Ātma Vicāra in Aparokṣānubhūti
In the Aparokṣānubhūti (“Direct Realization of the Self”), Adi Shankaracharya presents Ātma Vicāra (Self-Inquiry) not as an academic exercise or idle speculation, but as the direct, practical method for dispelling the primal ignorance (avidyā) that binds consciousness to the body-mind complex.
While later traditions (such as that of Sri Ramana Maharshi) distilled Self-Inquiry into the singular investigation into the source of the “I”-thought, Shankaracharya outlines the dialectical mechanics of inquiry: discriminating the Seer from the Seen, formulating the direct question of identity, systematically negating false identifications (neti neti), and exposing the irrationality of superimposing the perishable body upon the partless Atman.
1. The Foundation of Inquiry: Discrimination (Viveka)
Before inquiry can bear fruit, the mind must establish firm conviction regarding what is real (satya) and what is transient (anitya). This begins with the discernment between the Subject (Dṛk, the Seer) and the Object (Dṛśya, the Seen).
Verse 5: The Nature of Discrimination
Sanskrit
नित्यमात्मस्वरूपं हि दृश्यं तद्विपरीतगम्। एवं यो निश्चयः सम्यग्विवेको वस्तुनः स वै।।
Transliteration
Nityamātmasvarūpaṃ hi dṛśyaṃ tadviparītagam. Evaṃ yo niścayaḥ samyagviveko vastunaḥ sa vai
Swami Vimuktananda's Translation
Atman (the seer) in itself is alone permanent, the seen is opposed to it (i.e., transient) – such a settled conviction is truly known as discrimination.
Key Insight
- The Seer vs. The Seen: The nature of the Self (Ātmasvarūpa) is immutable and eternal (nitya). Everything perceived—thoughts, sensations, the physical universe—is the “seen” (dṛśya) and inherently opposite (viparīta): unstable, contingent, and perishable.
- Settled Conviction (Niścaya): Self-inquiry cannot proceed on intellectual curiosity alone; it requires an unshakable conviction that nothing observable can constitute one’s true identity.
2. The Core Questions of Self-Inquiry
In Verse 12, Shankaracharya defines the exact questions that constitute authentic philosophical and contemplative inquiry (vicāra).
Verse 12: The Structure of Inquiry
Sanskrit
कोऽहं कथमिदं जातं को वा कर्तास्य विद्यते। उपादानं किमस्तीह विचारः सोऽयमीदृशः।।
Transliteration
Ko’haṃ kathamidaṃ jātaṃ ko vā kartāsya vidyate. Upādānaṃ kimastīha vicāraḥ so’yamīdṛśaḥ
Swami Vimuktananda's Translation
Who am I ? How is this (world) created ? Who is its creator ? Of what material is this (world) made ? This is the way of that Vichara (enquiry).
Key Insight
- The Primary Question (“Who am I?“): The point of departure for all spiritual freedom is Ko’ham? (“Who am I?”). All cosmic and philosophical questions ultimately fold into this existential enquiry into the nature of the conscious subject.
- The Causality of the Universe: Understanding the efficient cause (kartā) and the material cause (upādāna) leads to the Advaitic revelation that Brahman is both the non-dual material and intelligent cause of appearance, just as gold is the sole substance of golden ornaments.
3. The Negative Dialectic: Dis-identification (Neti Neti)
Having posed the question “Who am I?”, the immediate next step is the process of exclusion (apavāda). The seeker investigates the elements of experience and recognizes what one is not.
Verse 13: Negation of Body and Senses
Sanskrit
नाहं भूतगणो देहो नाहं चाक्षगणस्तथा । एतद्विलक्षणः कश्चिद्विचारः सोऽयमीदृशः ॥ १३॥
Transliteration
Nāhaṃ bhūtagaṇo deho nāhaṃ cākṣagaṇastathā. Etadvilakṣaṇaḥ kaścidvicāraḥ so’yamīdṛśaḥ
Swami Vimuktananda's Translation
I am neither the body, a combination of the (five) elements, nor am I an aggregate of the senses; I am something different from both. This is the way of that Vichara (enquiry).
Key Insight
- Neither Physical nor Sensory: The body is an assemblage of inert gross elements (bhūtagaṇa), and the sense organs (akṣagaṇa) are instruments of perception. An instrument cannot be the conscious user of that instrument.
