These are my comprehensive notes from Sri Sadhu Om’s text, The Path of Sri Ramana (Parts One and Two), explicating the pure practice of Self-Enquiry (Atma-Vichara) and the true nature of Devotion (Bhakti) as taught by Bhagavan Sri Ramana Maharshi.
1. The Three Grammatical Persons
Spiritual experience and the mind’s attention operate strictly across three grammatical dimensions:
- First Person (The Subject): The subjective feeling of “I” (Aham / Tanmai).
- Second Person (The Addressed Object): “You” / external entities (Munnilai).
- Third Person (All Other Objects): “He”, “She”, “It”, “They”, thoughts, bodies, memories, senses, and the entire perceived universe (Padarkkai).
The world consists solely of 2nd and 3rd persons. In deep sleep, because the first-person feeling (“I am the body”) does not rise, second and third persons do not exist at all.
Attention to the 1st person is true devotion (Bhakti): God does not exist as an external object in the 2nd or 3rd person; God is the underlying reality and source of the 1st person (“I”). Attending to the Self is the highest devotion, effective yoga, and genuine seeking of God.
Self-Attention is God-Attention
“Since God ever shines as the reality of the first person, attending to the first person is the right attention to God and this is the true path of devotion… Since God or Brahman is thus always shining as the reality of ‘I’, giving the mind the practice of attending to Self is the only true seeking of God and the only effective yoga. Hence, Self-attention is the true God-attention!”
Meditations like “I am Brahman” or “I am He” treat Brahman as an external 2nd/3rd person concept, keeping the mind actively projecting (karma). Self-attention, by contrast, is pure stillness of mind (akarma).
Meditation vs. Stillness
“So long as the ego (the ‘I am the body’-consciousness) lasts, when one hears the word ‘Brahman’ one can only take it to denote one of the second or third persons and not any other thing (i.e. not the first person feeling), because in the sentence ‘I am Brahman’, since ‘I’ is already there to denote the first person, the word ‘Brahman’ can only be taken to mean either a second or a third person. When closely scrutinized, meditations such as ‘I am He’ or ‘I am Brahman’ are thus found to be nothing but an activity of the mind diverging towards a second or third person. There is therefore a vast difference (as between a mountain and a valley) between these meditations, which are mental activities, and the Self-attention taught by Bhagavan Sri Ramana, which is a stillness of mind!“
2. Attention is Attachment: The Flaw in “Witnessing Thoughts”
Modern spiritual teachers frequently advocate “watching or witnessing thoughts and events with detachment.” Sri Sadhu Om explains why this widespread instruction is fundamentally impractical:
The Self’s attention acts as nourishing Grace (anugraha). Whatever thoughts we observe, watch, or witness are fueled and sustained by that very attention.
The Glance of Grace
“The very nature of our (the Supreme Self’s) attention itself is Grace (anugraha). This means that whatever thing we attend to, witness, observe or look at, that thing is nourished and will flourish, being blessed by Grace. The more our attention—the glance of Grace (anugraha-drishti)—falls on it, the more the mind’s wavering nature and its ascendancy will increase.”
Struggling with bad thoughts or chanting neti, neti keeps attention on them, causing failure. Directing attention solely to the Self deprives thoughts of fuel, effortlessly bypassing them.
Fighting Thoughts vs. Bypassing Them
“That is why it is impossible for the mind to negate anything by thinking ‘I am not this, I am not this’ (neti, neti). On the other hand, if our (Self’s) attention is directed only towards ourself, our knowledge of our existence alone is nourished, and since the mind is not attended to, it is deprived of its strength, the support of our Grace. This is why aspirants who, in order to destroy evil thoughts like lust, anger and so on, fight against them and thereby think about them fail in their attempts, while aspirants practising Self-enquiry, who pay their full attention to Self with an indifference towards their thoughts, bypass them easily.”
True vairagya is strictly non-attention to what-is-other. “Watching thoughts with detachment” is a contradiction because attending to any object is itself attachment.
Non-Attention is Non-Attachment
“What Sri Bhagavan said is: ‘It is futile to scrutinize the various properties of all the principles (non-Self) which are veiling Self.’ No matter how much we scrutinize thoughts pertaining to second and third persons, they will never subside but will only increase… When He says later in the same work, ‘Not attending to what-is-other (that is, to any second or third person) is non-attachment (vairagya) or desirelessness,’ we should clearly understand that attending to (witnessing, watching, observing or seeing) anything other than Self is itself attachment, and when we understand thus we will realize how meaningless and impractical are such instructions as ‘Watch all thoughts and events with detachment’ or ‘Witness your thoughts, but be not attached to them’.”
When a thought rises, don’t follow or fight it. Ask: “To whom did this rise?” “To me” “Who am I?” to immediately snap attention back to the Source.
Cutting Thoughts at the Moment of Rising
“If other thoughts rise, one should, without attempting to complete them, enquire ‘To whom did they rise?‘. What does it matter however many thoughts rise? At the very moment that each thought rises, if one vigilantly enquires ‘To whom did this rise?’, it will be known ‘To me’. If one then enquires ‘Who am I?’, the mind (our power of attention) will turn back (from the thought) to its source (Self).“
3. The Tree Analogy: Cutting the Root Thought
Trying to eradicate thoughts one by one is like plucking individual leaves from a tree. Destroying the primal “I”-thought (the trunk) brings down all dependent thoughts simultaneously.
The Tree and the Trunk
“If the ‘I’-thought—the root of all thoughts—is prevented from rising, all other thoughts will also be prevented. If a man wants to cut down the millions of leaves and hundreds of branches of a tree, is it not enough if he cuts down the trunk? Similarly, a man who is trying to destroy all the millions and millions of thoughts will have succeeded in doing so if he destroys the ‘I’-thought, their root. Did we not start with the objective of scrutinizing thoughts? From what we have seen above, it is now clear that it is not necessary to scrutinize each and every thought, and that a scrutiny of only the ‘I’-thought, the root of all thoughts, is quite sufficient.”
