Peter Fenner - Radiant Mind
Nondual traditions have applied various terms to the experience that marks the full evolution of consciousness: self-knowledge, witness consciousness, no-mind, primordial mind, reality, openness, pure awareness, buddha-nature.
The great Dzogchen master Longchenpa listed an extensive set of terms that refer to this unconditioned reality (Thurman 1996):
This reality has names of many different kinds.
It is “the realm” that transcends life and liberation.
The primally present “natural spontaneity.”
The “essential realm” obscured by defilement.
The “ultimate truth,” the condition of reality.
The originally pure “stainless translucency.”
The “central reality” that dispels extremisms.
The “transcendent wisdom” beyond fabrications.
The “indivisible reality” clear-void-purity.
And the “Suchness” reality free of death transitions.
Such names are accepted by the clear-seeing wise.
According to Garab Dorje (Reynolds 1996), the function of Dzogchen can be described through three key aspects:
- Direct introduction to one’s own real nature
- Clearly recognizing this unique state
- Continuing to abide confidently in this state of freedom
Just as the experience of unconditioned awareness is the ultimate goal of all human endeavors, it’s also the ultimate fruition of the spiritual path.
It’s the only experience that’s completely open, unstructured, and without content, which is why it’s sometimes called “contentless wisdom.”
Radiant mind arises when we rest in unconditioned awareness and allow it to radiate through the totality of our conditioned existence, bringing peace, wisdom, and love to everything we experience.
The nondual experience can be spoken about in terms of three parameters: purity, depth, and duration.
- By purity, I mean the absence of conditioned structures of understanding and interpretation.
- By depth, I mean the extent to which the unconditioned pervades or infuses our conditioned existence.
- By duration, I mean the length of time we can rest in this state.
The more time we spend resting in and enjoying our ultimate nature, the more deeply we appreciate and treasure the experience, and the more naturally and spontaneously we gravitate back to it. In other words, we develop a homing instinct.
Nonduality is the experience that we—as finite, individual selves—are, at our deepest essence, indivisible from an infinite expanse of unconditioned consciousness and bliss.
In Zen, they say that unconditioned awareness is entered through a gateless gateway. The gateway is gateless, not only because there’s no gate, but also because the gateway is always exactly where we are. In the nondual approach, there’s absolutely no effort, struggle, or need to escape from who we are. In fact, any attempt to resist or escape our conditioning blocks us from experiencing our unconditioned nature. Every aspect and dimension of our experience is revealed to be an exquisite expression of freedom and transcendence.
The main characteristics of these two different approaches to the spiritual path can be summarized like this:
| Systems Based on the Need for Change Suggest That: | Systems Based on Immediate Experience Suggest That: |
|---|---|
| This isn’t it. | This is it. |
| We should do more. | We should do less — or do nothing. |
| We should try harder. | No effort is involved. |
| We can control our future. | Life is ultimately choiceless. |
| In order to progress, we need to study, learn, and know more. | Realization is a state of not knowing. |
| Reality is meaningful. | Reality has no real meaning. |
Think About the Following Questions
- If you do enjoy experiences of unconditioned awareness, how do you know they are experiences of unconditioned awareness?
- If you feel that you haven’t experienced unconditioned awareness, how do you know that you haven’t?
- Do these last two questions make you rethink the category to which you belong?
Just Sitting Meditation
“Just sitting” consists of:• Disengaging from high-level external stimulation such as other people, television, books, and computer screens• Sitting in a relatively still position• Being silent and awake• Then doing whatever you are doing• For around twenty minutes each day
Think what you’re thinking; feel what you’re feeling; experience what you’re experiencing.
There’s no need to follow your thoughts, nothing to concentrate on, nothing you need to do.
here’s · nothing to correct or adjust, no guidelines about what you’re supposed to be concentrating on, such as breathing, thoughts, feelings, or sensations.
because there’s no object of meditation and no need to meditate, there are no distractions.
Enjoying your contemplation is no better than enduring it. You don’t even ·need to know why you are doing it. All you need to do is to do itt
WHO AM I?B egin by sitting quietly and resting in unconditioned awareness as much as you can. Then, in a mood of inquiry, gently ask yourself the question “Who am I?”When thoughts, feelings, or experiences arise, inquire, “Who thinks, feels, or experiences that?” If problems arise, you might ask, “Who has that problem? Who is suffering?” Ask each question without expecting an answer. The question isn’t designed to elicit any content. Rather, it points to the uncreated creator of all constructions, unconditioned aware ness. When asking these questions, do not create any pressure - there are no answers!
THE “WHAT IS THI S ? -WHERE IS THAT?” EXERCIS EThis exercise is completed in pairs. One partner is the questioner; the other, the responder. The questioner and responder sit together for a few minutes in silent shared contemplation. The questioner then asks, “What is this?”This question refers to the whole field of experience, both conditioned and uncon ditioned, all the objects of experience, and also the one who is experiencing it all. There is no specific focus for this question. Whenever the responder replies, the questioner asks, “Where is that?” (i.e., “Where is that to which you are referring?” or “Can you find the place where this experience is located?”). The questioner only asks these two questions. The first question is asked only once, to begin the exchange. All questions should be asked from a state of unconditioned awareness, or no-mind. Do not ask the second question as though you believe there is an actual location to the experience. The exercise continues until the responder cannot locate the experience. Once you have completed it in one direction, change roles.
