Clarifying the Natural State

Notes and quotes from the Mahamudra manual by Dakpo Tashi Namgyal.


Homage to Vajradhara

Respectful homage to glorious Vajradhara.
Out of the unconstructed nature, the emptiness of dharmadhatu,
Appear the magical sceneries of the worlds and beings, profound and brilliant.
To their indivisible identity of empty bliss, spontaneously present from the beginning,
To the all-pervasive original mind, I respectfully bow down.


Part One: Preliminary Steps of Guidance

This has two steps:

  1. General preliminaries
  2. Specific preliminaries

1. General Preliminaries

  • This includes the reflections on the difficult-to-acquire freedoms and riches, impermanence, and so forth.
  • In this way, it is essential to develop a firm attitude of renunciation.

2. Specific Preliminaries

  • Reflect on impermanence: to ward off laziness.
  • Take refuge and form the bodhisattva resolve: to dispel obstacles.
  • Offer mandalas: to gather the accumulations.
  • Meditation and recitation of Vajrasattva: to purify obscurations.
  • Train in guru yoga: to receive blessings.

Instruction

Receive guidance in all of these points one after another and exert yourself in each of them for a suitable number of days, such as five or seven. At the end of each of these practices, gain some experience by relaxing your mind and remaining free and easy for as long as you can.


Part Two: The Main Part of the Meditation Stages

This has two main divisions:

  • Steps of Guidance
    • Guidance through Shamatha
    • Guidance through Vipashyana
  • Steps of Pointing-out Instruction

I. Guidance Through Shamatha

This has two steps:

  1. Shamatha with attributes
  2. Shamatha without attributes

A. Shamatha with Attributes

1. Supported Shamatha (Using an Object)

  • Posture: Assume the seven-fold posture of Vairochana.
  • Daytime: Place a neutral object (a pebble or stick, not too bright) level with your gaze. Rest attention on it gently—neither analyzing nor fixating tightly—simply to prevent wandering.
  • Nighttime: Focus attention on a pea-sized white sphere between the eyebrows.
  • Session Discipline: Keep sessions short and repeat frequently once natural calm arises.
  • Post-Meditation: Maintain quietude of body and mind; avoid entertainment, heavy exertion, and idle chatter.

2. Unsupported Shamatha (Resting in Pure Presence)

a) With Breath Practice (Capturing the Uncaught Mind)
  • Breath Counting: Anchor attention by counting cycles of inhalation and exhalation (starting with 3, then 7 rounds, etc.) with relaxed alertness. Take frequent rests.
  • Apparent Increase in Thoughts: If thoughts seem to multiply, this is not a fault; you are simply noticing the existing torrent for the first time. Neither guide nor pursue thoughts; rest loosely and continue.
  • Forceful Intervention (PHAT!): If stubbornly scattered, shout PHAT! with vigor. This severs the preceding thought before the next can rise; rest in the thought-free gap.
  • Skillful Balance: Recognize inner commentary (“this needs to be done…”) as mere thought projection. Skillfully alternate between focus and relaxation with self-confidence.
b) Without Breath Practice (Stabilizing the Captured Mind)
  • Freedom from the Three Times: Drop attention from external objects, sounds, and breath. Rest lucid and at ease:

    • Past: Do not recall what happened previously.
    • Future: Do not anticipate or plan ahead.
    • Present: Do not fabricate notions about what is occurring now.
    • Keep sessions short, repeating them frequently.
  • Remedies for Hindrances: Over-concentration obstructs lucidity; default to relaxation. For specific imbalances:

    • Agitated / Scattered: Sit in a warmer place, take nourishing food/drink, receive massage, lower your gaze, focus below the navel, and gently hold the breath in the belly.
    • Dull / Sluggish: Sit in a cooler place, splash cold water on your face, expel stale breath, raise your gaze, and sharpen alertness.
    • Drowsy: Stand up and move about to refresh yourself.
    • Obscured / Mentally Dense: Perform purification and merit-making: prostrate before and circumambulate sacred objects, make offerings/alms, sincerely confess misdeeds, and pray fervently for samadhi to arise.

B. Shamatha Without Attributes

This has two points:

  1. Tightening
  2. Loosening

1. Tightening (Sharpening Clarity)

  • Gaze & Posture: Maintain posture; raise your gaze level directly ahead.
  • Precision: Sharpen attention into vivid, one-pointed lucidity without fixating on any particular object or goal.
  • Short Sessions: Practice in brief, repeated intervals to maintain flawless precision.
  • Effect: Transforms dull calm into bright, lucid presence. (If calm periods shorten initially, keep sessions brief and frequent; both stability and clarity will expand.)

