Source: https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC4608430/

This paper proposes a multidimensional Phenomenological Matrix (PM) to resolve definitional ambiguities in mindfulness research. Rather than treating mindfulness as a monolithic trait or a single cognitive process, the authors frame it as a dynamic family of mental states definable across distinct phenomenological dimensions and corresponding large-scale neural networks.

Core Dimensions of the Phenomenological Matrix

The framework classifies mindfulness practices along three primary orthogonal axes and four secondary experiential qualities:

Primary Dimensions

  • Object Orientation: The degree to which attention is directed toward a specific intentional object (high in focused attention; low in open awareness or mind-wandering).
  • Dereification (Decentering): The explicit phenomenal recognition that thoughts, emotions, and perceptions are transient mental events rather than literal depictions of reality.
  • Meta-awareness: The continuous background monitoring of the current contents and quality of consciousness, providing the basis for noticing distraction, mind-wandering, or affective shifts without requiring an explicit introspective disruption.

Secondary Dimensions (Qualities)

  • Aperture: The breadth or scope of attentional focus (narrow spotlight vs. open panoramic field).
  • Clarity: The vividness and perceptual salience of the experiential content.
  • Stability: The capacity to sustain a given task-set or mental state over time against perturbations.
  • Effort: The felt exertion required to sustain the practice, which follows an inverted-U trajectory and drops significantly with expertise.

Mapping Practice Styles and Cognitive States

State / Practice StyleObject OrientationDereificationMeta-awarenessApertureEffort
Focused Attention (FA) – NoviceHighModerateModerateNarrowHigh
Focused Attention (FA) – ExpertHighHighHighNarrowMinimal
Open Monitoring (OM) – NoviceModerate/LowModerate/HighHighBroadModerate
Open Monitoring (OM) – ExpertMinimal / NoneVery HighVery HighWide OpenMinimal
Mind-WanderingLowLow (absorbed)LowDiffuseNone
Depressive RuminationHigh (sticky)Low (reified)Moderate/LowNarrowHigh
Addictive CravingHigh (cued object)Low (reified)LowNarrowVariable