- Distinct from Both (Etad-vilakṣaṇaḥ): The conscious Self transcends the aggregate of gross elements and faculties; it is the witnessing principle entirely distinct (vilakṣaṇa) from its perceived coverings.
4. Exposing the Absurdity of Superimposition (Adhyāsa)
Self-inquiry reaches a decisive turning point when the intellect recognizes the sheer category error of mistaking the body for the Self.
Verse 17: Exposing the Error of Body-Identity
Sanskrit
आत्मा विनिष्कलो ह्येको देहो बहुभिरावृतः । तयोरैक्यं प्रपश्यन्ति किमज्ञानमतः परम् ॥ १७॥
Transliteration
Ātmā viniṣkalo hyeko deho bahubhirāvṛtaḥ. Tayoraikyaṃ prapaśyanti kimajñānamataḥ param
Swami Vimuktananda's Translation
Atman is verily one and without parts, whereas the body consists of many parts; and yet people see an identity between these two! What can be greater ignorance than this?
Key Insight
- Partless Unity vs. Composite Diversity: The Atman is indivisible (viniṣkala), partless, and non-dual (eka). The body is composite, consisting of limbs, tissues, fluids, and constantly shifting parts (bahubhir āvṛtaḥ).
- The Supreme Ignorance: To conflate that which is indivisible, conscious, and eternal with a divisible, unconscious, and decaying conglomerate is the ultimate absurdity (kim ajñānam ataḥ param). Exposing this irrationality dissolves the false sense of embodiment.
5. Deeper Inquiry: Negation of the Subtle Body (Liṅga Śarīra)
Having negated the gross physical body, Self-Inquiry must proceed inwards to the subtle body (sūkṣma or liṅga śarīra)—the psychological apparatus composed of the mind (manas), intellect (buddhi), life-forces (prāṇas), and the ego-sense (ahaṅkāra). Seekers often fall into the trap of identifying with the mind or the “internal witness” idea; Shankaracharya applies ruthless discrimination to show that the subtle body is also merely an object of perception.
Verse 39: The Transience and Objectivity of the Subtle Body
Sanskrit
लिङ्गं चानेकसंयुक्तं चलं दृश्यं विकारि च। अव्यापकमसद्रूपं तत्कथं स्यात्पुमानयम्।।
Transliteration
Liṅgaṃ cānekasaṃyuktaṃ calaṃ dṛśyaṃ vikāri ca. Avyāpakamasadrūpaṃ tatkathaṃ syātpumānayam
Swami Vimuktananda's Translation
Even the subtle body consists of many parts and is unstable. It is also an object of perception, is changeable, limited and non-existent by nature. So how can this be the Purusha?
Key Insight
- The Sixfold Flaws of the Subtle Body:
- Aneka-saṃyuktam (Composite): It is an aggregate of seventeen subtle factors (five organs of perception, five organs of action, five vital prāṇas, mind, and intellect), and anything composite is non-eternal.
- Calam (Unstable): Mental states and thoughts are continuously in flux.
- Dṛśyam (Object of Perception): Thoughts, emotions, and memories are observed by consciousness; that which is seen cannot be the ultimate Seer.
- Vikāri (Subject to Change): The psyche alternates between joy, sorrow, sleep, and waking.
- Avyāpakam (Limited): The mind is localized and non-all-pervading.
- Asad-rūpam (Dependent / Unreal): The mind has no autonomous existence apart from the illumination of the Atman.
- The Ultimate Discrimination: Since the subtle body shares every characteristic of the “seen” (dṛśya), it can never be the Purusha (the true, unconditioned Witness). The seeker must surrender identification even with the intellect and mental sense of agency.
6. Cosmic Negation: The World as Pure Consciousness (Apavāda of Nāma-Rūpa)
Having negated identification with both the gross and subtle bodies, Self-Inquiry resolves the external objective universe (jagat). Shankaracharya employs classical Vedantic analogies (clay-pot, thread-cloth) to show that the universe has no substantive reality other than Pure Consciousness.