2. Loosening (Resting in Natural Ease)

  • Effortless Relaxing: Maintain posture and gaze, but drop all ambition and adjustments. Neither cling to calm nor resent thoughts; let attention settle naturally free and open.
  • Undistracted Openness: Rest vividly present and spacious without fidgeting.
  • Handling Thoughts: Neither suppress nor follow coarse or subtle thoughts. Embrace them with mindful presence—deprived of fuel, they cannot function as thoughts and naturally dissolve into calm.
  • Shift to Spontaneity: Transitions practice from deliberate concentration to effortless, natural undistraction.

The Three Stages of Shamatha

  1. Initial (Mountain Torrent): Fleeting moments of thought-free calm amidst a turbulent rush of gross and subtle thoughts.
  2. Intermediate (Placid River): Thoughts mostly subside into serene stillness, though occasional strong movements still cause distraction.
  3. Ultimate (Ocean Meeting River): Coarse and subtle thoughts cease; any subtle movement instantly dissolves into nonthought without gaining traction.

Foundational Importance

While shamatha alone is not the essence of Mahamudra, it is the indispensable, stable foundation required for insight (vipashyana).


II. Guiding by Means of Vipashyana

This has two parts:

  1. Establishing the identity of mind and the various perceptions
  2. Clearing up uncertainties about basis and expression

A. Establishing the Identity of Mind and Perceptions

This has two points:

  • 1. Establishing the identity of mind — the basis
  • 2. Establishing the identity of thoughts and perceptions — the expression

1. Establishing the Identity of Mind — The Basis

Direct Inquiry into the Mind

Rest in the lucid, thought-free state of shamatha with eyes gazing straight ahead, unblinking. Look directly into the observing mind and scrutinize:

  • Form & Color: What shape or color does it possess?
  • Location & Support: Where does it dwell, and upon what does it rest?
  • Identity: What definable nature or appearance does it have?
Investigating Inside and Outside
  • External vs. Internal: Does the mind dwell in external objects and beings, or within this physical body of karmic ripening?
  • Bodily Location: If within the body, does it occupy a specific spot from the crown of the head to the soles of the feet, or is it all-pervasive?
  • Mode of Pervasion: If pervasive, does it have an inside and outside, or is it diffuse?
  • Movement: If diffuse, how does it move and function when engaging with outer sensory objects?
Examining Emptiness and Lucidity

Investigate whether the mind is identifiable as empty or as aware:

  • Emptiness: Is it empty like nothingness (a blank void), or empty like open space?
  • Lucidity: Is its radiant awareness luminous like the light of the sun and moon, or like the flame of a butter lamp?
  • Probe deeply until you reach unshakeable, experiential certainty—do not settle for philosophical theory or hearsay.
Settling Beyond Conceptual Stillness
  • Intellectually resolving that mind lacks shape, color, location, and substance is easy, but resting in that abstract notion is merely the meditative mood of stillness.
  • Deepen inquiry through devotion: In what precise way is it aware? How is it empty? What is its actual mode of being?
  • Discover directly that mind is an inexpressible yet intimately experienceable aware emptiness (rig-tong).
Testing Authentic Experience
  • The Master’s Test: When the lama challenges the student with confusing or paradoxical statements:
    • Theoretical understanding crumbles under scrutiny.
    • Authentic personal realization remains unshaken, converging on the same essential point even if traditional words fail.
  • Direct Realization: Beyond all words, the mind is not a definable entity, but an intrinsically self-knowing aware emptiness—vivid, clear, and awake. Sustain this without distraction.

2. Establishing the Identity of Thoughts and Perceptions — The Expression

Examining Coarse Thoughts
  • Arouse a vivid, coarse emotional thought—such as fiery anger—within the aware-empty expanse of mind.
  • Look directly into it the instant it arises:
    • What is its exact color and shape?
    • Where does it originate, stay, and find support?
    • What is its concrete identity and appearance?
Examining Subtle Thoughts and Perceptions
  • Subtle Thoughts: Arouse or project a subtle mental movement and dissect its identity in the same manner.
  • Perceptions: Produce various perceptions—of the external world and living beings, enemies and friends, joys and sorrows. Scrutinize the core identity of each.
  • Avoiding Theoretical Generalization: Merely assuming that thoughts are “empty” is a conceptual trap. You must directly recognize their identity upon rising so their false solidity collapses on the spot.
Dissecting the Nature of Aware Emptiness

When claiming that thoughts and perceptions are “aware emptiness”, determine:

  • Timing: Is it aware emptiness only after the thought dissolves, or while the thought is actively present?
  • Direct Seeing:
    • Thoughts: Whatever thought arises, its very nature is unidentifiable—it is unobstructedly aware yet non-conceptual.
    • Perceptions: Sights and sounds are mere impressions of unobstructed presence—insubstantial, vivid, and free of solid reality.
Sustaining Perceiving Emptiness
  • Rest without distraction in this aware emptiness / perceiving emptiness—unfettered awareness devoid of self-nature.
  • Crucial Caution: Do not use “aware emptiness” as an antidote or weapon to dissolve thoughts. True certainty means recognizing that thoughts and perceptions are themselves empty and luminous in the very moment of their arising.