Attending to 2nd/3rd person thoughts multiplies them, whereas attending directly to the 1st person “I”-thought causes it to subside and dissolve.
The Unique Nature of the 'I'-Thought
“The first person thought, ‘I’, has this peculiar property: if (by enquiring ‘Who am I?’) attention is focused on it in order to discover what it is, this ‘I’-thought will subside. But on the contrary, the more we attend to thoughts pertaining to the second and third persons, the more they will increase.”
4. Being vs. Rising: Sat vs. Thought
| Dimension | Pure Being (Sat-Chit) | The Rising Ego (Chit-Jada Granthi) |
|---|---|---|
| Expression | Pure “I am” (Swarupa / Ulladhu) | Mixed “I am this / I am a man / I am the body” |
| Nature | Pure Existence-Consciousness; not a thought | The primal rising thought (Aham-vritti) |
| Continuity | Present unbroken in waking, dream, and deep sleep | Rises on waking, vanishes in deep sleep |
| Adjuncts (Upadhis) | Timeless, spaceless, formless, unattached | Bound to names, forms, sheaths, and bodily postures |
“I am” (Sat-Chit) is our true, unattached nature—pure existence-consciousness, not a thought. “I am a man / body” is the mixed consciousness (ego), which is the first thought rising from Being.
Being vs. Rising
“The feeling ‘I am’ is the experience common to one and all. In this, ‘am’ is consciousness or knowledge… This is chit. ‘We are verily consciousness,’ says Sri Bhagavan in Upadesa Undhiyar verse 23. This is our ‘being’ (that is, our true existence) or sat. This is called ‘that which is’ (ulladhu). Thus in ‘I am’, ‘I’ is existence (sat) and ‘am’ is consciousness (chit). When Self, our nature of existence-consciousness (satchit swarupam), instead of shining only as the pure consciousness ‘I am’, shines mixed with an adjunct (upadhi) as ‘I am a man, I am Rama, I am this or that’, then this mixed consciousness is the ego… The feeling ‘I am a man, I am so-and-so’ is only a thought. But the consciousness ‘I am’ is not a thought; it is the very nature of our ‘being’. The mixed consciousness ‘I am this or that’ is a thought that rises from our ‘being’. To understand thus the difference between our ‘being’ and our ‘rising’ (that is, between existence and thought) first of all is essential for aspirants who take to the enquiry ‘Who am I?’.”
Because the body, senses, and world disappear completely in deep sleep while “I am” remains unbroken, none of them constitute our real “I”.
The Litmus Test of Reality
“A thing is surely not ‘I’ if it is possible for one to experience ‘I am’ even in the absence of that thing.”
5. The Mechanics of Self-Enquiry: “Who Am I?” vs. “Whence Am I?”
Self-enquiry is an inward investigation of attention—not an intellectual debate, mental analysis, or mantra for vocal chanting (japa). “Who am I?” is a method of turning attention Selfward, never a formula for vocal repetition.
Not Meant for Japa
“Sri Bhagavan Himself has repeatedly said: ”Who am I?’ is not meant for repetition (japa)’!“
1. “Who Am I?” (Ko’ham?)
- Directly isolates the raw, unadulterated feeling of being from superimposed identities: “What is this feeling which shines as ‘I am’?“
2. “Whence Am I?” (Kuto’ham?)
- “Whence am I?” means “From what source?”, not “From where in the anatomical body?“.
- Meditating on a physical spot in the chest or chakras is still 2nd-person objective attention; the true Heart (Hridayam) is spaceless, formless Consciousness.
The Meaning of 'Whence?'
“Some others, thinking that they are following the second interrogative form, ‘Whence am I?’, try to concentrate on the right side of the chest (where they imagine something as a spiritual heart), expecting a reply such as ‘I am from here’! This is in no way better than the ancient method of meditating upon any one of the six yogic centres (shad-chakras) in the body! For, is not thinking of any place in the body only a second person attention (an objective attention)?
The meaning which Sri Bhagavan expects us to understand from the term ‘Whence?’ or ‘From where?’ is ‘From what?‘. When taken in this sense, instead of a place or time coming forth as a reply, Self-existence, ‘we’, the Thing (vastu), alone is experienced as the reply. If, on the other hand, we anticipate a place as an answer to the question ‘Whence?’, a place, conditioned by time and space, will be experienced within the body ‘two digits to the right from the centre of the chest’ (as said in Ulladhu Narpadhu - Anubandham verse 18). Yet this experience is not the ultimate or absolute one (paramarthikam). For, Sri Bhagavan has positively asserted that Heart (hridayam) is verily Self-consciousness, which is timeless, spaceless, formless and nameless. Finding a place in the body as the rising-point of the ego in reply to the question ‘Whence?’ is not the objective of Sri Bhagavan’s teachings; nor is it the fruit to be gained by Self-enquiry.”
3. One Single ‘I’ (Avoiding Ego-Self Dualism)
- There are not two separate entities (a “lower self” hunting a “higher self”). Clinging single-mindedly to the one unbroken feeling of “I” dissolves the phantom ego.
No Two Selves
“Are there two persons in the aspirant, the ego and Self? This is said because, since every one of us has the experience ‘I am one only and not two’, we should not give room to an imaginary dual feeling—one ‘I’ seeking for another ‘I’—by differentiating ego and Self as ‘lower self’ and ‘higher self’… Thus it is sufficient if we cling to the feeling ‘I’ uninterruptedly till the very end.”
