The Energy of the Soul and Mental Causation
Source: Robin Collins, “The Energy of the Soul? The Problem of Mental Causation,” Chapter 5 in The Soul Hypothesis: Investigations into the Existence of the Soul (eds. Mark C. Baker & Stewart Goetz, 2010).
1. The Energy Conservation Objection
One of the most persistent objections to substance dualism in modern philosophy of mind is the Energy Conservation Objection to mental causation. As philosopher Jerry Fodor famously summarized:
“The chief drawback of dualism is its failure to account adequately for mental causation… . How can the nonphysical give rise to the physical without violating the laws of the conservation of mass, of energy and of momentum?”
— Jerry Fodor
The objection assumes that:
- Every physical interaction in a closed system must strictly conserve energy and momentum.
- If an immaterial mind or soul acts upon the brain to produce bodily action, it must inject energy into or extract energy from the physical system.
- Therefore, Cartesian interactionist dualism violates fundamental physical conservation laws.
Robin Collins dismantles this objection by showing that its premises rest on outdated, 19th-century mechanistic assumptions contradicted by modern physics.
2. Refutation from Modern Physics
| Physicalist Assumption | Reality in Modern Physics | Implication for Dualism |
|---|---|---|
| ”Energy is strictly conserved across all interactions.” | Energy conservation fails globally in General Relativity (curved/expanding spacetime breaks time-translation symmetry). | The notion of energy need not apply to the mind; mind-brain interaction does not require conservation to hold. |
| ”Causal interaction strictly requires energy exchange.” | Quantum mechanics demonstrates non-local correlations and interactions (e.g., entanglement) without energy or momentum transfer. | Mental causation does not require energetic exchange to be scientifically plausible. |
Core Conclusion
The claim that interactionist dualism is incompatible with physics relies on classical Newtonian/thermodynamic intuitions. When evaluated against the actual formalisms of General Relativity and Quantum Mechanics, the energy conservation objection loses its foundational force, shifting the burden of proof back to the physicalist.

Muni's Play