EMBRACING YOURSELF AT A LEVEL B EYOND COMFORT AND CONVENTIONAnother way to move beyond your normal comfort zone is to have a signifi cant communication with one or two people (or types of people) with whom you normally wouldn’t interact. For example, these might be people who you feel aren’t worthy ofyour attention, people you’re averse to, people whose time you wouldn’t want to waste, people who are arrogant, people who live on the street, people who are timid and shy, people whose lives and values you totally disagree with. After interacting with them, take on their values, b eliefs, and behavioral characteristics for a short while. See if you can do this in spite of the resistance you might be feeling. Feel what life might be like for them.
BALANCING S ERENITY AND “SEEING THROUGH”In order to move toward resting in unconditioned awareness, we need to bal ance the experiences of serenity and “seeing through.” If there’s too much serenity and insufficient penetrating insight, or “seeing through,“we may sink into feelings of comfort and tranquility that leave us with little motivation to move through to unconditioned awareness. In other words, we may confuse relative feelings of peace with unconditioned aware ness, which goes beyond relative stillness or movement. If there’s too much critical insight and insufficient serenity, we may be come overly concerned with the acuity of our perceptions, and attached to the releases that happen when we see things from a metaperspective or cut through a fixation with our deconstructive skills . In these situations, we can become overly excited about what we’re seeing in ourselves and others. I invite you to consider your own tendencies and assess your particular ratio of serenity to critical insight. You can do this when you’re “just sitting” or when you’re involved in a nondual teaching. If you’re heavy on the insight, you can ·work to slow down your thinking so that you’re less prone to iden tify with your thoughts. If you’re heavy on tranquility, you can work with inquiry to directly enter a space that transcends any attachment to feelings and sensations.
Stories that may be de constructed include:• Personal beliefs (for example, “I’m a serious person.“)• Spiritual beliefs (for example, “When X happens, Y happens .“)• Constructions about suffering (for example, that it is bad, that it shouldn’t be happening, and that it is happening)• Constructions about fixations (for example, that we shouldn’t have them, and that we’re not enlightened until we remove them)• Stories about enlightenment• Stories about the deconstructive process
Like natural koans, de constructive inquiry should only be used when we sense that the timing is right. We’re inviting ourselves and other people to enter the space of wonderment and uncertainty, and experience what it feels like to not take things for granted. For this to occur, there must be a certain readiness and a level of trust in the relationship.
C H E C K I N G Q U E ST I O N SI n nondual practice, it’s important to b e able to determine the quality and purity of our unconditioned experience. We do this by asking ourselves “checking questions.”
hecking questions include: .. Is anything missing right now? .. Is there anything that we need to be doing at the moment? .. Is there something that we need to be thinking about? .. What would you say I’m doing right now? .. Can this be enhanced? .. What is this that I’m trying to enhance? .. Can we do more of this? .. C ould we lose it? .. Is this pleasurable? .. Where are you now? .. Are we making progress? .. Are we going anywhere? .. Is there anywhere to go?
These are the types of questions that naturally arise in the journey from the conditioned to the unconditioned and can be used to gauge the presence of conceptual residues. In as king these checking questions, we need to take care that they do not provide a trigger for a conceptual construction. Normally, we only ask these questions when we’re in a fairly open and spacious state of being-whe� we sense that we’ve reached a space that transcends loss and gain. If the questions prompt us to elaborate the space conceptually or increase our uncertainty about whether we’re in an unstructured space, then they have missed their in tention. Checking questions often become natural koans because they direct us back to the experience of unconditioned awareness .
egin withthe question “Okay, here I am right now. What do I like, or not like, about what I’m experiencing?” If there’s nothing good or bad about what’s happening, that’s great. If you don’t like what’s happening, start to fill in the blank. S tick with “what’s actually happening,” and resist the temptation to get into the “becauses.” The reasons why we don’t like what’s happening can be endless: “I .don’t like this experience of driving to work because it’s a waste of time, I could be doing something better, the traffic gets worse each year, I might be late for my meeting, it pollutes the environment, and the price of gas just keeps going .up.” Etc., etc. Samsara exists in the reasons!
At some point, after you’ve worked through all the particulars, you’ll con nect with the core structure, “I don’t like this,” and then you’ll lock into the three elements of this structure: “you,” “(not) liking,” and “this.” Perhaps you’ll lock into the “this”-what you’re experiencing as a gestalt, just this. Or per haps you’ll lock into “not liking.” What actually is liking? Where is it? Where does it happen? Or maybe you’ll begin to question “who” it is who’s not liking. Who are “you” who doesn’t like what’s happening? It doesn’t matter which of these you look at; if you look clearly at any of the elements, it will dissolve. All that’s needed to dissolve any of these elements is to move through the experience of not liking what’s happening, until you can see it clearly for what it is - something from your conditioned existence. As · soon as you can see through it, you enter unconditioned aware ness, into radiant mind.
Related Notes:

Muni's Play