6. Dative vs. Nominative: The Mechanics of Recalling Attention
When thoughts intrude during practice, Bhagavan provided a precise linguistic contrivance to snap awareness back to the subject:
- Asking “To whom do thoughts appear?” yields “To me” (dative / enakku), which effortlessly prompts the nominative “I” (nan).
- Asking “Who am I?” directly restores Self-attention and abidance in pure Being.
Dative to Nominative Shift
“It is only when there is a slackness of vigilance (pramada) during Self-attention that thoughts, which are an indication of it, will rise. In other words, if thoughts rise it means that our Self-attention is lost. It is only as a contrivance to win back Self-attention from thought-attention that Sri Bhagavan advised us to ask, ‘To whom do these thoughts appear?‘.
Since the answer ‘To me’ is only a dative form of ‘I’ (enakku), it will easily remind us of the nominative form, the feeling ‘I’ (nan). However, if we question, ‘Who thinks these thoughts?’, since the nominative form, the feeling ‘I’, is obtained as an answer, will not Self-attention, which has been lost unnoticed, be regained directly? This regaining of Self-attention is actually being Self (that is, remaining or abiding as Self)!“
7. Sadhana is Not Doing, But Being (Summa Iru)
Attention on objects is mental doing/action (karma); attention on the Self is non-action (akarma) and pure stillness (summa iruttal). True sadhana is not a mental task to be performed, but simply Being Still (Summa Iru).
Action vs. Inaction
“So long as our power of attention was dwelling upon second and third persons, it was called ‘the mind’ or ‘the intellect’, and its attending was called a doing (kriya) or an action (karma). Only that which is done by the mind is an action. But on the other hand, as soon as the attention is fixed on the first person (or Self), it loses its mean names such as mind, intellect or ego sense. Moreover, that attention is no longer even an action, but inaction (akarma) or the state of ‘being still’ (summa iruttal). Therefore, the mind which attends to Self is no more the mind; it is the consciousness aspect of Self (atma-chit-rupam)! Self alone realizes Self; the ego does not!
Such ‘being’ alone is the correct sadhana; sadhana is not doing, but being! What our Lord Ramana firmly advises us to take to, as the greatest and most powerful tapas is only this much: ‘Be still’ (summa iru), and not anything (dhyana, yoga and so on) as the duty to be performed by the mind.”
8. Catching the “Thief” (The Pure State Between Thoughts)
On waking from sleep, Consciousness moves with lightning speed:
- The Flash: Pure “I”-consciousness shoots from the Heart to the brain in one millionth of a second.
- The Distribution: From the brain, it spreads along the nerves (nadis) through the body like electrical voltage (abhimana-vega).
- The Superimposition: The moment it reaches the brain, it mixes with adjuncts: “I am this body.”
In the microsecond gap between sleep and waking (or between thoughts), the pure “I” shines without adjuncts. Developing nishtha-bala (strength of abidance) allows one to catch this “thief” (the rising ego) and dissolve it at its source.
King Janaka and the Thief
“This consciousness, which spreads with such a tremendous impetus and speed all over the body as ‘I’, remains pure, having no adjunct (upadhi) attached to it, till it reaches the brain from the Heart. But, since its force of attachment (abhimana-vega) is so great that the time taken by it to shoot up from the Heart to the brain is extremely short, one millionth of a second so to speak, ordinary people are unable to cognize it in its pure condition, devoid of any adjunct. This pure condition of the rising ‘I’ consciousness is what was pointed out by Sri Bhagavan when He said, ‘In the space between two states or two thoughts, the pure ego (the pure condition or true nature of the ego) is experienced’ (Maharshi’s Gospel).
When the attention is focused deeper and deeper within towards the feeling ‘I am’ and when the ego thereby shrinks more and more into nothingness, our power of attention becomes subtler than the subtlest atom and thereby grows sharper and brighter. Hence, the strength of abidance (nishtha-bala) will now be achieved to remain balanced between two states, that is, in a state after the end of sleep and before waking up, in other words, before being possessed by the first thought.
This is what Janaka, the royal Sage, meant when he said: ‘I have found out the thief (the time of his coming—the time and place of the ego’s rising) who has been ruining me all along; I will inflict the right punishment upon him.’ Since the ego, which was acting till now as if it were the first person, is found to be a second person alien to us, the right punishment is to destroy it at its very place of rising by clinging steadfastly to the real first person.”
The Twofold Knot (Granthi)
- The Knot of Bondage to the Nerves (Nadi-Bandha-Granthi): Pertains to Prana (breath) and the physical nervous system.
- The Knot of Attachment (Abhimana-Granthi): Pertains to the mind and latent tendencies (vasanas).
- Because mind and breath share one source (the Heart), destroying the mind’s attachment knot through enquiry automatically dissolves the physical nerve knot.
Severing the Knot ( Granthi-Bheda)
“Since the source of the mind and the prana is one (the Heart), when the knot of attachment (abhimana-granthi) is severed by the annihilation of the mind through Self-enquiry, the knot of bondage to the nerves (nadi-bandha-granthi) is also severed. Disconnecting the knot in such a way that it will never again come into being is called by many names such as ‘the cutting of the knot’ (granthi-bheda), ‘the destruction of the mind’ (mano-nasa) and so on.”
9. The Analogy of the Light Ray in the Dark Room
Following the feeling “I am” is like tracing a reflected beam of light back to the open sun. The vanishing of the reflected ray into boundless light is not a loss or void, but the realization of true Light.
Tracing the Ray to the Sun
“Just as the man came out into the open space from the dark room by steadfastly holding on to and moving along the reflected ray, so the enquirer reaches the open space of Heart… by assiduously holding on to the feeling ‘I am’.