B. Clearing Up Uncertainties About Basis and Expression

This has four points:

  1. Resolving that thoughts are mind
  2. Resolving that perceptions are mind
  3. Investigating the calm and the moving mind
  4. Resolving that all experience is nonarising

1. Resolving that Thoughts are Mind

Investigating Origin, Staying, and Departure
  • Origin: Evenly composed in aware emptiness, project a vivid thought (such as fiery anger). Look directly into it:
    • From what substance or basis did it arise?
    • Did it arise from the empty, aware mind like a child born from its mother or like light shining from the sun?
    • Or did the mind itself become the thought?
  • Staying: When anger is present, observe how it remains:
    • Is it accompanied by intense clinging to things as real, or is it simply an appearance of anger—an open space with no identifiable entity to grasp?
  • Departure: Observe how the thought departs:
    • Does it stop, or does it dissolve?
    • If stopped, who or what made it stop?
    • If it dissolves, does it dissolve due to circumstances, or spontaneously by itself?
    • Examine a variety of coarse and subtle thoughts in this manner to gain direct experiential certainty.
The Wave and Water Metaphor
  • Empty Appearance: Experience that whatever thoughts arise, they are empty appearances devoid of definable substance.
  • Arising and Dissolving in Self: Recognize that thoughts arise out of yourself and dissolve back into yourself.
  • Wave and Water Analogy:
    • A wave is nothing other than water, yet appears as a wave. Though appearing as a wave, it never departs from the nature of water.
    • In the same way, the moment thoughts appear, they are nothing other than the aware emptiness of unidentifiable mind.
    • Because mind’s expressive capacity is unconfined, it manifests as diverse thoughts without ever wavering from aware emptiness. Settle this point decisively.
Opposing Thoughts
  • Arouse a happy thought, then a sad thought.
  • Investigate whether there is any difference in their essential identity.
  • Gain unwavering certainty regarding all opposing types of thoughts.

2. Resolving that Perceptions are Mind

Investigating Visual Perceptions and Mind
  • Rest in aware emptiness and allow any visual form to be vividly experienced. Investigate its arrival, staying, and departure as before.
  • Different or Identical?
    • If perception and mind are different: Are they across from each other, one inside the other, or one above the other? Do they exist as separate, freestanding entities? Or is it merely mind appearing as visual perception? (If mind alone appears, there is only one mind, which contradicts them being different).
    • If perception and mind are identical: Does mind turn into the visual perception, or does the visual perception become mind?
  • Perceived Emptiness:
    • Recognize that whatever form is seen is merely the mind’s unconfined perceiving quality.
    • Every visual form has no definable identity—it is perceived emptiness.
    • Do not split perception and mind into “outside” and “inside”; settle decisively that perceptions and mind are indivisible.
The Dream and Mirror Metaphors
  • The Dream Metaphor: External forms appearing in a dream are nothing other than the dreaming mind itself—the dream appearances and the dreaming mind are indivisible.
  • The Mirror Metaphor:
    • Present experiences appear through the power of shared karma, like a clear mirror reflecting a blue object.
    • The mirror appears blue, yet it never turns into anything other than a clear mirror.
    • Likewise, while unconfined mind is influenced by karma, it appears in myriad ways upon encountering objects, yet never turns into anything other than mind itself.
Opposing and Multi-Sensory Perceptions
  • Opposing Perceptions: Investigate opposing visual forms, such as the beautiful and the ugly.
  • All Five Senses: Extend the same inquiry from visual forms to sounds, odors, flavors, and physical textures, until certainty is established across all sensory experience.

3. Investigating the Calm and the Moving Mind

Comparing Calm (Ne-pa) and Thought Movement (Gyu-wa)
  • Settle serenely in aware emptiness and look directly into this calm.
  • While in serene calm, allow a thought to vividly stir; look directly into this stirring movement.
  • Investigate Differences:
    • Is there any difference in their arrival, staying, and departure, or in their core identity?
    • Does their difference consist in one being better or worse, empty or not empty, or identifiable vs. unidentifiable?
Recognizing Single Nature and Natural Freedom
  • Discard the notion that serene calm (ne-pa) and abrupt thought movement (gyu-wa) are two different substances.
  • Realize they are the same single mind—rootless, intangible, self-knowing, and naturally pure aware emptiness.
  • Free of acceptance and rejection, repression and encouragement:
    • Aware emptiness is naturally free in stillness when calm.
    • Aware emptiness is naturally free in arising when thoughts occur.

4. Resolving that All Experience is Non-Arising

The Unborn, Rootless, and Self-Liberated Mind
  • Look directly into the natural state of mind itself—the source of all unconfined thoughts and perceptions:
    • Beginning: Unborn. It was not produced from causes or conditions, nor did it arise from any basis whatsoever—it is rootless from the beginning.
    • Present: Non-abiding. It does not exist as any shape, color, or form; it is entirely unidentifiable.
    • End: Unceasing yet self-liberating. Without being stopped by anyone, it is self-dissolving, self-clearing, and self-liberated.
  • Beyond Improvement or Degradation:
    • Experience mind as self-knowing emptiness that cannot be pinpointed as arising, dwelling, or ceasing.
    • It cannot be improved by the good or worsened by the bad.
    • It requires no fine-tuning, fabrication, or correction.
Vipashyana Insight vs. Conceptual Labeling
  • These investigations must be experienced directly through vipashyana insight within the meditative composure of aware emptiness.
  • If examined merely through conceptual labeling or philosophical analysis, one gains only an intellectual idea, failing to generate authentic personal experience.

Interlude: Prerequisites for the Pointing-Out Instruction

Necessity of Experiential Certainty

  • Pointing-out instruction must not be given before the meditator has resolved these inquiries through direct certainty.
  • Without certainty, students will doubt the instruction and seek other paths, or cling to meditative moods and stagnate in ordinary shamatha without reaching enlightenment despite years of effort.

The Three Capacities of Students

  • Highest Acumen: Must attain direct realization.
  • Middling Acumen: Must attain authentic experience.
  • Lesser Acumen: Must reach a stable understanding.
  • (Mere intellectual understanding without experience is never sufficient).

The Master’s Guidance and Restraint

  • Some can explain well but lack experience; others have experience but cannot articulate it.
  • The master skillfully guides using counter-arguments, hints, and paradoxical questions (“pulling the wool over their eyes”) to test genuine experience.
  • Even when authentic experience occurs, the pointing-out instruction should not be given too liberally until the experience has deepened and matured.

Integrating Investigation with Shamatha

  • Whether alternating vipashyana guidance with pointing out or investigating during pointing out, the best approach is using investigation to resolve and bring forth decisive personal experience first.
  • If personal experience is not yet established, the student should train in bringing forth the awake quality within shamatha until a stable foundation is achieved.

III. Steps of the Pointing-Out Instruction

This has two parts:

  1. The actual pointing-out of the innate
  2. Eradicating faults and identifying the meditation practice

A. The Actual Pointing-Out of the Innate

This has three aspects:

  1. Pointing out innate mind-essence
  2. Pointing out innate thinking
  3. Pointing out innate perception

1. Pointing Out Innate Mind-Essence

Setting and Posture
  • When giving the pointing-out instruction, no one else should be present besides the master and disciple.
  • The disciple assumes the meditation posture as before.
Pointing Out Shamatha
  • The master instructs:

    “Let your mind be as it naturally is without trying to correct it. Now, isn’t it true that all your thoughts, both subtle and gross, subside in themselves? Rest evenly and look to see if this mind doesn’t remain calm in its own natural state.”

  • The master lets the disciple look directly:

    “That’s called shamatha.”

Pointing Out Vipashyana
  • The master continues:

    “During this state, do not become dull, absent-minded, or apathetic. Is it not true that you cannot verbally formulate that the identity of this mind is such-and-such, nor can you mentally form a thought of it? Rather, isn’t it a totally unidentifiable, aware, unconfined, and lucid wakefulness that knows itself by itself?
    Within the state of evenness, look to see whether it isn’t an experience without any ‘thing’ experienced.”

  • The master lets the disciple look directly:

    “That’s called vipashyana.”

The Unity of Shamatha and Vipashyana
  • The master explains:

    “Here, these two are mentioned sequentially, but in actuality this kind of shamatha and vipashyana are not separate.
    Rather, look to see if this shamatha isn’t the vipashyana that is an unidentifiable, self-knowing, natural awareness. Also look to see if this vipashyana isn’t the shamatha of abiding in the natural state untainted by conceptual attributes. Rest evenly and look!”

  • The master lets the disciple look directly:

    “That’s called the unity of shamatha and vipashyana.”

The Birth of Meditation Practice and Its Names
  • The master declares:

    “Both are contained within your present mind. Experiencing and recognizing this is called the birth of meditation practice.
    This is what is given many names, such as buddhamind, mind-essence of sentient beings, nonarising dharmakaya, basic natural state, innate mind, original wakefulness, Mahamudra, and so forth. And this is what all the sutras and tantras, true treatises, and instructions aim at and lead to.”

The Meaning in a Nutshell & Continuity
  • Rather than confusing students with overly long explanations, the essential instruction is summarized:

    “The meaning in a nutshell is this: allow your mind to be as it naturally is, and let thoughts dissolve in themselves. This is your innate mind, which is an unidentifiable, self-knowing, natural awareness. Remain one-pointedly in its continuity and do not get distracted.”

  • Post-Meditation Mindfulness: Maintain this mindful presence undistractedly during daily activities between formal sessions.
  • Diligence: Train persistently for several days so this direct seeing of mind-essence does not slip away.

2. Pointing Out Innate Thinking

Direct Inquiry into an Arising Thought
  • The disciple assumes the posture in front of the master, who instructs:

    “Let your mind remain in its natural way. When thoughts have subsided, your mind is an intangible, aware emptiness. Be undistracted and look directly into the identity of this naked state!
    At this moment, allow a feisty thought, such as delight, to take form. The very moment it vividly occurs, look directly into its identity from within the state of aware emptiness.
    Now, is this thought the intangible and naked state of aware emptiness? Or is it absolutely no different from the identity of innate mind-essence itself? Look!”

Testing the Disciple’s Experience
  • When the disciple responds: “It is the aware emptiness. There seems to be no difference”, the master probes:
    1. “Is it an aware emptiness after the thought has dissolved?”
    2. “Or, is it an aware emptiness by driving away the thought by meditation?”
    3. “Or, is the vividness of the thought itself an aware emptiness?”
  • Assessment:
    • If the student answers (1) or (2), they have not cleared up former doubts and must be sent back to resolve this in meditation for a few days.
    • If the student experiences (3)—that the vividness of the thought itself is aware emptiness—they have seen the true identity of thought.
Seeing the Natural Face of Innate Thought
  • The master delivers the pointing-out instruction:

    “When you look into a thought’s identity, without having to dissolve the thought and without having to force it out by meditation, the vividness of the thought is itself the indescribable and naked state of aware emptiness. We call this seeing the natural face of innate thought or thought dawns as dharmakaya.
    Previously, when you determined the thought’s identity and when you investigated the calm and the moving mind, you found that there was nothing other than this intangible single mind that is a self-knowing, natural awareness. It is just like the analogy of water and waves.”

Transcending Bias and the “Meditation Famine”
  • The master questions:

    “This being so, is there any difference between calm and movement?
    Is there any difference between thinking and not thinking?
    Is it better to be serenely calm? Do you need to be elated about it?
    Is it worse when a thought abruptly arises? Do you need to be unhappy about it?
    Unless you perceive this hidden deception, you will suffer the meditation famine.

    So, from now on, when a thought does not arise you need not deliberately make one arise so as to train in the state of its arising, and when the thought does arise you need not deliberately prevent it, so as to train in the state of its nonarising. Thus, do not be biased toward calm or movement.”

  • Training: Apply this principle to all thoughts. For a period, deliberately conjure a thought when none arises to sustain its essence, preventing the identity of thought from slipping away. Practice diligently for several days.

3. Pointing Out Innate Perception

Direct Inquiry into a Visual Perception
  • Maintaining posture, the master asks:

    “While in the composure of the natural state, allow a visual perception, such as that of a mountain or a house, to be vividly experienced. When looking directly at the experience, is this perception itself an intangible aware emptiness? Or, is it the aware and empty nature of mind? Look for a while to see what the difference between them is.”

Testing the Disciple’s Experience
  • When the disciple responds: “There is no difference. It is an intangible, aware emptiness”, the master probes:
    1. “Is it an aware emptiness after the perceived image has disappeared?”
    2. “Or, is the image an aware emptiness by means of cultivating the aware emptiness?”
    3. “Or, is the perceived image itself an aware emptiness?”
  • Assessment:
    • If answering (1) or (2), the disciple must be sent back to investigate and meditate.
    • If experiencing (3)—that the vividly perceived visual image itself (unidentifiable other than as a mere presence of unconfined perception) is aware emptiness—the master gives the pointing-out instruction.
Seeing the Natural Face of Innate Perception
  • The master instructs:

    “When you vividly perceive a mountain or a house, no matter how this perception appears, it does not need to disappear or be stopped. Rather, while this perception is experienced, it is itself an intangible, empty awareness. This is called seeing the identity of perception.
    Previously you cleared up uncertainties when you looked into the identity of a perception and resolved that perceptions are mind. Accordingly, the perception is not outside and the mind is not inside. It is merely, and nothing other than, this empty and aware mind that appears as a perception. It is exactly like the example of a dream-object and the dreaming mind.
    From the very moment a perception occurs, it is a naturally freed and intangible perceiving emptiness. This perceiving yet intangible and naked state of empty perception is called seeing the natural face of innate perception or perception dawning as dharmakaya.”

Transcending Bias Between Perception and Emptiness
  • The master concludes:

    “This being so, ‘empty’ isn’t something better and ‘perceiving’ isn’t something worse, and perceiving and being empty are not separate entities. So, you can continue training in whatever is experienced.
    When perceiving, in order to deliberately train in perception, there is no need to arrest it. When empty, in order to deliberately train in emptiness, you do not need to produce it.
    Whenever you recall the mindful presence of practice, all of appearance and existence is the Mahamudra of dharmakaya, without the need to adjust, accept or reject. And so, from now on, continue the training without being biased toward perception or emptiness by repressing or encouraging either of them.”

  • Training: Allow various perceptions to occur while remaining undistracted in sustaining the unidentifiable essence. Train for several days.

B. Eradicating Faults and Identifying the Meditation Practice

This has two parts:

  1. Describing mistakes and faulty meditation
  2. Explaining flawless meditation practice

1. Describing Mistakes and Faulty Meditation

The Shortcomings of Exclusive Mental Calm
  • The Frozen Lake: Placing exclusive emphasis on mental calm makes the calm mind like a lake frozen over with ice, causing all gross and subtle perceptions of the six senses to cease. Believing this cessation to be the true meditation state is a grave fault.
  • The Inert State: If perceptions do not cease completely but become hazy, dim, and unclear, this is the defect known as the inert state.
  • Oblivion & Mindlessness: Remaining in a mindless stupor that fails to notice what is or isn’t—lost in oblivion with no awareness of what is occurring.
  • The Vacant Gap: Resting in a blank, vacant state between thoughts (after a preceding thought has ceased and before the next arises) without vipashyana awareness. These states are grave faults when unilluminated by insight.
  • Meditation Famine from Rigid Fixation: Even when embraced by vipashyana, feeling that one must remain rigidly unmoved from this maintaining of Mahamudra turns the practice into a meditation famine.
Faults Regarding Bliss and Perceptions
  • Unembraced Bliss: Indulging in a state full of bliss that is not embraced by vipashyana.
  • Perceptions as Enemies: Feeling that one must forcefully block perceptual experiences, or regarding perceptions as hostile opponents to be eliminated.
  • Clinging to Inconcreteness: Clinging to the rigid intellectual stance that all perceptions—whatever appears and is experienced—are insubstantial and empty. This clinging to inconcreteness is a grave error.
  • Indifferent Calm: Absent-mindedly ignoring perceptual experience without accepting or rejecting; this is mere indifferent calm and an ordinary worldly state.
Faults Regarding Thoughtlessness and Over-Effort
  • Obsession with Thoughtlessness: Exclusively regarding a lucid, thought-free state as meditation. While lucid awareness after a thought has subsided is genuine meditation, demanding that one must always be thought-free is imperfect. Similarly, compulsively interrupting a thought to force a lucid, thought-free state shows that the nature of thought movement and perception has not yet been realized.
  • Excessively Strained Mindfulness: Forcing a wide-awake state through intense, rigid mindfulness while rejecting natural, relaxed ease. Preferring tight over-concentration causes exhaustion and risks wearying of practice.
  • The Comfortable Middle Way: Investigate and balance focusing and relaxing across all situations—perceiving or empty, thinking or calm—to discover an effortless, natural way to sustain practice.

2. Explaining Flawless Meditation Practice

Undistracted Ordinary Mind (Tha-mal-gyi Shes-pa)
  • Definition: Authentic meditation is resting in undistracted ordinary mind—the mind’s uncontrived, natural state.
  • Non-Adjustment: The moment you attempt to correct, judge, accept, or reject your state, it ceases to be ordinary mind.
  • The Core Paradox of Practice:

    “While there isn’t even as much as an atom to cultivate by meditating, you shouldn’t be distracted for even as long as an instant.”

  • Simply maintain the mind as it naturally is with an awake, naturally aware presence—that alone is called “meditating.”
Sustaining Mindfulness Through All Conditions
  • Omnipresence of Practice: As long as naturally aware mindful presence does not wander, it remains authentic meditation under all conditions:
    • Whether utterly empty or serenely blissful.
    • Whether thoughts flow in a turbulent rush or manifold perceptions appear vividly.
  • Waves and Ocean Analogy: Mind-essence, thoughts, and perceptual experiences are not separate entities; they are the unconfined expressions of the single mind, just as waves are nothing other than the ocean.
  • Effortless Equanimity:
    • Sustain presence of mind in stillness when calm, in thinking when thoughts occur, and in perceiving when perceptions arise.
    • Do not try to think when still, nor deliberately prevent a thought when it arises.
    • Clear, empty, blissful, or restless—remain undistracted without modifying or correcting anything.

    “In short, everything is meditation training when you have naturally aware presence of mind, and nothing is meditation when you are distracted.”

