Religious Coping Strategies and Mental Health Red Flags
Positive and negative religious coping strategies, and red flags in religiosity and mental health.
| Category | Positive Strategies (P) | Negative Strategies (N) |
|---|---|---|
| To find meaning | - Benevolent religious reappraisal (redefining the stressor as benevolent and beneficial through religion) | - Punishing God reappraisal (redefining the stressor as punishing from God, sin) - Demonic reappraisal (redefining the stressor as an act of Devil) - Reappraisal of God’s power (redefining beliefs in God’s power, not sufficient in face of stressful events) |
| To gain control | - Collaborative religious coping (problem solving partnership with God) - Active religious surrender (active giving up control to God) | - Passive religious deferral (passive waiting for God to solve situation) - Pleading for direct intercession (waiting for a miracle or direct divine intervention) - Self-directing religious coping (search control individually rather than through God intervention) |
| To gain comfort and closeness to god | - Seeking spiritual support (comfort and reassurance through God’s love and care) - Religious focus (engage in religious activities to shift from problems) - Religious purification (search for religious actions to spiritual cleansing) - Spiritual connection (search for a sense of connection with transcendent forces) | - Spiritual discontent (confusion and dissatisfaction with God in stressful situations) - Marking religious boundaries (demark strict right/wrong or acceptable/unacceptable religious behaviors) |
| To Achieve intimacy with others and closeness to God | - Seeking Support from Clergy or Members (comfort and reassurance through love and care in religious members) - Religious Helping (Provide spiritual support and comfort to others) | - Interpersonal Religious Discontent (confusion and dissatisfaction with clergy/religion members in stressful situations) |
| To achieve a life transformation | - Seeking a Religious Direction (assistance in finding new direction when needed) - Religious Conversion (search for a religion to a radical change in life) - Religious Forgiving (religious support to achieve a state of peace from an offense feelings of anger, hurt and fear) |
Notes: P, positive religious coping strategies; N, negative religious coping strategies. Source: Adapted from Brief RCOPE instrument. Pargament, K., Feuille, M., & Burdzy, D. (2011). The Brief RCOPE: Current psychometric status of a short measure of religious coping. Religions, 2(1), 51–76. Available from https://doi.org/10.3390/rel2010051; Pargament, K. I., Koenig, H. G., Tarakeshwar, N., & Hahn, J. (2004). Religious coping methods as predictors of psychological, physical and spiritual outcomes among medically ill elderly patients: A two-year longitudinal study. Journal of Health Psychology, 9(6), 713–730. Available from https://doi.org/10.1177/1359105304045366.
”Red Flags” in the relationship of religiosity and mental health
| Category | Red Flag | Description |
|---|---|---|
| To find meaning | God’s punishment | (e.g., lack of spirituality was responsible for an event, expectative of punishment for bad thoughts and actions, interpretation of an event as a message from God telling about a failure) |
| Religious denial | (e.g., refuse to feel bad, bothered, or upset because of faith teachings or God will or plans) | |
| To gain control | Religious passivity | (e.g., surrender to God since nothing personal can make a difference, wait for a sign of God to take a decision, let the Church handle a situation, feeling of total helplessness without God) |
| Religious vengeance | (e.g., realize or pray for God to punish the true sinners, ask God to make others hurt, believe that God will have his vengeance on those who sin) | |
| To gain comfort and closeness to god | Self-neglect | (e.g., decide to devote all time to religion, sacrifice all interests, realize that the World is not important, stop taking care of self, and focus only in God) |
| Anger at God | (e.g., angry with God concerning bad events, for God not hear personal prayer, or letting something happen) | |
| Religious doubt | (e.g., questions about whether God exists, about faith, religion, beliefs, difficulty gaining comfort) | |
| To Achieve intimacy with others and closeness to God | Interpersonal religious conflicts | (e.g., argue with family or friends about religion or faith, feel that the Church did not support in time of need or angry with church members) |
| Conflicts with church dogma | (e.g., disagreement with clergy about faith, God, religion, the way to handle specific situations or the views of Church about personal events) | |
| Other | Self-worship | (e.g., decide to turn away from God and live alone, nothing accounts in the world, no longer worry about morality, focus only on personal pleasures) |
| Religious apathy | (e.g., lost in interest in God, other people, self, life is pointless, stop caring about what happens) |
Source: Adapted from Pargament, K. I., Zinnbauer, B. J., Scott, A. B., Butter, E. M., Zerowin, J., & Stanik, P. (1998). Red flags and religious coping: Identifying some religious warning signs among people in crisis. Journal of Clinical Psychology, 54, 77-89. doi:CCC0021-9762/98/010077-13.
Example: Spiritual Struggles and Coping in Substance Use
Common spiritual struggles occurring during episodes of active substance use and a hypothetical patient worksheet for completing therapeutic cognitive reappraisals, using secular or S/R (Spiritual/Religious) content, or both. The term “God” may be personalized to the individual’s religious or spiritual beliefs.
| Spiritual struggle: themes | Maladaptive thought or belief | Secular cognitive reappraisal | S/R cognitive reappraisal | Coping Strategy Employed |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Personal failure | I’m an addict who has failed myself and others. | I am living with substance use disorder, which is treatable. This is an illness from which I will recover. | I am living with substance use disorder, and I trust that God will help me in my efforts to heal. | Collaborative religious coping |
| Hopelessness | I’ve ruined my life and I can’t stop using alcohol/drugs. | Things can change for the better; I can make effective choices now. | Although things seem hopeless, nothing is impossible with God on my side. | Collaborative religious coping |
| Isolation/disconnection | I am so alone. | I have others that care about me even though I feel alone. | God’s love is with me always, I can seek His Presence. | Seeking spiritual support |
| Loss of self-identity and self-respect | I must be a weak person to have my life ruined by alcohol/drugs. | I am a valuable person with both strengths and vulnerabilities. | Alone I am weak, but with the grace of God I am strong. | Seeking spiritual support |
| Loss of connection with personal/life goals | My life is pointless. | My life has meaning in spite of alcohol/drug use. Now is a good time to reassess my goals. | I trust that God will lead me on a path of recovery, and I will find a better life. | Seeking a Religious Direction |
| Guilt and shame | My substance use is evidence that I don’t care enough about myself or others. | I need my substance use disorder treated in order to take good care of myself and others. | Nothing I have done is bigger than the mercy of God. As I achieve recovery, I will become better at taking care of myself and others. | Religious Forgiving |
| Anger | I hate my life and having this disease. | Recovery is possible and will restore meaning to my life. | If I am patient with myself and others, God will restore my peace. | Religious Forgiving |

Muni's Play