When the place where you are now is nothing but the unlimited space of light, can a darkness come into existence because of the void created by the disappearance of the reflected ray? Can its disappearance be a loss? Know that its disappearance itself is the true light; it is not darkness.”
10. The Sphurana and Final Annihilation
Setting aside body identification, the soundless feeling “I-I” (sphurana) shines in the Heart. By abiding in it, the ego is consumed and finally extinguished without residue, like a camphor flame.
The Camphor Flame
“How to enquire? Can the body, which is insentient like a log and such things, shine and function as ‘I’? It cannot. Therefore, discarding the corpse-like body as an actual corpse and remaining without even uttering the word ‘I’ vocally—if keenly observed what that feeling is which now shines as ‘I’, a sphurana alone will be experienced without sound as ‘I-I’ in the heart.
If without leaving it we just be, the sphurana, completely annihilating the feeling of individuality—the ego, ‘I am the body’—finally will come to an end just as the camphor flame dies out. This alone is proclaimed to be liberation by Sages and scriptures.”
11. Effortless Breath Suspension (Kumbhaka)
Forced breath retention (Raja Yoga) risks nervous disorders in weak or aging bodies. Intense inner enquiry causes effortless, natural breath suspension without any strain or suffocation.
Natural vs. Forced Kumbhaka
“When the mind, with a tremendous longing to find the source which gives it light, turns inwards, the breath stops automatically! Until there is a rising of a thought on account of non-vigilance (pramada) in Self-attention, this retention (kumbhaka) will continue in an enquirer quite effortlessly. In our everyday life when some startling news is suddenly brought to us or when we try to recollect a forgotten thing with full concentration, the breath stops automatically… In this state of retention (kumbhaka), no matter how long it continues, the enquirer does not experience suffocation, that is, the urge to exhale or inhale.
To bear the churning of the nadis effected through the method of breath-retention in raja yoga, the body must be young and strong… But there is no room for any such dangers if the churning is made to take place through enquiry.”
12. Visions, Siddhis, and Ramanastram
Celestial visions, sounds, and bliss in the sushumna are subtle mental experiences (visesha-anubhava), not Self-realization. Getting attached to them causes one to lose Self-attention and become “fallen from yoga” (yoga-bhrashtas).
The Danger of Yoga-Bhrashta
“There is no wonder that these experiences appear to be clearer and of greater reality than the sense-experiences in the ordinary waking state, because the experiences of the present waking world are gained through the gross five senses, which are functioning by the impure ‘I’-consciousness scattered all over the body, whereas these experiences of celestial worlds are gained through the subtle five senses, which are functioning by the pure, focused ‘I’-consciousness. Yet all these are only qualified mental experiences (visesha-manaanubhavas) and not the unqualified Self-experience (nirvisesha-ekatma-anubhava).
Whatever appears and is experienced is only a second person knowledge, which means that sadhana, the first person attention, is lost at that time! Many are those who take these qualified experiences of taste, light, sound and so on to be the final attainment of Self-knowledge (brahma-jnana), and because they have had these experiences they think that they have attained liberation and they become more and more entangled in attention to second and third persons, thus losing their foothold on Self-attention. Such aspirants are called ‘those fallen from yoga’ (yoga-bhrashtas).”
When subtle visions arise, apply Ramanastram: “To whom do these appear? To me. Who am I?” Like a possessing spirit that leaves when ignored, subtle phenomena vanish when deprived of attention, dissolving the mind into the Heart.
Ramanastram (The Invincible Weapon)
“Whenever one is overtaken by such qualified experiences, the weapon of Ramana (Ramanastram), ‘To whom are these experiences?’, is to be used! The feeling ‘To me’ will be the response! From this, by the enquiry ‘Who am I?’, one can immediately regain the thread of Self-attention.
When Self-attention is thus regained, those qualified experiences of second and third persons will disappear of their own accord because there is no one to attend to them (just as a spirit possessing a man jumps and dances more and more so long as others attend to and try to hold the man, but leaves him if there is nobody to attend to him).
When the mind, giving up knowing those qualified external sense-objects, again turns towards its form of light (consciousness), it will sink into its source, the Heart, and lose its form for ever. Therefore, the enquiry ‘Who am I?’ alone is the best sadhana, which will guard and guide us to the end and save us. It is the invincible supreme weapon (Brahmastram) which is bestowed only by the Grace of Sri Ramana Sadguru! It is the beacon-light which safeguards us lest we should stray away from the path to eternal happiness… It is the path of Sri Ramana, which alone transforms us into Self: ‘I am that I am’!“
13. Divine Grace and the Mature Mind (Pakva Manas)
The Heart exerts a magnetic pull of Grace (I-I) that draws the mind inward. Mature minds (pakva manas) joyfully surrender to its pull, while immature minds turn outward in fear of ego-dissolution.
The Magnetic Power of the Heart
“‘If the mind (the attention) is thus well fixed in sadhana (attending to Self), a power of divine Grace will then rise from within of its own accord and, subjugating the mind, will take it to the Heart.’ What is this power of divine Grace? It is nothing but the perfect clarity of our existence, the form of the Supreme Self (paramatman), ever shining with abundant Grace in the heart as ‘I-I’!
Mature aspirants will willingly and without rebelling submit themselves to this magnetic power of the Grace of Self-effulgence. Others, on the other hand, will become extroverted (that is, will turn their attention outwards) fearing the attraction of this power. Therefore, we should first make ourself fit by the intense love (bhakti) to know Self and by the tremendous detachment (vairagya) of having no desire to attend to any second or third person.”
14. The Parable of the Open Wall: The Illusion of Prison
A man surrounded by walls on three sides believes he is imprisoned. Looking behind (to the 1st person), he discovers there was never a fourth wall—he was free all along.
