Self-Related Processes: Self-as-Object to Self-as-Subject
Overview
In “From Self-Esteem to Selflessness: An Evidence (Gap) Map of Self-Related Processes as Mechanisms of Mindfulness-Based Interventions” (Britton et al., 2021, Frontiers in Psychology), the authors establish a continuum of self-related psychological processes spanning from the Self-as-Object (conceptual, narrative self) to the Self-as-Subject (embodied, perspectival self).
This taxonomy provides an empirical, psychological parallel to classical Self-Inquiry (Ātma-Vicāra), illuminating how contemplative practices systematically deconstruct conceptual identity, investigate embodied agency, and foster self-transcendence.
1. Conceptual Model: The Continuum of Selfhood
The model organizes self-related processes along a vertical continuum from Self-as-Object (top) to Self-as-Subject (bottom), structured as two overlapping spheres connected by self-regulation:
| Continuum Position | Domain | Mode | Core Function | Self-Related Processes (from Model) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Self-as-Object (Upper Pole) | Narrative Self | Conceptual | Self-Evaluation | • Narrative self • Self-evaluation • Self-criticism • Self-compassion • Rumination • Self-esteem |
| Intersection (Overlap) | Self-Regulation | Regulatory Interface | Mediating narrative appraisal and somatic experience | • Self-efficacy • Decentering |
| Self-as-Subject (Lower Pole) | Perspectival Self | Embodied | First-person experiential vantage point | • Perspectival self • Sense of agency • Sense of ownership • Interoception • Sense of boundaries |
2. Table of Self-Related Processes, Assays & Measures
| Self-Related Process | Assay / Instrument | Description | Sample Items |
|---|---|---|---|
| Decentering | Experiences Questionnaire (EQ) | Two subscales: Rumination (6 items) and Decentering/Wider Perspectives (14 items), capturing disidentification, non-reactivity, and dereification (20 items total). | (Frequency) • Decentering: “I can slow my thinking at times of stress.” • Rumination: “I analyze why things turn out the way they do.” |
| Toronto Mindfulness Scale (TMS) | Two subscales: Curiosity (6 items) and Decentering (7 items), capturing disidentification, dereification, acceptance, and openness (13 items total). | (Agreement) • Decentering: “I experienced myself as separate from my changing thoughts and feelings.” • Curiosity: “I was curious to see what my mind was up to from moment to moment.” | |
| Dysfunctional Attitudes | Dysfunctional Attitudes Scale (DAS) | Single scale measuring depressogenic schemata, such as black-and-white thinking and negatively biased forms of self-appraisal (40 items). | (Agreement) • “My life is wasted unless I am a success.” • “If I do well, it is probably due to chance, if I do badly it is probably my own fault.” |
| Interoceptive Accuracy | 13 Objective Behavioral Tasks | Objective behavioral measurements including heartbeat counting, heartbeat detection, joint position, and blood glucose accuracy. | • Heartbeat counting: Estimate number of heartbeats. • Heartbeat detection: Detect heartbeat and report when it occurred relative to an external stimulus. |
| Interoceptive Attention | Multidimensional Assessment of Interoceptive Awareness-2 (MAIA-2) | Eight subscales assessing dimensions of interoceptive attention: Attention regulation (7), Body listening (3), Emotional awareness (5), Noticing (4), Not-distracting (6), Not-worrying (5), Self-regulation (4), Trusting (3); 37 items total. | (Frequency) • Attention regulation: “I can return awareness to my body if I am distracted.” • Body listening: “When I am upset, I take time to explore how my body feels.” |
| Negative Automatic Thoughts | Automatic Thoughts Questionnaire (ATQ) | Single scale measuring frequency of negative self-statements (30 items). | (Frequency of thought) • “I’m no good.” • “My life is a mess.” |
| Rumination | Ruminative Response Scale (RRS) | Single scale measuring frequency of thoughts or actions in response to feeling depressed (22 items). | (Frequency of thought) • “Think about how alone you feel.” • “Think ‘Why can’t I get going?‘” |
| Rumination Reflection Questionnaire (RRQ) | Two subscales: Rumination (12 items) and Reflection (12 items); 24 items total. | (Agreement) • Rumination: “I often find myself re-evaluating something I’ve done.” • Reflection: “I love exploring my ‘inner’ self.” | |
| Self-Compassion | Self-Compassion Scale (SCS) | Six subscales: Self-kindness (5), Self-judgment (5), Isolation (4), Common humanity (4), Mindfulness (4), Over-identification (4), plus total composite score (26 items total). | (Frequency) • “I try to be loving toward myself when I’m feeling emotional pain.” • “I try to see my failings as part of the human condition.” |
| Self-Efficacy | Generalized Self-Efficacy Scale (GSES) | Single scale measuring self-beliefs related to coping with life demands (10 items). | (Accuracy) • “I can solve most problems if I invest the necessary effort.” • “If I am in trouble, I can usually think of a solution.” |
| Self-Efficacy Scale (SES) | Two subscales: General self-efficacy (17 items) and Social self-efficacy (6 items); 23 items total. | (Agreement) • General: “I avoid facing difficulties.” (reverse scored) • Social: “I do not handle myself well in social gatherings.” | |
| Self-Esteem | Rosenberg Self-Esteem Scale (RSES) | Single scale measuring global self-competence and worthiness (10 items). | (Agreement) • “At times I think I am no good at all.” (reverse scored) • “I take a positive attitude toward myself.” |
| Self-Transcendence | Non-dual Awareness Dimensional Assessment (NADA) | State and Trait versions. Two subscales: Bliss (4 items, positive affect) and Self-transcendence (9 items, dissolution of self-world boundaries and unity); 13 items total. | (Frequency) • Self-transcendence: “I have had an experience in which the boundaries of my self dissolved.” • Bliss: “I have experienced an all-embracing love.” |
| The Perceived Body Boundaries Scale (PBBS) | Single item assessing the sense of being more or less separated from the world using visual gradations of body boundary transparency. | Evaluates gradations of body boundary salience to measure the boundaries of the self relative to the physical body and environment. | |
| Spatial Frame of Reference Continuum (SFoRC) | Single item where individuals rate how far their sense of self expands into the world using concentric circles radiating outward. | Identifies how far the felt sense of self extends beyond the organism into external space. |
3. Connections to Classical Self-Inquiry (Ātma-Vicāra)
In traditional Advaita and Ramaṇa Maharṣi’s self-inquiry:
- Deconstruction of the Narrative Self (Ahaṃkāra):
- Thoughts, self-esteem, self-criticism, and rumination belong to the conceptual realm of mental modifications (vṛttis). They are objects known by awareness (dṛśya), never the knowing subject (dṛk).
- Investigation of the Embodied Perspective (Deha-Ātma-Buddhi):
- The sense of agency (“I am the doer”, kartṛtva) and somatic ownership (“I am the body”) are located in the embodied perspectival center. Self-inquiry investigates: “To whom does this sense of ownership belong?”
- Decentering into Pure Witness & Self-Transcendence:
- Decentering (dereification) transitions the practitioner from being entangled in the mental object to resting as the unchanging space of awareness.
- Full self-transcendence corresponds to the dissolution of illusory subject-object duality (grāhya-grāhaka), revealing non-dual awareness (NADA / advaita).
Sources & Context
- Source Paper: Britton, W. B., Desbordes, G., Acabchuk, R., Peters, S., Lindahl, J. R., Canby, N. K., … & Proulx, J. (2021). From Self-Esteem to Selflessness: An Evidence (Gap) Map of Self-Related Processes as Mechanisms of Mindfulness-Based Interventions. Frontiers in Psychology, 12, 730972. DOI: 10.3389/fpsyg.2021.730972.
See also:

Muni's Play