The Maturation of Mindfulness
  • Smooth Sailing: When mindfulness and mind are no longer separate entities, all of experience transforms into the nature of mindful presence.
  • Gradual vs. Instantaneous Practitioners:
    • Instantaneous (cig-car-ba): A rare few with exceptional karmic readiness can sustain mindfulness directly from the outset without steps.
    • Gradual (rim-gyis-pa): Most must follow sequential guidance to clear doubts through experiential investigation; otherwise, mindfulness remains superficial and cannot pierce to the essence.
  • The Ultimate View: All sutras, tantras, and teachings of Indian and Tibetan mahasiddhas converge on this single realization of ordinary mind (tha-mal-gyi shes-pa) and uncontrived natural mind (ma-bcos rang-babs-kyi sems).

Part Three: Subsequent Ways to Continue the Training

This has six points:

  1. General reasons for meditation training
  2. Special training without separating meditation and post-meditation
  3. Cutting through hindrances, sidetracks, and strayings
  4. Enhancing by transcending into nonarising
  5. Developing strength through utilizing the conducts
  6. How realization arises and the enhancement practices

1. General Reasons for Meditation Training

Sustaining the Realization
  • It is not enough that authentic meditation practice has taken birth; it must be sustained flawlessly.
  • Without sustaining it, one either slips back into ordinary confusion or expends effort in conceptual gathering and purifying practices.
  • The Straying: Straying from this innate meaning is like a king behaving like a common subject, or a lion joining a pack of dogs.
The Six Supports of Meditation Practice
  1. Revulsion is the Feet (The Guardian): Contemplate the suffering of samsara and the impermanence of this life. Cut worldly ties and resolve to equalize life and Dharma practice.
  2. Devotion is the Head (The Enhancement): Entrust yourself fully and make sincere supplications to the guru and Kagyu lineage masters, never wavering from seeing them as living buddhas.
  3. Mindfulness is the Watchman (The Heart): Never forsake mindfulness. Do not confine it to formal sessions; train in constant companionship by recalling the natural state at all times and in all situations.
  4. Compassion is the Activity: Cultivate loving-kindness, compassion, and bodhichitta for all sentient beings, encompassing them with dedication and aspiration.
  5. Seclusion as Protection: Until reaching full perfection in training, remain in secluded retreat. Regard premature “benefiting others” through teaching and propagating Dharma as obstacles of Mara.
  6. Conscience and Modesty are the Armor: Inwardly take your own mind as witness; outwardly avoid creating causes of displeasure for your teacher or spiritual friends. Exert yourself through strict mountain retreat, seclusion, and silence.

2. Special Training Without Separating Meditation and Post-Meditation

The Core Principle
  • Everything is meditation training as long as your naturally aware presence of mind does not wander.
The Three Manners and Nine Essential Points

To sustain the essence, remain in three manners:

  1. Fresh (So-ma):
    • Body: Relax deeply from within (releasing excessive tension without casting away posture).
    • Speech: Do not force or control the breath.
    • Mind: Remain unconcerned, without taking anything as support.
  2. Artless (Rang-babs):
    • Leave the mind as it naturally is.
    • Leave it without fabricating a definable entity.
    • Remain undistracted.
  3. Unbound (Lhug-pa):
    • Remain free from accepting and rejecting.
    • Remain effortless without striving.
    • Leave the six sense impressions in their naturalness.
Five Analogies for the Practice
  • Sky: Elevate your experience and remain wide-open like the sky.
  • Earth: Expand your mindfulness and remain pervasive like the earth.
  • Mountain: Steady your attention and remain unshakable like a mountain.
  • Flame: Brighten your awareness and remain shining like a flame.
  • Crystal: Clear your thought-free wakefulness and remain lucid like a crystal.
Three Analogies for Composure
  • Cloudless Sky: Unobscured, remain in lucid and intangible openness.
  • Wave-Free Ocean: Unmoving, remain in complete ease, undisturbed by thoughts.
  • Sheltered Flame: Unchanging and brilliant like a flame sheltered from wind, remain utterly clear and bright.
Three Sequential Stages of Instruction
  1. Relaxation: Suspend all effort and deeply relax body and mind. Naturalness is the primary physical key point.
  2. Freshness: Settle in uncontrived freshness without indecision or ambitious goal-seeking, avoiding hazy apathetic moods while maintaining naked, lucid presence.
  3. Non-Arising: Maintain practice after resolving that all perceptions are non-arising and naturally freed. Every perception dissolves the instant it is embraced by aware presence; train in not pinpointing anything rather than applying conceptual labels.
Handling Imbalances & The Herdsman Metaphor
  • If dullness or agitation arises, apply specific remedies and stabilize one-pointed focus like a stake driven into the ground.
  • When tired of tight concentration, maintain a constant, naturally aware presence during breaks and daily activities.
  • The Competent Herdsman Metaphor:

    Just as a competent herdsman lets his cattle roam and graze freely without constantly corralling them—simply keeping sight of them—you do not need to block or control thoughts and perceptions.
    Merely sustain a naturally aware presence of mind, continuing with unbound ease without pinpointing whatever is experienced.