Dialogue: The Parable of the Three Walls
The Man (turning behind and looking): “Ah, here there is no obstacle! Let me run away through this way.”
The Friend: “What! Why do you run away? Is it necessary for you to do so? If you do not run away, will you remain in prison?”
The Man: “Oho! Yes, yes! I was not at all imprisoned! How could I have been imprisoned when there was no wall at all behind me? It was merely my own delusion that I was imprisoned. I was never imprisoned, nor am I now released! So I do not even need to run away from near these walls where I am now! The defect of my not looking behind was the reason for my so-called bondage; and the turning of my attention behind is really the sadhana for my so-called liberation! In reality, I am ever remaining as I am, without any imprisonment or release!”
The two walls in front = 2nd & 3rd persons (world/objects); the open space behind = 1st person (Self). Temporally, walls represent past and future; attending to the true nature of the present dissolves time itself into the eternal Self.
The Meaning of the Three Walls (Space & Time)
“The two walls in the story signify the second and third persons. The first person is the third wall said to be behind the man. There is no way at all to liberation by means of second and third person attention. Only by the first person attention ‘Who am I?’ will the right knowledge be gained that the ego, the first person, is ever non-existent, and only when the first person is thus annihilated will the truth be realized that bondage and liberation are false.
Just as we have explained the three walls as representing the three places (first, second and third persons), we can also explain them as representing the three times: the present, past and future. Even through the attention to the present—avoiding all thoughts of past and future—in order to know what is the truth of the present, all thoughts will subside and the ‘present’ itself will vanish into the eternal Self.”
15. Defining the Real Waking State
Any state where 2nd or 3rd persons (objects/others) are perceived is merely a dream. True Waking is the state of pure, undivided Self-consciousness where nothing is perceived apart from the Self.
True Waking vs. Dream
“‘If it is said that we have awakened from one dream and have come to another dream, the present waking state, why, after we awaken from this waking state, will even that not be another dream like this? How are we to determine, ‘Another awakening is no longer necessary; this is the real waking’?’
Whatever state it may be which we feel to be waking, so long as there is an experience of the existence of any second or third persons, which are other than oneself, it is not at all the real waking state; it is only a dream!
Verily, our real waking (our real state) is that in which our existence alone (not attached to any kind of body) shines unaided and without cognizing anything other than ‘we’. The definition of the correct waking is that state in which there is perfect Self-consciousness and singleness of Self-existence, without the knowledge of the existence of anything apart from Self! From this one can determine the real waking.”
16. Summary: The Direct Path vs. Traditional Methods
| Feature | Traditional Paths (Yoga / Kriya / Raja Yoga / Tantra) | Sri Ramana’s Path (Atma-Vichara) |
|---|---|---|
| Object of Attention | Second/Third persons (chakras, mantras, deities, breath, thoughts) | The First person (the raw subjective feeling “I”) |
| Nature of Practice | Mental action / Doing (Kriya / Karma) | Mental stillness / Non-doing / Pure Being (Summa Iru) |
| Handling Distractions | Witnessing, fighting, or replacing thoughts (Neti, Neti) | Cutting the root instantly: “To whom do thoughts rise?” “Who am I?” |
| Breath Control | Forceful retention (Hatha Kumbhaka) | Spontaneous, effortless retention through intense inner enquiry |
| Subtle Visions/Siddhis | Pursued or cherished as milestones (Visesha-Anubhava) | Banished immediately as 2nd-person distractions via Ramanastram |
| Danger of Deviation | Becoming “fallen from yoga” (Yoga-Bhrashta) | Safeguarded unconditionally by the supreme weapon of enquiry |
| Final Fruit | Attainment of subtle celestial realms (Loka) | Total dissolution of the ego into timeless, formless Awareness |
PART TWO: CREATION, BHAKTI, AND THE NATURE OF LOVE
17. First-Person Research vs. Objective Research: God, World, and Religion
Man’s endless questions and doubts are exclusively directed toward second- and third-person entities: the world and God. No one ever raises doubts about their own existence: “Do I exist or not?”
Because all doubts arise concerning outer objects, mankind has expended its intellectual energy on objective research, neglecting the subject. Lord Buddha remained silent about God, and Bhagavan Sri Ramana repeatedly insisted: “Let us see about God and the world afterwards; first know yourself.”
Philosophical debates over whether the world is real or unreal, sentient or insentient, bliss or misery, are futile mental distractions. Once the ego (“I”) ceases to exist through Self-attention, all duality ends in an experience that is universally agreeable.
First Know Yourself
“Lord Buddha declined to say anything about God in reply to those who asked about Him. But, knowing that it would serve no useful purpose to say anything not only about God but even about the world and its nature, in reply to people who asked about them Sri Bhagavan used to repeatedly insist, ‘Let us see about God and the world afterwards; first know yourself’. ‘The world is real’, ‘No, it is an unreal appearance’; ‘The world is sentient’, ‘It is not’; ‘The world is happiness’, ‘It is not’; - what is the use of arguing thus in vain? Having given up (attending to) the world, having known oneself, and both one and two (thoughts about non-duality and duality) having come to an end - that state in which ‘I’ (the ego) has ceased to exist is agreeable to all.”
Scientific and psychological investigations focus strictly on second- and third-person objects, yielding only a mixture of good and evil (technological advance alongside war and bloodshed). Because modern psychology does not lead to the transcendent peace of Self-knowledge, it is not true first-person research. Only turning inward to discover “Who am I, who knows the mind?” bestows enduring peace.
The True First-Person Research
“Man’s questions and doubts are only about the world and God. Why? Because no man ever raises any questions or doubts about himself, that is, about his knowledge (chit) of his own existence (sat), ‘Do I exist or not?’ Since all doubts rise only about the knowledge which man has of the existence of the world and God, all this time he has been eagerly making research only about these other two entities and not about himself.
And just as the results which have been achieved through other branches of scientific research are only a mixture of good and evil, so the results which have been achieved through psychological research are also only a mixture of good and evil. Therefore, since psychological research has not resulted in the blissful peace of Self-Knowledge, which transcends all such dualities as good and evil, it is clear that such research is not an attention to the correct first person object. Turning one’s attention towards oneself in order to find out ‘Who am I, who knows the mind?’ alone is the correct first person attention. Anyone who attends to himself in this manner, whoever he may be, will certainly attain the true Knowledge of Self.
Bhagavan Sri Ramana was born on earth in modern times in order to reveal that the practice of Self-attention, which is the correct research upon the first person, is the only path which will unfailingly bestow peace, tranquillity and happiness upon man, who has up till now been wasting the immense and precious power of his mind in making research upon second and third person objects, which has resulted in so much war, bloodshed and destruction.”
Religion (mata) can exist only as long as the mind (mati) exists. In the profound silence where the mind has merged into the Heart, sectarian religions cease to stand.
Religion and the Mind
“Religion (mata) will exist only so long as the mind (mati) exists. In the abundantly peaceful great Silence in which that mind has merged in the heart by turning within scrutinizing itself (enquiring ‘who am I, this mind?’), no such religion can stand.”
18. The Three Theories of Creation & The Defect in Outlook (Drishti)
Scriptures present different theories of creation to accommodate different levels of maturity and understanding:
- Srishti-Drishti Vada: The theory of gradual creation—that creation (srishti) occurs prior to and independent of our perception (drishti).
- Drishti-Srishti Vada: The theory of simultaneous creation—that our perception (drishti) is itself the cause of creation (srishti).
- Ajata Vada: The ultimate truth—that neither creation (srishti) nor perception (drishti) has ever occurred at all.
The Three Theories of Creation (Vadas)
“Sri Bhagavan used to explain on many occasions that the Vedas and other scriptures teach so many different theories of creation in order to suit the different levels of maturity and understanding of the people, and that all these countless theories of creation can be classified into three distinct categories, namely (1) srishti-drishti vada or the theory that the creation (srishti) of this world occurs prior to and independent of our seeing (drishti) of it, (2) drishti-srishti vada or the theory that our seeing (drishti) is the cause of the creation (srishti) of this world and (3) ajata vada or the theory that neither creation (srishti) nor seeing (drishti) has ever happened at all.”
The Cinema Projector Analogy
- The Arc-Lamp: The light of Self (God). Without it, no projection on the screen is possible.
- The Film-Reel: Latent mental tendencies (vasanas). Powered by prarabdha karma, the reel spins, causing the individual to perceive a world and mistakenly identify a body as “I”.
- The Jnani’s Screen: In the Jnani, all vasanas have been destroyed. Without the film-reel in the projector, no picture-show of names and forms appears—only the unbroken, unlimited Light of Self-consciousness shines.
The Cinema Projector and the Film-Reel of Vasanas
“If there were no arc-lamp in the cinema projector, the picture show could not appear on the screen. Similarly, if the light of Self were not present, the creation, sustenance of this world could not take place. The light of Self is that which is commonly known by the name ‘God’, and without its presence the acts of creation and sustenance could not take place. For the sake of people who lack sufficient maturity of understanding, this truth is expressed metaphorically in the theory of gradual creation by saying that it is God who creates and sustains this world.
When the film-reel of the tendencies is made to rotate by the power of prarabdha, the individual sees a world corresponding to those tendencies and, having identified a body as ‘I’, experiences a seeming life for himself in that world. If the film-reel were not in the projector, the picture-show consisting of names and forms would not appear on the screen. Instead only a bright light would be seen there. Similarly, what shines in the outlook of the Jnani, in whom all the tendencies have been destroyed, is not this world-picture consisting of names and forms; what the Jnani experiences is only Himself, the unlimited light of Self-consciousness. That is why Sri Adi Sankara says in verse 116 of Aparokshanubhuti: Drishtim jnanamayin kritva pasyet brahmamayam jagat which means, ‘Making one’s outlook of the nature of knowledge (jnanamaya), one should see the world as Brahman’.”
Defect in Outlook, Not in Creation
Transforming the world into heaven or making man immortal is unnecessary; even right now, the world is Brahman and man is the immortal Spirit. The defects we perceive are not flaws in God’s creation (srishti), but distortions in our own outlook (drishti). Rectifying our vision through Self-knowledge reveals all as Brahman.
Defect in Outlook, Not in Creation
“Transforming this world into a heaven devoid of misery and making man immortal are not things which have to be newly done. Even now the world is truly nothing other than Brahman, the blissful Supreme Reality, and man is in his true nature nothing other than Self, the immortal spirit. Therefore the world and man do not now need to be made either blissful or immortal. All that we need to do is to see them as they really are. That is why Sages say, ‘Making one’s outlook of the nature of knowledge, one should see the world as Brahman’ (drishtim jnanamayin kritva pasyet brahmamayam jagat).
The defects which we now see in the world and in man are not defects in God’s creation but are only defects in our own outlook. Therefore there is no use in trying to rectify God’s creation by usurping His power; if we wish to rectify all the defects which we see, we must rectify our own outlook; there is no other way. Those who know the reality will declare that there is no defect in creation (srishti), but that there is a defect only in outlook (drishti).“
19. Tackling ‘I’ vs. ‘Mine’: Karma Yoga as Jamuna, Bhakti & Jnana as Ganges
Vedic codes of conduct, fasting, and charity (Nitya-Karma anushtana) aim to curtail the craving for sense objects and weaken the feeling of “mine” (mamata).