Verse 64: Negating Names and Forms
Sanskrit
घटनाम्ना यथा पृथ्वी पटनाम्ना हि तन्तवः । जगन्नाम्ना चिदाभाति ज्ञेयं तत्तदभावतः ॥ ६४॥
Transliteration
Ghaṭanāmnā yathā pṛthvī paṭanāmnā hi tantavaḥ. Jagannāmnā cidābhāti jñeyaṃ tattadabhāvataḥ
Swami Vimuktananda's Translation
Just as earth appears under the name of a jar, or threads under the name of a cloth, so does Consciousness appear under the name of the universe. It (Brahman) should be known by negating those names.
Key Insight
- Name and Form (Nāma-Rūpa) as Mere Labels: A “pot” is simply clay with a name and utility (vācārambhaṇaṃ vikāro nāmadheyam); a “cloth” is nothing but threads. Similarly, the entire manifold universe is nothing but Pure Consciousness (Cit) appearing under names and conceptual labels.
- Knowing Through Negation (Tat-tad-abhāvataḥ): Realization is attained not by destroying the physical world, but by negating the independent reality attributed to its names and forms, discovering that Consciousness alone shines as the underlying reality.
7. The Culmination of Inquiry: Dissolving the Self/Non-Self Division (Sarvātma-Bhāva)
The ultimate dialectical twist of Advaitic Self-Inquiry arrives when even the provisional distinction between Ātman (Self) and Anātman (non-Self) is transcended. Having initially used discrimination to free awareness from embodiment, Shankaracharya reveals that from the standpoint of non-dual Truth, the body and universe are themselves nothing other than Consciousness.
Verse 69: The Body is Pure Consciousness
Sanskrit
यथैव मृन्मयः कुम्भस्तद्वद्देहोऽपि चिन्मयः। आत्मानात्मविभागोऽयं मुधैव क्रियते बुधैः।।
Transliteration
Yathaiva mṛnmayaḥ kumbhastadvaddeho’pi cinmayaḥ. Ātmānātmavibhāgo’yaṃ mudhaiva kriyate budhaiḥ
Swami Vimuktananda's Translation
Just as a jar is all earth, so also is the body all consciousness. The division, therefore, into the Self and non-Self is made by the ignorant to no purpose.
Key Insight
- The Body as Consciousness (Deho’pi Cinmayaḥ): Just as a clay jar has no independent existence apart from clay (mṛnmayaḥ kumbhaḥ), the physical body has no independent existence apart from Pure Consciousness (cinmayaḥ).
- Transcending the Method: The initial division into Self and non-Self (ātmānātma-vibhāgaḥ) was merely an interim thorn used to remove the thorn of ignorance. Once false identification is purged, the seeker discovers that there never was a “non-Self” to begin with—all that appears is the non-dual luminous Self.
8. Abiding in Realization Amidst Prārabdha Karma (Jīvanmukti)
Self-Inquiry is not merely a theoretical conclusion; it transforms how one encounters phenomenal life. A common obstacle for practitioners is reconciling non-dual realization with the continuing stream of bodily experience and worldly events. Shankaracharya explains that while the momentum of past karma (prārabdha) exhausts itself through the body, the inquirer remains established in unbroken awareness, completely free from anxiety or disturbance.
Verse 89: Living Without Distress Amidst Prārabdha
Sanskrit
आत्मानं सततं जानन्कालं नय महामते। प्रारब्धमखिलं भुञ्जन्नोद्वेगं कर्तुमर्हसि।।
Transliteration
Ātmānaṃ satataṃ jānankālaṃ naya mahāmate. Prārabdhamakhilaṃ bhuñjannodvegaṃ kartumarhasi
Swami Vimuktananda's Translation
O enlightened one, pass your time always contemplating on Atman while you are experiencing all the results of Prarabdha; for it ill becomes you to feel distressed.
Key Insight
- Continuous Abidance (Satataṃ Jānan): The culmination of Self-Inquiry is unbroken, continuous resting in one’s true nature as pure Consciousness, rather than slipping back into identification with the ego or circumstances.
- Witnessing Prārabdha without Agitation (Nodvegaṃ Kartum Arhasi): The body-mind may experience pleasant or painful circumstances predetermined by past karma (prārabdha). However, knowing that these pertain solely to the projected body and not to the immortal Self, the enlightened seeker remains tranquil, free from anxiety, craving, or distress (udvega).
