Self-Related Processes: Self-as-Object to Self-as-Subject

Overview

In “From Self-Esteem to Selflessness: An Evidence (Gap) Map of Self-Related Processes as Mechanisms of Mindfulness-Based Interventions” (Britton et al., 2021, Frontiers in Psychology), the authors establish a continuum of self-related psychological processes spanning from the Self-as-Object (conceptual, narrative self) to the Self-as-Subject (embodied, perspectival self).

This taxonomy provides an empirical, psychological parallel to classical Self-Inquiry (Ātma-Vicāra), illuminating how contemplative practices systematically deconstruct conceptual identity, investigate embodied agency, and foster self-transcendence.


1. Conceptual Model: The Continuum of Selfhood

The model organizes self-related processes along a vertical continuum from Self-as-Object (top) to Self-as-Subject (bottom), structured as two overlapping spheres connected by self-regulation:

Continuum PositionDomainModeCore FunctionSelf-Related Processes (from Model)
Self-as-Object (Upper Pole)Narrative SelfConceptualSelf-Evaluation• Narrative self
• Self-evaluation
• Self-criticism
• Self-compassion
• Rumination
• Self-esteem
Intersection (Overlap)Self-RegulationRegulatory InterfaceMediating narrative appraisal and somatic experience• Self-efficacy
• Decentering
Self-as-Subject (Lower Pole)Perspectival SelfEmbodiedFirst-person experiential vantage point• Perspectival self
• Sense of agency
• Sense of ownership
• Interoception
• Sense of boundaries

Self-Related ProcessAssay / InstrumentDescriptionSample Items
DecenteringExperiences Questionnaire (EQ)Two subscales: Rumination (6 items) and Decentering/Wider Perspectives (14 items), capturing disidentification, non-reactivity, and dereification (20 items total).(Frequency)
• Decentering: “I can slow my thinking at times of stress.”
• Rumination: “I analyze why things turn out the way they do.”
Toronto Mindfulness Scale (TMS)Two subscales: Curiosity (6 items) and Decentering (7 items), capturing disidentification, dereification, acceptance, and openness (13 items total).(Agreement)
• Decentering: “I experienced myself as separate from my changing thoughts and feelings.”
• Curiosity: “I was curious to see what my mind was up to from moment to moment.”
Dysfunctional AttitudesDysfunctional Attitudes Scale (DAS)Single scale measuring depressogenic schemata, such as black-and-white thinking and negatively biased forms of self-appraisal (40 items).(Agreement)
• “My life is wasted unless I am a success.”
• “If I do well, it is probably due to chance, if I do badly it is probably my own fault.”
Interoceptive Accuracy13 Objective Behavioral TasksObjective behavioral measurements including heartbeat counting, heartbeat detection, joint position, and blood glucose accuracy.• Heartbeat counting: Estimate number of heartbeats.
• Heartbeat detection: Detect heartbeat and report when it occurred relative to an external stimulus.
Interoceptive AttentionMultidimensional Assessment of Interoceptive Awareness-2 (MAIA-2)Eight subscales assessing dimensions of interoceptive attention: Attention regulation (7), Body listening (3), Emotional awareness (5), Noticing (4), Not-distracting (6), Not-worrying (5), Self-regulation (4), Trusting (3); 37 items total.(Frequency)
• Attention regulation: “I can return awareness to my body if I am distracted.”
• Body listening: “When I am upset, I take time to explore how my body feels.”
Negative Automatic ThoughtsAutomatic Thoughts Questionnaire (ATQ)Single scale measuring frequency of negative self-statements (30 items).(Frequency of thought)
• “I’m no good.”
• “My life is a mess.”
RuminationRuminative Response Scale (RRS)Single scale measuring frequency of thoughts or actions in response to feeling depressed (22 items).(Frequency of thought)
• “Think about how alone you feel.”
• “Think ‘Why can’t I get going?‘”
Rumination Reflection Questionnaire (RRQ)Two subscales: Rumination (12 items) and Reflection (12 items); 24 items total.(Agreement)
• Rumination: “I often find myself re-evaluating something I’ve done.”
• Reflection: “I love exploring my ‘inner’ self.”
Self-CompassionSelf-Compassion Scale (SCS)Six subscales: Self-kindness (5), Self-judgment (5), Isolation (4), Common humanity (4), Mindfulness (4), Over-identification (4), plus total composite score (26 items total).(Frequency)
• “I try to be loving toward myself when I’m feeling emotional pain.”
• “I try to see my failings as part of the human condition.”
Self-EfficacyGeneralized Self-Efficacy Scale (GSES)Single scale measuring self-beliefs related to coping with life demands (10 items).(Accuracy)
• “I can solve most problems if I invest the necessary effort.”
• “If I am in trouble, I can usually think of a solution.”
Self-Efficacy Scale (SES)Two subscales: General self-efficacy (17 items) and Social self-efficacy (6 items); 23 items total.(Agreement)
• General: “I avoid facing difficulties.” (reverse scored)
• Social: “I do not handle myself well in social gatherings.”
Self-EsteemRosenberg Self-Esteem Scale (RSES)Single scale measuring global self-competence and worthiness (10 items).(Agreement)
• “At times I think I am no good at all.” (reverse scored)
• “I take a positive attitude toward myself.”
Self-TranscendenceNon-dual Awareness Dimensional Assessment (NADA)State and Trait versions. Two subscales: Bliss (4 items, positive affect) and Self-transcendence (9 items, dissolution of self-world boundaries and unity); 13 items total.(Frequency)
• Self-transcendence: “I have had an experience in which the boundaries of my self dissolved.”
• Bliss: “I have experienced an all-embracing love.”
The Perceived Body Boundaries Scale (PBBS)Single item assessing the sense of being more or less separated from the world using visual gradations of body boundary transparency.Evaluates gradations of body boundary salience to measure the boundaries of the self relative to the physical body and environment.
Spatial Frame of Reference Continuum (SFoRC)Single item where individuals rate how far their sense of self expands into the world using concentric circles radiating outward.Identifies how far the felt sense of self extends beyond the organism into external space.

3. Connections to Classical Self-Inquiry (Ātma-Vicāra)

In traditional Advaita and Ramaṇa Maharṣi’s self-inquiry:

  1. Deconstruction of the Narrative Self (Ahaṃkāra):
    • Thoughts, self-esteem, self-criticism, and rumination belong to the conceptual realm of mental modifications (vṛttis). They are objects known by awareness (dṛśya), never the knowing subject (dṛk).
  2. Investigation of the Embodied Perspective (Deha-Ātma-Buddhi):
    • The sense of agency (“I am the doer”, kartṛtva) and somatic ownership (“I am the body”) are located in the embodied perspectival center. Self-inquiry investigates: “To whom does this sense of ownership belong?”
  3. Decentering into Pure Witness & Self-Transcendence:
    • Decentering (dereification) transitions the practitioner from being entangled in the mental object to resting as the unchanging space of awareness.
    • Full self-transcendence corresponds to the dissolution of illusory subject-object duality (grāhya-grāhaka), revealing non-dual awareness (NADA / advaita).

Sources & Context

  • Source Paper: Britton, W. B., Desbordes, G., Acabchuk, R., Peters, S., Lindahl, J. R., Canby, N. K., … & Proulx, J. (2021). From Self-Esteem to Selflessness: An Evidence (Gap) Map of Self-Related Processes as Mechanisms of Mindfulness-Based Interventions. Frontiers in Psychology, 12, 730972. DOI: 10.3389/fpsyg.2021.730972.

See also: