Religious Coping Strategies and Mental Health Red Flags

Positive and negative religious coping strategies, and red flags in religiosity and mental health.

CategoryPositive Strategies (P)Negative Strategies (N)
To find meaning- Benevolent religious reappraisal (redefining the stressor as benevolent and beneficial through religion)- Punishing God reappraisal (redefining the stressor as punishing from God, sin)
- Demonic reappraisal (redefining the stressor as an act of Devil)
- Reappraisal of God’s power (redefining beliefs in God’s power, not sufficient in face of stressful events)
To gain control- Collaborative religious coping (problem solving partnership with God)
- Active religious surrender (active giving up control to God)
- Passive religious deferral (passive waiting for God to solve situation)
- Pleading for direct intercession (waiting for a miracle or direct divine intervention)
- Self-directing religious coping (search control individually rather than through God intervention)
To gain comfort and closeness to god- Seeking spiritual support (comfort and reassurance through God’s love and care)
- Religious focus (engage in religious activities to shift from problems)
- Religious purification (search for religious actions to spiritual cleansing)
- Spiritual connection (search for a sense of connection with transcendent forces)
- Spiritual discontent (confusion and dissatisfaction with God in stressful situations)
- Marking religious boundaries (demark strict right/wrong or acceptable/unacceptable religious behaviors)
To Achieve intimacy with others and closeness to God- Seeking Support from Clergy or Members (comfort and reassurance through love and care in religious members)
- Religious Helping (Provide spiritual support and comfort to others)
- Interpersonal Religious Discontent (confusion and dissatisfaction with clergy/religion members in stressful situations)
To achieve a life transformation- Seeking a Religious Direction (assistance in finding new direction when needed)
- Religious Conversion (search for a religion to a radical change in life)
- Religious Forgiving (religious support to achieve a state of peace from an offense feelings of anger, hurt and fear)

Notes: P, positive religious coping strategies; N, negative religious coping strategies. Source: Adapted from Brief RCOPE instrument. Pargament, K., Feuille, M., & Burdzy, D. (2011). The Brief RCOPE: Current psychometric status of a short measure of religious coping. Religions, 2(1), 51–76. Available from https://doi.org/10.3390/rel2010051; Pargament, K. I., Koenig, H. G., Tarakeshwar, N., & Hahn, J. (2004). Religious coping methods as predictors of psychological, physical and spiritual outcomes among medically ill elderly patients: A two-year longitudinal study. Journal of Health Psychology, 9(6), 713–730. Available from https://doi.org/10.1177/1359105304045366.


”Red Flags” in the relationship of religiosity and mental health

CategoryRed FlagDescription
To find meaningGod’s punishment(e.g., lack of spirituality was responsible for an event, expectative of punishment for bad thoughts and actions, interpretation of an event as a message from God telling about a failure)
Religious denial(e.g., refuse to feel bad, bothered, or upset because of faith teachings or God will or plans)
To gain controlReligious passivity(e.g., surrender to God since nothing personal can make a difference, wait for a sign of God to take a decision, let the Church handle a situation, feeling of total helplessness without God)
Religious vengeance(e.g., realize or pray for God to punish the true sinners, ask God to make others hurt, believe that God will have his vengeance on those who sin)
To gain comfort and closeness to godSelf-neglect(e.g., decide to devote all time to religion, sacrifice all interests, realize that the World is not important, stop taking care of self, and focus only in God)
Anger at God(e.g., angry with God concerning bad events, for God not hear personal prayer, or letting something happen)
Religious doubt(e.g., questions about whether God exists, about faith, religion, beliefs, difficulty gaining comfort)
To Achieve intimacy with others and closeness to GodInterpersonal religious conflicts(e.g., argue with family or friends about religion or faith, feel that the Church did not support in time of need or angry with church members)
Conflicts with church dogma(e.g., disagreement with clergy about faith, God, religion, the way to handle specific situations or the views of Church about personal events)
OtherSelf-worship(e.g., decide to turn away from God and live alone, nothing accounts in the world, no longer worry about morality, focus only on personal pleasures)
Religious apathy(e.g., lost in interest in God, other people, self, life is pointless, stop caring about what happens)

Source: Adapted from Pargament, K. I., Zinnbauer, B. J., Scott, A. B., Butter, E. M., Zerowin, J., & Stanik, P. (1998). Red flags and religious coping: Identifying some religious warning signs among people in crisis. Journal of Clinical Psychology, 54, 77-89. doi:CCC0021-9762/98/010077-13.


Example: Spiritual Struggles and Coping in Substance Use

Common spiritual struggles occurring during episodes of active substance use and a hypothetical patient worksheet for completing therapeutic cognitive reappraisals, using secular or S/R (Spiritual/Religious) content, or both. The term “God” may be personalized to the individual’s religious or spiritual beliefs.

Spiritual struggle: themesMaladaptive thought or beliefSecular cognitive reappraisalS/R cognitive reappraisalCoping Strategy Employed
Personal failureI’m an addict who has failed myself and others.I am living with substance use disorder, which is treatable. This is an illness from which I will recover.I am living with substance use disorder, and I trust that God will help me in my efforts to heal.Collaborative religious coping
HopelessnessI’ve ruined my life and I can’t stop using alcohol/drugs.Things can change for the better; I can make effective choices now.Although things seem hopeless, nothing is impossible with God on my side.Collaborative religious coping
Isolation/disconnectionI am so alone.I have others that care about me even though I feel alone.God’s love is with me always, I can seek His Presence.Seeking spiritual support
Loss of self-identity and self-respectI must be a weak person to have my life ruined by alcohol/drugs.I am a valuable person with both strengths and vulnerabilities.Alone I am weak, but with the grace of God I am strong.Seeking spiritual support
Loss of connection with personal/life goalsMy life is pointless.My life has meaning in spite of alcohol/drug use. Now is a good time to reassess my goals.I trust that God will lead me on a path of recovery, and I will find a better life.Seeking a Religious Direction
Guilt and shameMy substance use is evidence that I don’t care enough about myself or others.I need my substance use disorder treated in order to take good care of myself and others.Nothing I have done is bigger than the mercy of God. As I achieve recovery, I will become better at taking care of myself and others.Religious Forgiving
AngerI hate my life and having this disease.Recovery is possible and will restore meaning to my life.If I am patient with myself and others, God will restore my peace.Religious Forgiving