9. Cultivating the Thought of Fullness: Overcoming Void and Objectivity (Brahmavṛtti Abhyāsa)
In the advanced stages of contemplative inquiry (nididhyāsana / Vedantic meditation), the mind often falls into subtle pitfalls—identifying with objective forms (bhāva-vṛtti) or sinking into blankness and nihilistic void (śūnya-vṛtti). Shankaracharya formulates the psychological law of contemplation: the mind assumes the likeness of whatever it dwells upon. To attain liberation, the inquirer must actively cultivate the unbroken thought of Brahman (brahmavṛtti), which alone brings fullness (pūrṇatva).
Verse 129: The Law of Mental Identification and Fullness
Sanskrit
भाववृत्त्या हि भावत्वं शून्यवृत्त्या हि शून्यता। ब्रह्मवृत्त्या हि पूर्णत्वं तथा पूर्णत्वमभ्यसेत्।।
Transliteration
Bhāvavṛttyā hi bhāvatvaṃ śūnyavṛttyā hi śūnyatā. Brahmavṛttyā hi pūrṇatvaṃ tathā pūrṇatvamabhyaset
Swami Vimuktananda's Translation
While thinking of an object the mind verily identifies itself with that, and while thinking of a void it really becomes blank, whereas by the thought of Brahman it attains to perfection. So one should constantly think of (Brahman to attain) perfection.
Key Insight
- The Law of Mental Identification (Yad Dhyāyati Tad Bhavati):
- Bhāva-vṛttyā hi bhāvatvam: When consciousness is directed toward external objects or worldly phenomena (bhāva), the mind takes the shape of the finite object and is bound by limitations, desires, and fears.
- Śūnya-vṛttyā hi śūnyatā: When the mind attempts to quiet itself by meditating on nothingness or emptiness (śūnya), it falls into numbness, inert blankness, or unconsciousness (laya), mistaking a mental vacuum for liberation.
- Brahma-vṛttyā hi pūrṇatvam: When the mind is suffused with the modification of Brahman (Brahmākāra Vṛtti)—the constant awareness of all-pervading, non-dual Consciousness—it merges into fullness and perfection (pūrṇatva).
- The Discipline of Fullness (Tathā Pūrṇatvam Abhyaset): Authentic Vicāra does not stop at cold, negative dissolution into a void. It fulfills itself in the positive realization of the Plenum (Pūrṇam). The practitioner is therefore instructed to constantly habituate the mind to the awareness of Brahman until the conceptual modification itself dissolves into unmediated, non-dual Being.
10. Resolving the World: From Effect to Cause, and Beyond (Kārya-Kāraṇa Vilāpana)
In Verse 139, Shankaracharya presents one of the most elegant and decisive contemplative methods in Advaita Vedanta: the method of resolving the effect into the cause (kārya-kāraṇa-anuvṛtti or vilāpana). Rather than fighting perceptions, the seeker traces every manifestation back to its conscious substrate, dismisses the independent reality of the effect, and thereby transcends even the concept of “cause” itself.
Verse 139: Resolving Effect into Cause
Sanskrit
कार्ये हि कारणं पश्येत्पश्चात्कार्यं विसर्जयेत्। कारणत्वं स्वतो नश्येदवशिष्टं भवेन्मुनिः।।
Transliteration
Kārye hi kāraṇaṃ paśyetpaścātkāryaṃ visarjayet. Kāraṇatvaṃ svato naśyedavaśiṣṭaṃ bhavenmuniḥ
Swami Vimuktananda's Translation
One should verily see the cause in the effect, and then dismiss the effect altogether. What then remains, the sage himself becomes.
Key Insight
- The Three-Step Dialectic of Resolution:
- Kārye kāraṇaṃ paśyet (See the cause in the effect): When looking at any phenomenon (the world, body, thoughts), recognize the substrate. Just as one sees clay in the pot or gold in the ornament, see Pure Consciousness in every perceived object.
- Paścāt kāryaṃ visarjayet (Dismiss the effect): Once the cause is recognized as the sole substance, abandon the illusion that the effect has an autonomous existence. A pot is nothing over and above clay; the world is nothing over and above Brahman.
- Kāraṇatvaṃ svato naśyet (The causality itself dissolves): “Cause” is a relative concept that depends entirely on having an “effect.” When the effect is dismissed as non-separate, Brahman is no longer even a “cause”—it is the absolute, non-relational Reality.
- What Remains, the Sage Becomes (Avaśiṣṭaṃ Bhavenmuniḥ): Stripped of the duality of cause and effect, what remains is unconditioned, self-luminous Awareness. The contemplative sage (muni) abides as that very remainder (avaśiṣṭam).
11. The Power of Total Absorption: The Wasp and the Worm (Bhramara-Kīṭa Nyāya)
In Verse 140, Shankaracharya illustrates the transformative power of unbroken meditation (nididhyāsana) through the celebrated traditional analogy of the wasp and the caterpillar (bhramara-kīṭa nyāya). Intense contemplation with unwavering conviction dissolves the seeker’s false individuality and reveals their intrinsic identity as Brahman.
Verse 140: Transformation Through Intense Conviction
Sanskrit
भावितं तीव्रवेगेण वस्तु यन्निश्चयात्मना। पुमांस्तद्धि भवेच्छीघ्रं ज्ञेयं भ्रमरकीटवत्।।
Transliteration
Bhāvitaṃ tīvravegeṇa vastu yanniścayātmanā. Pumāṃstaddhi bhavecchīghraṃ jñeyaṃ bhramarakīṭavat
Swami Vimuktananda's Translation
A person who meditates upon a thing with great assiduity and firm conviction, becomes that very thing. This may be understood from the illustration of the wasp and the worm.
Key Insight
- The Power of Focused Consciousness (Tīvravegeṇa Niścayātmanā):
- Tīvravega denotes the highest velocity and intensity of contemplative absorption, free from doubt, lethargy, or distraction.
- Niścayātmanā denotes firm, unshakeable conviction born of discrimination (viveka) and inquiry (vicāra). Contemplation is not a vague wishing, but an ascertained truth.
- The Metaphor of the Wasp and the Worm (Bhramara-Kīṭa Nyāya):
- In Indian philosophical literature, it is observed that a caterpillar confined by a wasp becomes so intensely absorbed in the thought of the wasp that it undergoes a metamorphosis and takes on the very nature of the wasp.
- Similarly, when the jīva (individual) meditates unceasingly with total conviction upon the infinite Brahman (“Aham Brahmāsmi”), the illusory veil of individuality falls away, and the practitioner swiftly realizes their identity as Brahman (brahmavid brahmaiva bhavati).
12. The Ultimate Climax: Reducing the Visible to Consciousness and Abiding in Felicity
In Verse 142, Shankaracharya delivers the grand culmination of the practice of Self-Inquiry and contemplative meditation. The seeker does not destroy the world physically; rather, through penetrative understanding, the visible (dṛśya) is resolved into the invisible Witness (adṛśya), and the mind abides in uninterrupted felicity, drinking the nectar of Pure Consciousness.
Verse 142: Abiding in Eternal Felicity
Sanskrit
दृश्यं ह्यदृश्यतां नीत्वा ब्रह्माकारेण चिन्तयेत्। विद्वान्नित्यसुखे तिष्ठेद्धिया चिद्रसपूर्णया।।
Transliteration
Dṛśyaṃ hyadṛśyatāṃ nītvā brahmākāreṇa cintayet. Vidvānnityasukhe tiṣṭheddhiyā cidrasapūrṇayā
Swami Vimuktananda's Translation
Having reduced the visible to the invisible, the wise should think of the universe as one with Brahman. Thus alone will he abide in eternal felicity with mind full of consciousness and bliss.
Key Insight
- Reducing the Visible to the Invisible (Dṛśyaṃ Hy-adṛśyatāṃ Nītvā):
- The “visible” (dṛśyam) is the objective world of names, forms, and sensory perceptions.
- “Reducing to the invisible” (adṛśyatām nītvā) means withdrawing belief in the objective independence of phenomena and tracing them back to their non-perceivable, unmanifest source—the witnessing Consciousness (Adṛṣṭaṃ Draṣṭṛ of the Bṛhadāraṇyaka Upaniṣad).
- Contemplating as Brahman (Brahmākāreṇa Cintayet):
- Rather than seeing multiplicity, the contemplative sees all appearances as modifications of Brahman alone. Perceptions no longer distract; they are recognized as waves on the ocean of Awareness.
- Abiding in Imperishable Felicity (Nityasukhe Tiṣṭhet):
- Spiritual joy in Advaita is not a transient emotional high produced by external contact; it is Nityasukha—the innate, unconditioned peace of the Self. The enlightened sage remains stably established (tiṣṭhet) in this peace.