Between the two impurities “I” (ahamkara) and “mine” (mamata), “mine” is more noticeable and tangible, so earnest seekers tackle “mine-ness” first through unselfish service (Karma Yoga).
However, “mine” is merely the leaves and branches of the tree. No matter how many times they are cut, they sprout again under favorable conditions. True liberation requires tracing and uprooting the root: the ego “I”.
The river analogy illustrates this transition:
- The Jamuna: Symbolizes Karma Yoga. It is a tributary that purifies the mind and weakens “mine-ness”.
- The Ganges: Symbolizes Bhakti Yoga (Love) and Jnana Yoga (Knowledge). The Jamuna delivers the seeker into the Ganges, which flows directly and unfailingly into the vast Ocean of Brahman.
The Uprooting of 'Mine' and 'I'
“If we minutely scrutinise every injunction and prohibition such as fasting, charitable deeds and other codes of conduct as enjoined by the Vedas, to be followed by people in their daily actions (Nitya-Karma anushtana), it will become clear that all these aim at making one to sacrifice at least a bit of ‘mine-ness’ and put a check on one’s craving for the worldly enjoyments.
Thus out of the two impurities ‘I’ and ‘mine’, as ‘mine’ is easily noticeable, it is no wonder that all good people with noble aspiration generally first try to tackle only the ‘mine-ness’. For, such a mind which is thus purified through the renunciation of ‘mine-ness’ another truth also will dawn: ‘This ‘mine’ is just like the leaves and branches of a tree. No matter with what effort and how many times they are cut, the leaves and branches - ‘mine-ness’ - will, under favourable conditions, keep on sprouting again and again in some form or other in their own time. Therefore, the root ‘I’ should be traced out and annihilated.’ Even for this truth to dawn, is it not necessary that the restless intensity of ‘mine-ness’ should be lessened to a very great extent? Until this understanding comes to an earnest seeker through the proper discrimination of the purified mind that ‘I’ is the right root-impurity and that it has to be rooted out, service to humanity, sacrifice for others and similar unselfish activities in the line of Karma Yoga will be going on in his life making up the major part of his endeavour.
Then, according to his previous tendencies and tastes he steps into either the path of devotion (Bhakti Yoga) or the path of knowledge (Jnana Yoga) which alone are directly concerned with the annihilation of the ego, the root-impurity. He who was all this time being carried along by the current of the tributary Jamuna, has now been handed over to the Ganges, the mother river. Here the Jamuna symbolizes the path of Karma (Karma Yoga) while the Ganges symbolizes both the path of Love (Bhakti Yoga) and the path of Knowledge (Jnana Yoga). These two are, like the Ganges, ever flowing into the ocean of Brahman unfailingly taking along the aspirant who falls into their current.”
20. The Two Paths to Existence (Sat): Consciousness (Chit) and Love (Ananda)
To attain the Supreme Reality of Sat-Chit-Ananda (Existence-Consciousness-Bliss), Consciousness (Chit) and Bliss (Ananda) serve as the two direct paths to reach pure Existence (Sat):
- Path of Consciousness (Chit): The Path of Knowledge (Jnana Marga).
- Path of Bliss (Ananda / Priya): The Path of Love (Bhakti Marga).
Brahman stretches out its two divine arms—Knowledge and Love—to draw us into Itself. In truth, Brahman lays Itself down as the Path for us to tread upon:
- The Path: Attending to “I am”.
- The Goal: Remaining as “I am”.
The Two Arms of Brahman: Chit and Ananda
“To attain Existence-Consciousness-Bliss (Sat-Chit-Ananda), the Self or Brahman, Consciousness (Chit) and Bliss (Ananda) themselves act as the two Paths i.e., to reach Existence, the Supreme (Sat), Consciousness (Chit) and Bliss (Ananda or Priya) are the only Paths. The Path of Consciousness (Chit) is the Path of Knowledge (Jnana Marga) and the Path of Bliss (Ananda) is the Path of Love (Bhakti Marga).
To say the truth, Brahman, the Sat itself stretches its two arms - Consciousness (Chit) and Bliss (Ananda) to draw us to itself or in other words lays Itself down under our feet as the Path of Knowledge and the Path of Love for us to tread upon. Thus, the holy words, ‘I am the Path and I am the Goal’ are proved. The Path is to attend to ‘I am’ and the Goal is to remain as ‘I am’!“
21. The Evolution of Bhakti: The “School” of Love
Bhakti is the feeling of love, which exists inherently in all beings. In its pure, unconditioned state, Love is Shiva. Like the holy waters of the Ganges, love is inherently pure by nature.
The development of love progresses through distinct standards in the “School” of Bhakti:
| Standard | Stage of Bhakti | Nature of Devotion | Means Employed |
|---|---|---|---|
| Unenrolled | Instinctive Love | Worldly attachment (Vishaya Bhakti) in animals/primitive man | Physical strength and raw instincts |
| I st Standard | Ritual Action | Enjoyment of sense objects fanning the fire of desire | Performance of karmas and rites |
| II nd Standard | Polytheistic Worship | Worldly desires (Vishaya Bhakti) aimed at gaining power | Worship of diverse names and forms of God (e.g., Ravana, Indra) |
| III rd Standard (a) | Single-Deity (Ishta) | Love of objects (Vishaya Bhakti) directed to one Beloved God | One-pointed worship of one chosen deity |
| III rd Standard (b) | Pure Theistic Devotion | Love of God alone (Deiva Bhakti) | Surrender: “God will look after everything; why worry?” |
| IV th Standard | Guru-Bhakti | Climax of dualistic love (Dvaita Bhakti); desires for objects destroyed | Sitting at the Guru’s Feet in the bliss of discrimination (Viveka-Ananda) |
The essence of Bhakti Yoga is to gather scattered thoughts and fix the mind on one thought. Shifting devotion from one deity to another allows the mind to branch out into multiple thoughts; fixing on one form stabilizes the mind.
