.9.28: The Parable of the Tree and the Root of Rebirth
When the assembled scholars fell silent, Yājñavalkya addressed them with these verses:
3.9.28 (1): Hair and Skin
Sanskrit Verse
तान्हैतैः श्लोकैः पप्रच्छ—
यथा वृक्शो वनस्पतिस्तथैव पुरुषोऽमृषा ॥
तस्य लोमानि पर्णानि, त्वगस्योत्पाटिका बहिः ॥ १ ॥
Transliteration
tānhaitaiḥ ślokaiḥ papraccha—
yathā vṛkśo vanaspatistathaiva puruṣo’mṛṣā ||
tasya lomāni parṇāni, tvagasyotpāṭikā bahiḥ || 1 ||
Translation
As a large tree (vanaspati), so indeed is a man. (This is) true. His hair is its leaves, his skin its outer bark.
3.9.28 (2): Blood and Sap
Sanskrit Verse
त्वच एवास्य रुधिरं प्रस्यन्दि त्वच उत्पटः ॥
तस्मात्तदतृण्णात्प्रैति रसो वृक्शादिवाहतात् ॥ २ ॥
Transliteration
tvaca evāsya rudhiraṃ prasyandi tvaca utpaṭaḥ ||
tasmāttadatṛṇṇātpraiti raso vṛkśādivāhatāt || 2 ||
Translation
It is from his skin that blood flows, and from the bark sap. Therefore when a man is wounded, blood flows, as sap from a tree that is injured.
3.9.28 (3): Flesh, Sinews, Bones, and Marrow
Sanskrit Verse
मांसान्यस्य शकराणि, किनाट्ं स्नाव, तत्स्थिरम् ॥
अस्थीन्यन्तरतो दारूणि मज्जा मज्जोपमा कृता ॥ ३ ॥
Transliteration
māṃsānyasya śakarāṇi, kināṭṃ snāva, tatsthiram ||
asthīnyantarato dārūṇi majjā majjopamā kṛtā || 3 ||
Translation
His flesh is its inner bark, and his sinews its innermost layer of bark; it is tough. His bones lie under, as does its wood; his marrow is comparable to its pith.
3.9.28 (4): Whence Does a Mortal Resprout?
Sanskrit Verse
यद्वृक्शो वृक्णो रोहति मूलान्नवतरः पुनः ॥
मर्त्यः स्विन्मृत्युना वृक्णः कस्मान्मूलात्प्ररोहति ॥ ४ ॥
Transliteration
yadvṛkśo vṛkṇo rohati mūlānnavataraḥ punaḥ ||
martyaḥ svinmṛtyunā vṛkṇaḥ kasmānmūlātprarohati || 4 ||
Translation
If a tree, after it is felled, springs again from its root in a newer form, from what root does man spring forth after he is cut off by death?
3.9.28 (5): Not from the Seed Alone
Sanskrit Verse
रेतस इति मा वोचत, जीवतस्तत्प्रजायते ॥
धानारुह इव वै वृक्शोऽञ्जसा प्रेत्य सम्भवः ॥ ५ ॥
Transliteration
retasa iti mā vocata, jīvatastatprajāyate ||
dhānāruha iva vai vṛkśo’ñjasā pretya sambhavaḥ || 5 ||
Translation
Do not say, “From the seed,” (for) it is produced in a living man. A tree springs also from the seed; after it is dead it certainly springs again (from the seed as well).
3.9.28 (6): If Uprooted, Whence Does He Spring?
Sanskrit Verse
यत्समूलमावृहेयुर्वृक्शं न पुनराभवेत् ॥
मर्त्यः स्विन्मृत्युना वृक्णः कस्मान्मूलात्प्ररोहति ॥ ६ ॥
Transliteration
yatsamūlamāvṛheyurvṛkśaṃ na punarābhavet ||
martyaḥ svinmṛtyunā vṛkṇaḥ kasmānmūlātprarohati || 6 ||
Translation
If a tree is pulled out with its root, it no more sprouts. From what root does a mortal spring forth after he is cut off by death?
3.9.28 (7): Vijñānam Ānandaṃ Brahma
Sanskrit Verse
जात एव; न, जायते, को न्वेनं जनयेत्पुनः ॥
विज्ञानमानन्दं ब्रह्म, रातिर्दातुः परायणम्,
तिष्ठमानस्य तद्विद इति ॥ ७ ॥ २८ ॥
इति नवमं ब्राह्मणम् ॥ इति तृतीयोऽध्यायः ॥
Transliteration
jāta eva; na, jāyate, ko nvenaṃ janayetpunaḥ ||
vijñānamānandaṃ brahma, rātirdātuḥ parāyaṇam,
tiṣṭhamānasya tadvida iti || 7 || 28 ||
iti navamaṃ brāhmaṇam || iti tṛtīyo’dhyāyaḥ ||
Translation
If you think he is ever born, I say, no, he is again born. Now who should again bring him forth?
Knowledge, Bliss, Brahman (Vijñānam Ānandaṃ Brahma), the supreme goal of the distributor of wealth as well as of him who has realised Brahman and lives in It.Thus ends the Ninth Brahmana of the Third Chapter.
Philosophical Excursus: Shankara on Vijñānam Ānandaṃ Brahma
In the closing commentary of this section, Adi Shankaracharya examines the precise meaning of Brahman as Bliss (Ānanda):
-
Not an Object of Empirical Cognition:
- In ordinary worldly experience, “bliss” denotes experiential pleasure enjoyed by a subject upon contacting an agreeable object.
- However, in liberation (mokṣa), all dualities of subject, object, and instrument disappear (“Where one sees nothing else, hears nothing else, knows nothing else, that is the Infinite” — Chāndogya 7.24.1).
- Therefore, Brahman does not “experience” or “cognise” Its own bliss as an object. Brahman is Bliss itself—pure, unconditioned, homogeneous consciousness.
-
Refutation of Dualistic Views of Liberation:
- Schools such as the Sāṃkhyas or Nyāya-Vaiśeṣikas hold that liberation is mere absence of pain without positive bliss, while others imagine an individual soul continuing to feel pleasure.
- Shankara refutes both: Liberation is the absolute dissolution of limiting adjuncts (upādhis). Just as a drop of water poured into the ocean retains no separate boundary, the individual self merges into the non-dual Brahman.
- Scriptural descriptions of the liberated being “rejoicing” or “enjoying all desires” are figurative eulogies (arthavāda) expressing the knower’s identity with all existence.

Muni's Play