- The Mind Saturated with the Essence of Consciousness (Dhiyā Cidrasa-Pūrṇayā):
- Far from being reduced to a stupor or void, the intellect (dhī) is saturated to overflowing with the sweet essence and nectar of Consciousness (cidrasa-pūrṇā), radiating serene, self-existent bliss.
Summary of the Inquiry Process in Aparokṣānubhūti
┌─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐
│ 1. VIVEKA (Verse 5) │
│ Distinguishing the eternal Seer (Atman) from the │
│ perishable Seen (Dṛśya). │
└──────────────────────────────┬──────────────────────────────┘
│
▼
┌─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐
│ 2. VICĀRA / JIJÑĀSĀ (Verse 12) │
│ Launching the fundamental enquiry: "Who am I? What is │
│ the true cause of this existence?" │
└──────────────────────────────┬──────────────────────────────┘
│
▼
┌─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐
│ 3. GROSS BODY NEGATION (Verse 13) │
│ Negating identification with physical elements │
│ (body) and perceptual instruments (senses). │
└──────────────────────────────┬──────────────────────────────┘
│
▼
┌─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐
│ 4. ADHYĀSA-KHAṆḌANA (Verse 17) │
│ Piercing the irrational superimposition of the composite │
│ body onto the undivided, partless Awareness. │
└──────────────────────────────┬──────────────────────────────┘
│
▼
┌─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐
│ 5. SUBTLE BODY NEGATION (Verse 39) │
│ Transcending identification with the mental/psychic │
│ apparatus (mind, ego, prāṇas) as an object of perception.│
└──────────────────────────────┬──────────────────────────────┘
│
▼
┌─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐
│ 6. COSMIC NEGATION / APAVĀDA (Verse 64) │
│ Negating the reality of names and forms (nāma-rūpa); │
│ realizing the universe as Pure Consciousness alone. │
└──────────────────────────────┬──────────────────────────────┘
│
▼
┌─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐
│ 7. NON-DUAL CULMINATION (Verse 69) │
│ Dissolving the provisional division of Self/non-Self; │
│ realizing the body and all appearance as Cinmaya. │
└──────────────────────────────┬──────────────────────────────┘
│
▼
┌─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐
│ 8. STEADFAST ABIDANCE / JĪVANMUKTI (Verse 89) │
│ Living in unbroken Self-knowledge without agitation │
│ while experiencing the natural fruits of Prārabdha. │
└──────────────────────────────┬──────────────────────────────┘
│
▼
┌─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐
│ 9. BRAHMA-VṚTTI ABHYĀSA (Verse 129) │
│ Transcending both worldly objects and meditative void; │
│ cultivating the thought of Brahman to realize Fullness. │
└──────────────────────────────┬──────────────────────────────┘
│
▼
┌─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐
│ 10. KĀRYA-KĀRAṆA VILĀPANA (Verse 139) │
│ Seeing cause in effect, then discarding the effect; │
│ causality itself drops away; the sage is what remains. │
└──────────────────────────────┬──────────────────────────────┘
│
▼
┌─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐
│ 11. BHRAMARA-KĪṬA NYĀYA (Verse 140) │
│ Intense absorption with firm conviction dissolves ego; │
│ the seeker swiftly awakens as Brahman itself. │
└──────────────────────────────┬──────────────────────────────┘
│
▼
┌─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐
│ 12. DṚŚYA-VILĀPANA & NITYA-SUKHA (Verse 142) │
│ Resolving the visible into the invisible Witness; │
│ abiding in eternal felicity, mind filled with Cidrasa. │
└─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┘
Related Notes:
- Aparokshanubhuti
- Aparokshanubhuti Verse 5
- Aparokshanubhuti Verse 12
- Aparokshanubhuti Verse 13
- Aparokshanubhuti Verse 17
- Aparokshanubhuti Verse 39
- Aparokshanubhuti Verse 64
- Aparokshanubhuti Verse 69
- Aparokshanubhuti Verse 89
- Aparokshanubhuti Verse 129
- Aparokshanubhuti Verse 139
- Aparokshanubhuti Verse 140
- Aparokshanubhuti Verse 142
- Upadesha Sara

Muni's Play