The School of Bhakti
“What is Bhakti? It is a feeling of love. The feeling of love exists inherently in all creatures. It is to say that whatever one likes, this liking is the love (Bhakti) towards that thing. This liking or love, in its pure state, is Shiva. Love is like the Ganges water. By nature, the water of the Ganges is holy. So is love. Just as love is present in beasts and birds in the form of instincts, in the primitive man the feeling of love is present only in the form of instincts or love for the things of the world (Vishaya Bhakti).
The Man who performs different karmas with great earnestness to appease his many desires, enjoys the results of his karmas in many consecutive births and even in different worlds; but the greater the enjoyments of the objects of the world the more fiercely is set ablaze the fire of his desires… When Ravana, Hiranyakashipu and Indra - (for every mighty one there is a mightier one) - who had become extraordinarily powerful through their worship (Upasana), were sorely discontented and dug their own grave with their jealousy towards each others and cravings for other’s property, how much contentment can the Man secure through his petty power of worship?
The main point of Yoga is to collect the scattered thoughts into one and fix the mind on that one thought only… In the Path of Love (Bhakti Marga) when such confidence in God: ‘God will look after everything in my life; why should I think and worry about it’ increases, thousands of unnecessary thoughts will depart. But this alone is not sufficient. The important point in Bhakti Yoga is to fix the mind on one name and form of God, and not change the worship from one name and form of God to another and thereby allowing the mind to branch out into so many thoughts and waver.
This Guru Bhakti (in the IVth standard) is the climax of all dualistic love (dvaita bhakti). No other form of love (bhakti) excels this. Because of the discrimination (Viveka) which annihilated all his desires for worldly objects the Man now, is sitting at his Guru’s Feet enjoying the Bliss (Ananda) of being fully satisfied in the presence of his Guru (i.e., in the state of Viveka-Ananda).“
22. The Sad-Guru Within: True Guru-Bhakti as Self-Abidance
The Sad-Guru is not merely an external body; the Guru resides within as the true Self. The Self-awareness shining as “I-I” in the Heart is the real, eternal Feet of the Sad-Guru.
Attaining the Self is attaining God and Guru. So long as the Guru is perceived as separate, fear cannot be overcome. Fearlessness exists only in the state of “otherlessness” (non-duality).
Surrendering the ego into the Self (Swatma Bhakti) is the truest, highest love of the Guru (Guru-Bhakti).
The Sad-Guru Within
“Your Sad-Guru is within you. The Self-awareness eternally shining and ever directly experienced as ‘I-I’ within you, is the real Feet of your Sad-Guru. Cling to it. That alone will lead you to the goal.
Attaining the Self alone is to attain God or Guru. On the other hand, so long as you see your God or Guru as different from your Self, you cannot know the Self which is the state of Perfect Freedom. So long as there is the feeling of separateness, fear is bound to be there. If you want to be free from fear (the state of fearlessness) be in the state of otherlessness, Self. But that does not mean that your Guru is no longer there. When you dive within and are established in the heart, you will know that your Self is the true nature of your SadGuru. It is in that state alone that you are ever with your Guru. Your Love of the Self (Swatma Bhakti) i.e., your (ego’s) merging into the Self, is verily your true Love of the Guru (Guru-Bhakti).“
23. Love as Being vs. Desire as Rising (Para Bhakti)
Love that projects outward onto second- and third-person objects is fragmented movement—this is Desire.
When Love abides motionless in itself, it is unbroken, full, and all-pervading:
- Love is our Being: Unbroken Existence (Sat).
- Desire is our rising: The ego’s movement toward objects.
The love of the Self (Swatma Bhakti) is the ultimate refinement of love: Supreme Love (Para Bhakti) and Non-dual Love (Ananya Bhakti). The state of simply being is immutable Bliss (Ananda).
Love is Being, Desire is Rising
“The love that springs upon other things can never be the full one (poorna). When love is full (poorna), the defect in the form of the movement of springing upon other things will not be there. The fullness of love unbroken and all-pervading is ‘Not with an other (Non-dual)‘. He alone who has love, but ‘Not for an other’ (Ananya Bhakti) is one who has the Full Love (Sampoorna Bhakti).
When love abides as itself, it is the full and perfect Love. When the Love takes the form of movement, it is fragmented and becomes desire which springs upon other objects. It is Love when it is in the form of unbroken Existence; it is desire when it is in the form of movement or fragmentation. As second and third person objects are fragments, your love towards them will be in the form of a mere desire - even towards such a loved one as your Guru. But, when the Love abides in the unbroken being of the first person - the Self, It is full and perfect.
This state of Love of Self (Swatma Bhakti) is the final state of refinement of love and is called Supreme Love (Para Bhakti), Non-dual Love (Ananya Bhakti). Hence Love is our Being. Desire is our (ego’s) raising. The state of our just being is the state of immutable Bliss (Ananda), the state of indivisible Supreme Love (Aparichinna Para Bhakti).“
24. Jnana and Bhakti: The Analogy of Gravitation
Jnana (Knowledge) and Bhakti (Love) are not separate or opposing disciplines; they are mutually inseparable aspects of realization:
- Bhakti is the pull of gravitation.
- Jnana is remaining stable upon the earth.
Without the pull of gravitation, stability is impossible; without stability, gravitational attraction has no ground. Neither can exist without the other.
Bhakti and Jnana: The Analogy of Gravitation
“Without the power of gravitation, can anything remain stable on earth? So also, the pull of gravitation is Bhakti; the remaining stable is Jnana. Therefore, neither of them can remain without the other.”

Muni's Play