Unifying Composure and Daily Life
  • Continuously sustain lucid, undistracted presence through the four daily activities (walking, sitting, standing, lying down).
  • Spontaneous presence expands until every thought and perception is directly experienced as aware emptiness upon rising.
  • Formal composure (samahita) and post-meditation mindfulness (post-samahita) become indistinguishable.
  • Caution with Meditative Moods (Nyams): Meditative moods of bliss, clarity, and nonthought will arise. Do not indulge or keep company with them, as they obscure the natural state. Repeatedly extricate your mind and return to the fresh, naked state.

3. Cutting Through Hindrances, Sidetracks, and Strayings

The Danger for Beginners

Students of limited learning who spend little time with their master risk falling into severe sidetracks and strayings due to intellectualization or attachment to meditative moods.

The Four Strayings Regarding Emptiness
  1. Straying with Regard to the Nature of Knowables:
    • True View: The indivisible unity of perception and emptiness, endowed with the supreme of all aspects.
    • Basic Straying: Nihilistically dismissing karma and ethics, believing virtue and vice are totally inconsequential in “empty space.”
    • Temporary Straying: Articulating the view well conceptually, but failing to bring it into living personal experience.
  2. Straying with Regard to the Path:
    • True View: The indivisible unity of path and fruition; the fruit is innate from the beginning.
    • Basic Straying: Believing the path is the practice and the fruit is an external attainment to be achieved in the future.
    • Temporary Straying: Possessing the true practice, but distrusting it and seeking something “superior” elsewhere, or adding conceptual embellishments.
  3. Straying with Regard to the Remedy:
    • True View: The indivisible unity of what is discarded (spang-ba) and its remedy (gnyen-po); by recognizing its natural face, the emotion becomes its own remedy.
    • Basic Straying: Splitting the emotion and the practice as two separate things, using meditation as a weapon or antidote against emotion.
    • Temporary Straying: Believing one can only meditate after emotional difficulties or disturbing situations have subsided.
  4. Straying with Regard to Generalization:
    • True View: The indivisible unity of means and knowledge; all phenomena are the essence itself.
    • Basic Straying: Abstractly generalizing through conceptual focus that everything lacks self-nature.
    • Temporary Straying: Clinging to past experiences wanting to recreate them, or judging: “I dislike the present state; I must create a better one later!”
Sidetracks: Clinging to the Three Meditative Moods (Nyams)
  • Rigorous practice brings wondrous experiences of bliss, clarity, and nonthought:
    • Bliss Experiences: Physical ecstasy, feeling immune to heat or cold, lightness where the body is forgotten, joyful laughter, losing track of day and night.
    • Clarity Experiences: Lucid transparency, heightened vision in the dark, luminous displays, clairvoyant intuition of others’ minds.
    • Nonthought Experiences: Visions of empty forms, insubstantiality, perception devoid of concepts, deep voidness.
  • The Karmic Trap of Clinging:
    • Clinging to Bliss leads to rebirth in the Desire Realm (Kamadhatu).
    • Clinging to Clarity leads to rebirth in the Form Realm (Rupadhatu).
    • Clinging to Nonthought leads to rebirth in the Formless Realm (Arupadhatu).
  • Three Categories of Experiences:
    • Shamatha-connected: Often foster trancelike absorption that impedes progress.
    • Vipashyana-connected: When sustained free from clinging, moods dissolve naturally and accelerate insight.
    • Realization-connected: Pure and beyond straying.
  • Instruction: Smash attachment to all trancelike absorptions and meditative moods; do not allow them to eclipse the natural state.

4. Enhancing by Transcending into Nonarising

This has five parts:

  1. The time for transcending
  2. Investigating thoughts and perceptions
  3. Investigating the meditation and the meditating mind
  4. The actual transcending into nonarising openness
  5. Mingling meditation and post-meditation, day and night

5. Developing Strength Through Utilizing the Conducts

This has seven points:

  1. The time for utilizing the conducts
  2. Utilizing thoughts
  3. Utilizing emotions
  4. Utilizing gods and demons
  5. Utilizing suffering
  6. Utilizing sickness
  7. Utilizing the process of dying

6. How Realization Arises and the Enhancement Practices

(The Four Yogas of Mahamudra)

This has five points:

  1. The various ways realization arises
  2. One-Pointedness (Rtse-gcig) and its enhancement
  3. Simplicity (Spros-bral) and its enhancement
  4. One Taste (Ro-gcig) and its enhancement
  5. Non-Meditation (Sgom-med) and its enhancement

Related Notes: